RSN June Fundraising
FB Share
Email This Page
add comment
Print

Cole writes: "It is breathtaking impudence that Republicans should try to campaign on whether we are better off than we were in the last six months of the Bush administration. I can't believe we are even arguing about this. Seriously? The country had fallen off a cliff in the last years of Bush, or rather had been pushed off one by GOP policies."

Is the country better off than it was when George W. Bush passed off the presidency to Barack Obama? (photo: Getty Images)
Is the country better off than it was when George W. Bush passed off the presidency to Barack Obama? (photo: Getty Images)


Top Ten Ways We Are Better Off Than in January 2009

By Juan Cole, Informed Comment

06 September 12

 

t is breathtaking impudence that Republicans should try to campaign on whether we are better off than were were in the last six months of the Bush administration. I can't believe we are even arguing about this. Seriously? The country had fallen off a cliff in the last years of Bush, or rather had been pushed off one by GOP policies.

  1. In January 2009 we lost 600,000 jobs. In 2008 over-all, we lost 2.6 million jobs, the most in 6 decades! We're now adding over 100,000 jobs a month.
  2. Home mortgage foreclosures had spiked 80% in 2008!
  3. We were at war in Iraq in January, 2009, with 314 American troops killed in 2008 in what had become a fruitless quagmire launched on false pretexts in contravention of international law. The US military is out of Iraq, despite the lobbying of the Republican Party and elements in the Pentagon to try to stay there in the teeth of Iraqi opposition.
  4. Usama Bin Laden, despite having killed over 3000 Americans on US soil, was still at large and actively plotting further attacks in the US. The Bush administration had closed down the CIA Bin Laden desk.
  5. In January 2009, US new auto sales fell 37%, the most in decades, and for the first time China sold more cars than America. The major automobile companies were heading for bankruptcy. Obama turned all that around, in the teeth of opposition from people like Mitt Romney.
  6. Non-hydro renewable energy only supplied 3% of American electricity; now it is nearly 6%, in large part because of Obama incentives. Green energy reduces carbon dioxide emissions and so helps decrease the worst effects of global warming, and its increases US energy inedependence.
  7. Some 30 million Americans lacked basic health care insurance, who will now be covered, including large numbers of children.
  8. Our country had betrayed its most basic values by torturing prisoners. Obama called a halt to water-boarding.
  9. George W. Bush was president.
  10. Dick Cheney was vice president!
 

Comments   

We are concerned about a recent drift towards vitriol in the RSN Reader comments section. There is a fine line between moderation and censorship. No one likes a harsh or confrontational forum atmosphere. At the same time everyone wants to be able to express themselves freely. We'll start by encouraging good judgment. If that doesn't work we'll have to ramp up the moderation.

General guidelines: Avoid personal attacks on other forum members; Avoid remarks that are ethnically derogatory; Do not advocate violence, or any illegal activity.

Remember that making the world better begins with responsible action.

- The RSN Team

 
+53 # walthe310 2012-09-06 11:21
The answer is h*** yes. We are out of Iraq and we are drawing down our troops in Afghanistan. Bin Laden is dead and al-Qaeda is on the run. The economy is improving slowly from the Great Recession. Too many are still unemployed and the housing bubble is not over. Who shall we thank for the state of the economy? Republicans in Congress who have attempted to block every one of President Obama's initiatives.

We can rightly blame GW Bush and Alan Greenspan for not preventing the Great Recession and the housing bubble. After 3-4 years, Barack has rightly taken ownership of the economy. He acted to prevent it from becoming the Great Depression 2. It seems that most people don't realize how bad the economic situation was and capable of becoming. Too many believe the GOP mantra that it is Obama's fault, while the GOP are doing everything in their power to prolong the slow recovery until after the election. It is the same strategy used by the CIA under Nixon's direction to overthrow the Allende government in Chile in 1971. Now the people of the US are learning what it is like to be on the wrong end of economic warfare.
 
 
+41 # Barbara K 2012-09-06 11:27
Yes, I believe we are much better off. We are on the mend now, instead of spiraling off a cliff. Jobs are being added instead of taken away. We have a Raise in the Minimum Wage. Hoping that the Raise goes even higher so people can actually afford to live on their wages without needing food stamps and can enjoy a meal out now and then. We are so much better off that some will never know it because they are so wealthy that they were not hurt under Bush.

OBAMA/BIDEN 2012 !!
 
 
-120 # chirostv 2012-09-06 11:35
And Guantanemo is closed. Wait on that one. Unemployment never got past 8%. Wait on that one. The deficit is lower by 50%. wait on that one. All the troops are home. wait on that one. The auto industry has come raoring back. wait on that one. Obama is still President and his stupid friend Biden are still President and Vice-President. Wait on those until November and those will be taken care of!
 
 
+5 # humanmancalvin 2012-09-06 12:26
"Wait on those until November and those will be taken care of!"

That my friend is called wishful thinking. Too many of you low information types will find it hard to pull the Romney lever while holding your collective noses shut.
 
 
+22 # Ray Kondrasuk 2012-09-06 12:45
Obama has withdrawn all troops from Iraq, supporting and complying with the SOFA (Status of Forces Agreement) that Bush signed in his last months in office.

So give a nod to both.

http://mediamatters.org/research/2010/06/27/memo-to-media-bush-set-a-timetable-for-withdraw/166835
 
 
+14 # carpepax 2012-09-06 13:24
Yep, you're right. He didn't cure cancer...so I'm voting for cancer this November.
 
 
+6 # lexy677 2012-09-06 17:07
I am sorry carpepax, the people here seem to be immune to irony. It appears Dumber and dumber people are visiting and commenting on this site.
 
 
0 # bingers 2012-09-10 04:10
Quoting lexy677:
I am sorry carpepax, the people here seem to be immune to irony. It appears Dumber and dumber people are visiting and commenting on this site.


That's what happens when conservatives get wind of a site with rational people and of course, while 95% of liberals are more rational and intelligent than conservatives and have more open minds as well, not all are brain wizards.
 
 
+48 # Art947 2012-09-06 13:29
When you are a "jerk' you're a jerk all the way!

Obama signed an Executive Order shortly after he took office -- your friends, the Republicans in Congress (with help from "blue dog" democrats) passed legislation that REFUSED to fund the transfer of detainees or the closing of the detention center.

It takes a long time after an economy begins to mend for unemployment to go down, EVEN THOUGH employment is rising! More people re-join the labor force in a rising economy and keep the percentages stagnant for awhile. This is an elementary arithmetic issue.

The troops have returned from Iraq and a timetable for their departure from Afghanistan is in place. How long do your Republican "friends" want to stay in these countries? FOREVER!

GM is now once again the largest car manufacturer in the world. Didn't Romney say we should just let the companies go bankrupt?
 
 
+30 # ericlipps 2012-09-06 14:00
Don't count on it. People know what Romney is, and what Ryan is, and know that the last thing we need is a remake of Bush-Cheney (or was it Cheney-Bush?).
 
 
+10 # ALinSTL 2012-09-06 18:35
AND MITT HAS THE BURDEN OF HAVING TO FOLLOW ORDERS FROM THE GUYS AT THE TOP OF THE MORMON CHURCH SINCE HE IS A BISHOP UNDER THEIR RULE...
 
 
+8 # Mrcead 2012-09-06 14:09
It's going to take a lot more than that to get RSN readers to forget about the traumatic period of American history known as the W-8. So wind your neck back in mate.
 
 
+4 # Old Man 2012-09-06 15:32
Quoting Mrcead:
It's going to take a lot more than that to get RSN readers to forget about the traumatic period of American history known as the W-8. So wind your neck back in mate.

It must be happy hour some place.
 
 
+6 # James Smith 2012-09-07 07:41
Yes, Obama has not done all we hoped. Most notably reversed the policies of George W, Bush that got us into this mess. The "Patriot" Act not only was not repealed, it was extended.

We are still at war in Afghanistan and an undeclared war in Pakistan.

The "Bail-out" (nee robbery) of the fiscally greedy and irresponsible banks was planned in the BUsh administration and BHO permitted it to continue.

The "failures" of Obama have been in not repudiating Bush and all of his errors and the Republicans who were determined to block anything he wanted, even if it had a Republican root, such as the health care plan, Romney promoted for Massachusetts.

To be a Republican is to be a member of GOP (Gear Obstructionist Party).
 
 
+1 # bingers 2012-09-10 04:08
Quoting chirostv:
And Guantanemo is closed. Wait on that one. Unemployment never got past 8%. Wait on that one. The deficit is lower by 50%. wait on that one. All the troops are home. wait on that one. The auto industry has come raoring back. wait on that one. Obama is still President and his stupid friend Biden are still President and Vice-President. Wait on those until November and those will be taken care of!


Guantanamo is not closed because the Republicans would not allow spending money to do it. Unemployment is down, but not nearly as much as it would be if the Republicans hadn't filibustered all 44 bills from the Pelosi congress and refuse to take up the current jobs bill, the auto industry HAS come roaring back, the troops are mostly all home from Iraq, and thank God Obama and the most expert foreign affairs person in Government, Joe Biden are still in office. Nearly every problem we have has been caused by the stupidity of conservative actions with the help of Clinton and the blue dogs. The last rational conservative in government, Barry Goldwater is dead and every single remaining one is bat crap crazy.
 
 
-42 # Judge Sturdy 2012-09-06 12:38
4. Osama Bin Laden did not murder 3000 people. The actual architects of that crime are currently being held at Guantanamo. Bin Ladin was holed up and hiding in Pakistan, a defeated man, and no longer posed a threat to anyone. Am I the only one who is sick to death of supposed left-liberals celebrating the murder of an unarmed individual whose capture, interrogation and trial would have been a real victory for humanity?
 
 
+33 # Art947 2012-09-06 13:32
We are not celebrating the death of anyone! We are just asking you to admit that it took a committed leader, Barack Obama, to bring an end to the Osama affair -- after George Bush gave up on the project that he initiated! BTW, I am sure that you, and your Republican cronies, would NEVER let us forget it if GWB had been the leader when Osama bin Laden was removed.
 
 
+1 # bingers 2012-09-10 04:16
There's also the fact that the Army had bin Laden directly in their sights, literally, and that Bush made them stand down. And the fact that the bin Laden family had rescued Dumbya from bankruptcy on 2 occasions. See a connection there? Just another case of Republican treason so common in the Bush era.
 
 
+21 # Ray Kondrasuk 2012-09-06 14:01
When I last checked, 'bout two years ago, American deaths that horrific day in New York totaled 2,476. Add in foreign nationals working in the Twin Towers and the number approaches 2,800.

Since then, many rescuers have suffered premature deaths because of lung disease caused by exposure to the toxic rubble. (See Michael Moore's "Sicko"), so maybe 3,000 is not an exaggeration.
 
 
+33 # Reyn 2012-09-06 14:13
Then no leader was ever responsible for the actions of his soldiers. Hitler was not responsible for millions of genocidal murders, neither was Pol Pot, neither was Stalin.

In an attempt to score political points for your side, with a single stroke of the pen you eliminate the worst crimes in history, or transfer them to hapless followers as being the ones solely responsible.

Pathetic.

Michael Canty was my friend. I had known him from 12. We played D and D together for years. I went to watch his track meets occasionally. As an adult he gave richly to charity and helped others whenever he could. Osama bin Laden killed him, as surely as if he'd held the aircraft controls.

Yes "judge" - I think his death was richly deserved and while I do not celebrate it, I admit it, proudly - I'm human and I am glad that the murderer, yes murderer of my nearly lifelong friend, is dead.
 
 
+26 # Old Man 2012-09-06 15:39
Very nicely said Ryan and I'm very sorry for your loss.
 
 
-2 # jcdav 2012-09-08 04:13
As I recall OBL CLAIMED responsibility for 911 very soon after the tragic event. I must say I really am disappointed that he was not captured and given a trial. Part of me says it would have been a propaganda fest on his part and that was avoided by killing him. Still, calling his killing "justice" is a stretch.
 
 
+1 # bingers 2012-09-10 04:13
Are you so dumb that you don't realize the repercussions of either capturing him alive or not disposing of his body would have brought?
 
 
+32 # Reductio Ad Absurdum 2012-09-06 13:26
The list is actually a lot longer, but the most significant one the author missed is that we are no longer on the brink of economic catastrophe. It was not as if the Republicans drove the bus into the right-hand ditch, the bus was teetering on the precipice of disaster, and the tsunami of consequences roaring in on the aftermath had just begun and it hasn't really stopped since. And not ONE — NOT ONE! — attempt was made by the Republicans to help the situation; they were bound and determined to make it worse by obstructing Obama at every step, promulgating the utterly false narrative that we were in trouble because of the debt (which THEY had run up with Bush tax cuts, off-book wars and Medicare D giveaways to Big Pharma), and promoting the idiotic strategy of imposing austerity and job SLASHING during a time of high unemployment — completely contrary to a century of economic evidence.
 
 
+29 # Ray Kondrasuk 2012-09-06 14:09
Stephen Colbert had to apologize about his initial take on that large digital counting display... in the trillions.... at the Republican convention.

Colbert said he thought it was merely totaling Romney's wealth...

And I think in his Classic-Clinton speech last night, William Jefferson said the the Republicans could righteously point up at the numbers roaring by on the counter and proudly declare,
"We made that!"
 
 
+22 # ALinSTL 2012-09-06 18:40
DON'T FORGET BONEHER FIGHTING TO KEEP THE BUSH TAX CUTS SO JOB CREATORS COULD CREATE JOBS...HAS ANYBODY ASKED HIM,"WHERE ARE ALL THOSE JOBS YOU SAID WERE COMING, JACK?????"
 
 
-28 # dfitz515@gmail.com 2012-09-06 13:49
Well, you all may think we are better off than we were 4 years ago, but I for one am not. I'm looking at foreclosure after 4 years of faltering in this economic disaster that started way before Republican administrations were in office,(actuall y it was in Jimmy Carter's administration) . Look it up. Fannie May, Freddie Mac. My IRA which I had to rely on is drying up rapidly. No health care insurance because of no job that I was laid off of in 2009 after LITERALLY pouring out my blood,sweat and tears over for 30 years! It is the regulatory agencies established in this country that need to take hold and control problems such as this from never happening again. Overspending is what further complicates the issue before us. And, already Obama will be approving a 1.5 trillion over-budget expenditure for this country if he is re-elected.
 
 
+29 # Art947 2012-09-06 15:34
As an American who cares about his fellow residents of this country (and others on the planet), I am truly sorry that dfitz555 is not better off today than he was in the past, however, he provides no information as to why he lost his job, home, etc. Please note, however, that the Republicans have indicated that the wealthy are the "job creators." Since 2009, these creators have become even more wealthy. Why haven't they provided a job for dfitz?
 
 
+7 # kalpal 2012-09-07 06:00
because the euphemism is just a euphemism and will never be more than a euphemism. Much like the GOP used to be the law and order party except they were the first to turn to illegal behavior when this nation was attacked.
 
 
+16 # Old Man 2012-09-06 16:02
Don't get me wrong dfitz but you can't blame Carter or Obama for your poor planning of your personal finances. If you cashed in your 30 yrs. IRA that was your first mistake, if you had a house that should have been the first hot potato you should have dropped and walked away from.
People have been living in a "Bubble" for 30 yrs. You can thank the Republicans for your "Bubble" bursting.
 
 
-16 # Madamegar 2012-09-07 00:16
and yet,all Obama did was dig it in deeper! So where does he rate? Compared to any other Republican or Democrat....and it only will get worse,and a lot worse after elections!!!!
 
 
0 # bingers 2012-09-10 04:30
Quoting Madamegar:
and yet,all Obama did was dig it in deeper! So where does he rate? Compared to any other Republican or Democrat....and it only will get worse,and a lot worse after elections!!!![/quote[quote name="Madamegar"]and yet,all Obama did was dig it in deeper! So where does he rate? Compared to any other Republican or Democrat....and it only will get worse,and a lot worse after elections!!!!


About where Eisenhower does, since he's almost a rubber stamp of Eisenhower, but a bit to the right of Ike. Better than Nixon, Carter, Reagan, Bush I & miles above Bush II.
 
 
+16 # ALinSTL 2012-09-06 18:42
...& ELECTING ROMNEY/RYAN IS GOING TO CHANGE ALL THIS HOW?!?!?!?!?!?! ?
 
 
+1 # bingers 2012-09-10 04:31
Quoting ALinSTL:
...& ELECTING ROMNEY/RYAN IS GOING TO CHANGE ALL THIS HOW?!?!?!?!?!?!?



By making it algorithmically worse.
 
 
+2 # bingers 2012-09-10 04:27
You have no idea what you're talking about. Granted interest rates were high under Carter, but they were inherited from Ford. Reagan is the one ultimately responsible for our problems caused bu his absurd trickle down policies which caused an immediate recession which he stopped by raising taxes on the poor and middle class to pay for the enormous cuts for the rich. In the entire world he was only able to find 18 economists who agreed with that policy.

Your IRA should be doing better since the stock market has more than doubled since Obama took office, and under "Obamacare" you will be covered. And overspending is NOT the problem. The only country in the developed world that spends less than we do is Taiwan. The problem is undertaxation of the rich which needs to return to the top marginal rate it was before Reagan destroyed the economy. BTW, we were NOT better off in '84 than in '80. Check out the figures yourself.

We ARE better off now than in '08 and the entire world credits Obama for averting a worldwide depression. One brought on by conservative economic actions.
 
 
+27 # Mrcead 2012-09-06 14:02
Of course we're better off. Republicans are rather impatient folk aren't they? All of those national level disasters are supposed to be undone in 4 years? That's a very, very irrational and unrealistic expectation, even in storybook land.

I can see how life would be stressful for a person who only sees in black and white all the while ignoring the vast shades of grey. The sad part is they drag everyone else down with them, shared ideology or not.
 
 
-15 # Madamegar 2012-09-06 15:21
We're not!!!
 
 
+10 # pernsey 2012-09-06 21:48
Quoting Madamegar:
We're not!!!


Why because Fox news tells you arent?
 
 
+7 # kalpal 2012-09-07 05:58
I am amazed that Cheney and his deputy Addington are not in jail along with the rest of the war council which created bogus legal opnions giving America the cover to used untrained men and women as interrogators and abusers.
 
 
+9 # wwway 2012-09-07 06:03
We will continute to be better off when more of the provisions of the Affordable Health Care act go into effect and when a Democratic majority in the Senate and House can move that Act forward.
Americans will have more money to pursue interests and afford other important things that help the economy. I know my family will.
The social/politica l/economic Anarchy proposed by Republicans isn't designed to help Americans. It's designed to help the wealthy who have ALWAYS hated the idea of giving anyone a chance to compete with them.
 
 
-10 # spartacusjones 2012-09-07 08:05
I can understand the "drift toward vitriol." I hope this missive does not "offend," BUT:

The President has claimed the authority to have ANYONE -- including American citizens -- murdered, and all on his own ipse dixit, for whatever secret reasons he may please. No charges, no trial, no due process.

AND he has, in fact, ordered the murders of numerous innocent persons, including at least 2 US citizens.

That and that alone is reason enough for him to spend the rest of his life in prison.

But some mincing sycophants will still vote for him because they like his smile and his sweetie planted a little garden, or because he's (half) Black and they want to show how "enlightened" they are. or because he has a "D" instead of an "R" on his chest

A jackass and his liberty are soon parted. Which is to say the people get the government they deserve.
The readers of RSN appear to be completely divorced from reality. And RSN isn't "news" it's just pro-Democrat propaganda, just as bad and just as false as the corresponding dunghills pro-Republican propaganda.

A wise man once said, "Never try to teach a pig to sing; it wastes your time and annoys the pig."

Therefore, I shall absent myself and leave you all to wallow in the swill of your mindless adulation for a corporate pimp who has out-Bushed Bush in destroying the Bill of Rights.

liberty and justice,

sj
 
 
+1 # bingers 2012-09-10 04:34
Yeah, that's another Bush policy he should have ended. Nobody thinks Obama's perfect. He's too far right to be what sane people want, but your charges are way far amplified and contain stupid conclusions.
 
 
+1 # cynnibunny 2012-09-10 11:55
Quoting bingers:
Nobody thinks Obama's perfect. He's too far right to be what sane people want...


Well said! We - progressives, middle-of-the-r oaders, unionists, radicals - need to look at the president along a spectrum or good and bad. Yes, he's not perfect, but he's frightfully better than what Ryan and Romney stand for.

We should look at the election for what it really is: if Romney/Ryan win, then we've given the greedy Koch's, the absolutists like Rove, and the fear-mongers like Cheney the proof that the Presidency can be bought.
 
 
+7 # Mark Leonard 2012-09-08 03:09
Soon we'll ask voters in this world of soundbites, shrinking attention spans, and stupidity "Are you better off than you were 15 minutes ago?"

Does anyone remember what Herbert Hoover did to grease the skids for the depression and FDR did to pull us up?
 
 
-7 # JGross001 2012-09-08 07:34
The main way we are better off now is that we are coming up on an election that gives us a chance to replace Obama. Oops, I guess that makes me a racist, maybe I should have said it better. Supposedly, the "great recession" ended about 6 months after Obama was sworn in. All he had to do was nurture the recovery, but that did not go well. The recovery has been pitiful, and therefore many people, blacks included, are out of work.
 
 
+2 # bingers 2012-09-10 04:36
Quoting JGross001:
The main way we are better off now is that we are coming up on an election that gives us a chance to replace Obama. Oops, I guess that makes me a racist, maybe I should have said it better. Supposedly, the "great recession" ended about 6 months after Obama was sworn in. All he had to do was nurture the recovery, but that did not go well. The recovery has been pitiful, and therefore many people, blacks included, are out of work.


So, you're one of those low information voters who don't realize that the one and only reason the recovery hasn't been vigorous is Republican filibusters. They have been doing so many that every year since Obama took office they've done more than the Democrats did in the previous century.
 
 
0 # cynnibunny 2012-09-10 10:15
It is "breathtaking impudence" - yes - but extremely clever! Is the Republican propaganda machine in tune with the emotions of nostalgia or what? I think they are. Take a moment and try to feel, not with your personal convictions, but with your sense of the 'public' (as created and mediated by Fox News and other - gulp! - popular media channels).....

When we 'look' into the past, we don't see African-America n presidents. We see Norman Rockwell's America - lillywhite and false. When we look into the past, we see all that is 'good' - from a particular point of view. The fact that our progressive mindset is deliberate, and nearly natural for Democrats does not presume the same for Republicans and Independents.

It was a remarkably naive suggestion that Obama made: comparing now to 4 years ago! It is dangerous - not because of the truth, but because nostalgia is a cognitively shallow, emotionally unclear black hole.
 

THE NEW STREAMLINED RSN LOGIN PROCESS: Register once, then login and you are ready to comment. All you need is a Username and a Password of your choosing and you are free to comment whenever you like! Welcome to the Reader Supported News community.

RSNRSN