| FOCUS: If You Need to Understand the Stakes of This Election, Look to Today's Supreme Court Case |
| Written by <a href="index.php?option=com_comprofiler&task=userProfile&user=11104"><span class="small">Charles Pierce, Esquire</span></a> |
| Thursday, 03 March 2016 11:37 |
|
Pierce writes: "Everyone needs to pay attention right now. The Supreme Court heard its most important case since the death of Antonin Scalia, in what most people believe is a 4-4 tie on issues like abortion rights."
If You Need to Understand the Stakes of This Election, Look to Today's Supreme Court Case03 March 16
Everyone needs to pay attention right now.
The Texas law—HB1—is the same legislation that led to Wendy Davis' vain but herculean filibuster in the Texas legislature. It placed certain restrictions on abortion providers that were designed to force most of them to close, especially those serving poor women and women in rural parts of the state. In Whole Woman's Health, the Supreme Court will consider two provisions of HB 2: the requirement that abortions be performed only in ambulatory surgical centers, hospital-like facilities usually used to perform outpatient surgery, and the mandate that doctors performing abortions have admitting privileges at a nearby hospital. Medical groups, including the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, have repeatedly noted that these restrictions are not necessary to provide safe abortion care, while anti-abortion groups contend that the restrictions are crucial to protect women's health. At issue is the concept of "undue burden," which was central to the 1992 Casey decision in which the Court first took the trimmers to Roe v. Wade. Thus did state legislators redefine "undue burden" so as to eliminate any roadblock they could throw up short of having the women walk a tightrope over a lake of fire. Were Scalia still alive, we probably could count on this redefinition being further expanded. Now, though, it seems from the oral arguments that the best the defenders of the law can hope for is that the case gets kicked back down the food chain, not only because it would seem to be Kennedy's preference that the whole thing go away for a while, but also because Justices Ruth Bader Ginsberg and Elena Kagan were not buying an ounce of Texas' argument that they only ever had the interests of the ladies at heart. First, RBG caught Texas Solicitor General Scott Keller (and the law he was defending) making no distinction between medical abortions, which involve pills, and surgical abortions, and she was curious as to why a clinic specializing in the former would need to meet the standards of a surgical center.
Then Kagan went to town, exposing even further the mendacity of the Texas legislature in masking its intention with mock concern for a woman's health. Keller disappeared into a cloud of squid ink concerning the convicted murderer Kermit Gosnell from Philadelphia, which is a fine conjuring spell if you're sparring with Megyn or Greta or Sean, but which turned out to be sadly inadequate outside of the studios of the Fox News Channel.
As I said, my intuition is that the Court's going to punt on this one, but, at the very least, once again, the stakes of the upcoming presidential election are clear in this case, where there is no ideological majority any more and, therefore, no longer a constituency for ridiculous bad-faith arguments like the ones made in defense of this Texas law, which was passed to eliminate abortions. Period. Maybe the Court no longer is required to believe nonsense just because it has five votes. |




oday, the Supreme Court heard its most important case since the death of Antonin Scalia, in what most people believe is a 4-4 tie on issues like abortion rights.