Pierce begins: "We have become a nation in which children have become expendable. Trayvon Martin is just the most recent example."
Trayvon Martin. (photo: Family, Trayvon Martin)
Trayvon Martin and the End of Excuses
24 March 12
e have become a nation in which children have become expendable. Trayvon Martin is just the most recent example.
We executed children in this country until long after the rest of the world - except Iran - thought that was a good idea. Almost six million children live in poverty in this country. Almost six million of them are without health insurance of any kind, and that's reckoned to be an improvement. None of this is accidental. These children are expendable because the people we elect make policy decisions of which we approve - or, at least, of which we do not disapprove. The Republicans in Congress - behind the "leadership" of zombie-eyed granny-starver Paul Ryan - would like to zero out the SCHIP children's health-care program. If they do that, it will not be done by accident. The Florida legislature, behind the leadership of the National Rifle Association, passed the "stand your ground" law, despite the fact that even police and prosecutors were warning that it amounted to a hunting license for anyone who had both a gun, and the ability to concoct a good story. Trayvon Martin is not dead by accident.
But, already, even in the face of widespread outrage, the notion is continuing to circulate through the country, like topical anesthetic working on an open wound, that what happened to Trayvon Martin was, if not entirely accidental, then merely a combination of unfortunate circumstances culminating in an entirely regrettable event. (That's not even to mention the wilder precincts of mouth-breathing public commentary. If you ever needed proof that whatever consulting genius came up with the idea of having a Comments section follow every newspaper story deserves to die a slow and painful death by honey and fire ants, this story is pretty much what you're looking for.) Conservatives caution the president not to "inject race" into the incident any further, because, as we know, we can't tell how much of a factor "race" was, because George Zimmerman was half-Hispanic and because of the backward masking on the Sergeant Pepper album. (I am not kidding.) Geraldo Rivera, looking for relevance in all the wrong places, blames hoodies:
But I am urging the parents of black and Latino youngsters particularly to not let their children go out wearing hoodies. I think the hoodie is as much responsible for Trayvon Martin's death as George Zimmerman was.... Every time you see someone sticking up a 7-11, the kid is wearing a hoodie.... When you see a black or Latino youngster, particularly on the street, you walk to the other side of the street. You try to avoid that confrontation.
(And every time I see someone convicted of ripping off pension funds, he's wearing a $500 suit. Don't wear $500 suits!)
For his part, the president was calm and measured, because that's the way the president is, and because he is rather circumscribed in what he can say publicly on topics like this because of factors that should be obvious from the Comments section above. Nevertheless, he neatly put Florida's deeply unpopular Republican governor, Rick Scott, on the spot:
"I am glad that not only is the Justice Department looking into this, but the governor of the state of Florida has put together a task force."
Translation: Make it a good one, Rick, because your ass is in this jackpot, too.
Well I certainly don't feel calm and measured, and it's not because my kids "could have been Trayvon." No, they could not have. My kids are white. They lived in the suburbs. They could wear their pants anyway they liked. They could have worn hoodies to Midnight Mass on Christmas Eve, and nobody would have looked askance at them, let alone blown them away with a handgun. (As I recall, I once wore a black hoodie to Midnight Mass on Christmas Eve.) The worst threat to my children's lives in the big wide world was that some suburban matron who couldn't see over the steering wheel would run them down in the family SUV. They didn't have to worry about running into some trigger-happy, half-mad wannabe on the way home from the convenience store. And that's what keeps me from being calm and measured.
I am sick to death of people who celebrate "the family" making excuses about why other people's children are expendable. I am sick to death of politicians who are more concerned about protecting zygotes than about the teenagers on whom they seek to balance their budgets and advance their careers. (Barney Frank's line about conservatives's believing that life "begins at conception and ends at birth" was not entirely a joke, although it's always been treated as one.) I am sick to death of opportunistic yahoos who can look at this country's unhealthy attachment to firearms and declare that the actions of George Zimmerman, while unfortunate, were pretty much what the Founders had in mind. I am sick to death of the steady drip-drip-drip of all the topical anesthetics we mix up whenever something like this happens. Had Emmett Till been killed in 2012, there'd be at least three people sitting in the CNN Green Room right now - and probably 15 of them sitting offstage at Fox - waiting to explain how unfortunate it was that the lad so transgressed against local custom that circumstances dictated that he be beaten to a pulp and tossed into the river tied to a cotton-gin fan. I am sick to death about how we can argue about anything simply to argue about it, and then move along to the next argument, as though anything at all has been settled.
I think this controversy has some legs to it. What alarms me is not that Zimmerman hasn't yet been arrested, but the awful feeling that the Florida legislature, with the approval of the people of Florida, may have passed a law so idiotic that it prevents local law-enforcement from arresting him at all. (I can't imagine what the good cops in Sanford must be feeling today. The dispatcher told this clown not to pursue Martin, and he did it anyway. They must simply be angry at the world at this point.) And what makes me angry down to my soul is not that my children could have been Trayvon, but that, because of the way we have ordered our politics and our society, only someone like Trayvon could have been Trayvon.
|
THE NEW STREAMLINED RSN LOGIN PROCESS: Register once, then login and you are ready to comment. All you need is a Username and a Password of your choosing and you are free to comment whenever you like! Welcome to the Reader Supported News community. |













Comments
We are concerned about a recent drift towards vitriol in the RSN Reader comments section. There is a fine line between moderation and censorship. No one likes a harsh or confrontational forum atmosphere. At the same time everyone wants to be able to express themselves freely. We'll start by encouraging good judgment. If that doesn't work we'll have to ramp up the moderation.
General guidelines: Avoid personal attacks on other forum members; Avoid remarks that are ethnically derogatory; Do not advocate violence, or any illegal activity.
Remember that making the world better begins with responsible action.
- The RSN Team
I have never looked upon anyone in this country since as anything other than an American. The flag is red, white, and blue, but citizenry is of every skin hue.
They referred to their own indigenous mountain tribespeople as nguoi thuong and held them in contempt in the south.
Like yourself, they were comfortable with using pejoratives such as "Cong."
they called us a lot of names, at least Cab came home without hate.
By whatever name, they were worthy opponents who fought for something they believed in as did we.
As to Cong being a pejorative, it is simply a shortening of the designation Vietcong. It was also what we used to refer to our principal foe during the time of my service.
After losing so many soldiers during the 1968 Tet offensive and the second countrywide offensive that May, the NLF found itself displaced in numbers by NVA regulars, whom you probably also referred to as "Cong."
As a former G.I., I'm sure you're aware that many if not most G.I.s referred to all Vietnamese as "slopes," or "slopeheads," or worse.
I also assume that you, as part of the invasion force, were trying to kill them, who were making that distinction, though you should have had no dog in the fight.
Maybe I'm wrong. Did you become a member of the VVAW?
I am aware of terms you cite and while in country actively and vocally discouraged such terminology as did my dying friend.
You term myself and the other American's as the invasion force and you are welcome to do so, but we did not see ourselves that way. See cold war reference.
Upon returning home, I took part in anti-war actions because I believed our deployment had been based on a series of lies.
That damn war is over and we have new battles to fight. Such as those against the killing of children here in the nominal land of the free.
Zimmerman violated the rules, everything that springs from that violation is his own responsibility. If he was in trouble, he was responsible for that trouble! Since he had violated Treyvon's rights, not the other way around. He had absolutely no right to approach, talk to or otherwise get involved with Martin. So, as a criminal who has invaded someones right to privacy, he can't claim self defense. Anymore than a thief can come into your home, shoot you, and then claim self defense because you tried to shoot him.
Zimmerman was ordered to stand down and he disobeyed that order, that made him into a vigilante unlawful! Against whom Martin had every right to defend himself!
If he was bruised and cut by Trayvon...and I stress the "if" since we don't know for sure (no arrest or pictures taken of him)...then, it was Trayvon who was acting in self-defense. This guy had a gun! Would you not try to run or fight back when someone had a gun in your face?
But in reality, we don't KNOW anything but the fact that Zimmerman admitted shooting Trayvon, who according to authorities, had nothing but skittles and an iced tea in his hands, and a hoodie on his head.
This Florida law reeks of America's greatest woe: we've been taught that it's okay to kill and believe that that is the ONLY way to protect ourselves.
Thanks, Obwon, for your insights into this situation.
N.
NO! I do not share responsibility for Trayvon's murder! Nor do I share responsibility for "Stand Your Ground" legislation!
When I here this 'group consciousness' crap, I recoil. I am not responsible for the oil spill when I drive my car. I am not responsible for someone's killing when I live in the same country. I am not responsible for China's inhumane treatment of it's workers because sometime way back when I bought an Apple product (because I believed they were an aware company).
Once we become aware of something, then we can do something about it. Not before! And just because I did not say something about it, doesn't mean that I agree with the status quo.
That 'group consciousness' claptrap has been used by BP guilt propagandists, Richard Nixon to claim support from 'silent majoiry', Nazi apologists to blaim all Germans, and so on.
What killed Trayvon was an absurd law, the absurdly uncontrolled access to guns, and an individual's 'transparent' yet overstepping understanding of his mandate.
Sports do not cary the message of sportsmanship anymore. In 2012 sports represent - and make - big money. Those who earn millions - be it the players or coaches are with few exceptions not the most educated. The fans identify themselves with players who are making millions. This crusade against education and people who are highly educated makes the fans feel better about themselves. Those less educated may have deep down complex of inferiority or worse an outright hatry. When the ability to bring up intelligent discussion ceases, then use of the gun gives sense of power and accomplishment. At that point the issue for the murderer is not taking away human life, but the primitive sense of empowerment. Kasandra you are right, our humanity is suffering. And the observation of Progressive Patriot is correct also.
At least in NYC., where we have these auxillary units, the department keeps these guys on a very short leash, and even then they've caused a few problems for the force. So that now, as a general rule, these aux units are usually police academy recruits. Very few civilians and they are often paired with police recruits who have to worry that improper actions might harm their chances at a career in police work.
Another reason for mentality test for those passing the law as well as those brandishing a gun.
Pa lawmaker who put a law in similar brandished a weapon at people who passed him on Rte 22...he got away with it. He should have lost his job...but then it is Pa a Red State for all the lives they want to kill Thanks GOP
Several states refused to ratify the Constitution, unless there was a clause that protected the right of the individual states to form their own militia, to protect their citizens against an overly powerful Federal government. (Remember, they had just come out of a war with Britain, who had posted troops throughout the Colonies, to enforce the King's edicts.
Our National Guard is the states' militia, fulfilling the states' rights under the Second Amendment. There are three specific purposes for which _the_Congress_ (not George W. Bush or any other president) is allowed to call up the states' militia to national service, none of which is the unilateral invasion of a nation halfway around the world. The National Guard has been used unconstitutiona lly in both Afghanistan and Iraq. (Read Article I, Section 8 ... the Powers of Congress.)
"A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed."
Question: Are Zimmerman and the millions of other American gun owners members of "a well regulated Militia?"
As a criminal, he proceeded to unlawfully invade the privacy of Martin without the benefit of any lawful reason, and against the cities own advice, nay, orders! The 911 does not "advise" people obligated to follow it's instructions, it orders them to follow those instructions, under pain of acting alone!
In the eyes of the law Zimmerman became a criminal vigilante who shot a child to death for no good reason!
Touche! Indeed.
While walking in my neighborhood the other night, I actually thought, "maybe I better not put my hood up on my raincoat. Somebody might shoot me." That's a thought I can honestly say I never considered before Zimmerman shot Trayvon. And before Geraldo ever said such a dumb thing.
I truly hope that you will be proven wrong about the law preventing Zimmerman from being arrested. He needs to go on trial. But if he doesn't, I take some pleasure in knowing that he will never feel completely at ease ever again throughout his life. He's a marked man and I hope he feels scared every minute of it that someone, somewhere, is following him ready to pounce like he did on Trayvon.
NRA should be the ones in the hoodies perhaps that will change some thoughts, eh?
We are killing and jailing too many of our young people.
and our people of color.
it is a national disgrace.
Thank you for telling it like it is.
kathie mm
He even said in a gospel that no one should look down at another who is poor, diseased. He said it could be him we treat inhumanly. Guess people weren't versed on this.
I never treat anyone cruel who has less. I would rather give them food, blanket than perhaps know they died on the way side. Jesus is in all of us, too bad so many choose to be Satan.
In training classes for an unarmed security force, 20+ years ago, we were taught, by a former state trooper, and judo expert, how to disarm a person with a gun ... something I never want to have to try ... I'm not as young as I was then. (The trainer claimed that in 25 years as a state trooper, he had _never_ drawn his gun.) I'm sure it's not just "the good guys" who know how to disarm someone.
Guns are a far too simple, and final, "solution" to conflict. I have to commend the Portland Police for a recent incident in which they were able to talk an armed person out of a house without any gunfire. Negotiation is how it should _always_ be done. Guns should be the last resort, not the solution.
Suckers like Zimmerman need to be stopped and put where they can't hurt anyone. But they are empowered by vicious little rats like Paul Ryan, who is lauded by the crazies who have spiked up the number of hate organizations to over 1,000 in this country.
I blame the Republican leadership for this, starting with John Boehner and Mitch McConnell. They have set the stage for the hate crimes and the nasty racialism they encourage by not speaking out against rotten scum like Glenn Beck and Rush Limbaugh. Yet they are only doing the bidding of the heads of large corporations who fear that they will be made to pay fair taxes for their obscene profits, people like the insidious Koch brothers, who contribute to Republicans who then use any means to get elected so they can continue to serve their wealthy masters. Because these minions of dysfunction and spite comprise only about 30% of the population, they will use any dirty trick in their repertoire to get their way--one of them being the racialism that got Trayvon Martin killed.
J'acuse you GOP rotters, J'acuse.
Rebuild Our Hearts, Take Back America
Why would you even mention color? This is the problem...color should not matter...but, unfortunately, in America, it is what is seen first. And the shooting will never stop, regardless of the color of one's skin (which has NOTHING to do with who we become in our world, unless we LET it have something to do with it), and THAT is the most unfortunate thing of all.
Money is their game...no more memberships let get proof to get them shut down once and for all.
Rebuild
America....tear Down the Terrorists in America
Rebuild your life....Take Back America.
Rising crime led to a truly dangerous, socially degenerative law allowing anyone who senses a threat from another to kill them. And, as in this case, if there are no witnesses the survivor can claim self-defense and go free.
Consider the potential impact: I would bet every person of color here is exposed to threatening behavior each week. Should they then declare open season, using this law to justify their response?
The answer is "no" for two reasons. First, they cannot expect equal justice in the Sunshine State. But the more accurate reason is most have learned to rise above these daily doses of hatred--they have character. And courage. And know the law is wrong.
Florida best elect real leaders who can unite us. And close this Pandora's Box before absolute hell erupts here.
Your last statement is so true. If Zimmerman walks away free and never serves any time for murder there will be riots in Florida. It's Rodney King all over again.
JFK was the first president to stipulate civil rights is a moral issue. Let us all stop and examine our consciences about this and other incidents.
For those who often tout their piety, whatever happened to "Do unto others as you would be done unto"? Or "Judge not that ye be not judged"?
Deep in my heart, I do believe we shall overcome someday. I just hope that day comes soon.
"Breathes there a one with soul so dead
As never to oneself have said
No matter what excuses may be pled
A child is dead!
In a seemingly prosperous Florida town
A young black boy was wantonly gunned down
The police were summoned and quickly came
But the lad lay dead all the same.
Must we not all wonder why?
A happy, friendly child had to die.
He went to the store and was coming back
Then was slain for the crime of “walking while black”
For too long this has been the case
People hating people based on race.
Fathers mourn and mothers weep
Are our consciences asleep?
Before there is an irrepressible outcry
How many innocents must wrongfully die?
All citizens of good will must take a stand
And drive this viciousness from the land.
Now we all must raise our voice
See the options and make a choice
This is too much; we’ll take no more
We must act now and end this dreadful horror.
Let this recent murder be the last
Banish it to a terrible past
Let it never again be said
A child is dead!"
As a person who held his dying best friend in his arms on a battlefield, I truly and completely abhor your implication that calling for an end to racially driven child murder suggest I don't belong in the country I was born in and fought for.
But some where I think that it says everyone is innocent until proven guilty.
Now bear in mind I am in no way saying that Zimmerman is not guilty. What I am saying is that as Americans we live by the rule of law. I stress that while this investigation is on going we should hold our personal opinions of what we THINK happened and hope our laws find out what really is a fault here.
The lynch mob mentality that is being expressed here has no place in what we all hope and want is a civil American Society.
Unless of course those of you would like to become vigilantes??
Just some food for thought.
I also thought that we in the US lived by the rule of law. Our president doesn't seem to think so. He acts like he's living in the Wild West going around killing willy nilly with drones and Navy Seal operatives.
What message is he sending to our youth when he boasts on national tv about killing Bin Laden? about using drones to kill US citizens because it's self defense? it's for protecting the homeland? Sounds to me like that law in Sanford Fl is the same being used by our President!
I also know that there is an ICC. Why is it that Bin Laden, Qaddafi, Al Alawiki and others weren't tried by this criminal court and put to justice? Killing isn't the answer in any case.
Every news report strongly suggests there was/is probable cause for an arrest. Even the Martin family is not presuming conviction. They have time and again called for the sequence to start and have not presumed its conclusion.
Huh?? WTF? Too many kids?? What has that got to do with any part of this issue?
i'm not quite sure what your point is, unless you mean to say that if mr martin and mr zimmerman had never been born, one would not have been around to kill the other?
to a party in the neighborhood and was killed in the middle of the afternoon. Another recent case involved a teen who knocked on a door during halloween and was shot in the back as he ran away. That's rednecks for you, cowards packing arms because they are "afraid".
I for one don't trust anyone who stalks me in a van with a gun, either - but, hey, I'm sensitive.
There was a witness and he said Trayvon had Zimmerman on the ground and was beating him. Zimmerman was calling for help. (Trayvon's dad has listened to the 911 tape and said it is NOT Trayvon calling for help.
Trayvon was 6'2" football player, bigger than Zimmerman.
It would not make any sense to arrest Zimmerman now. Why not wait and see what the Grand Jury does.
It's pretty clear that more guns, more concealed handgun licensing does NOT lead to more deaths. In fact, just the opposite, when states adopt CHL laws, crime drops.
You might think carrying a gun would cause you to become violent (I don't know, maybe you would react that way.) Most people recognize the seriousness. I had a friend tell me that carrying a gun caused him to become less confrontational . He realizes what he would have to go through if he just pulled his gun, much less shot someone. He is less likely to argue of whose got the right of way. Less likely to flip someone off.
Switch, I'd like to see documentation to support the above statement.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/More_Guns,_Less_Crime
posted as a convenient way to find more information
If, in fact, Trayvon Martin was so much bigger than George Zimmerman, then why in the hell was Zimmerman chasing him unless it was to do him some great bodily harm? I know I wouldn't chase a 6'2" youngster, white, black, or green, unless I understood, deep down inside, that if he gives me any lip, I can pop a cap in his ass.
Zimmerman was advised by the 911 operator to stand down and not give chase. In ignoring that, he essentially disobeyed authority.
I will forever think that Zimmerman felt he could be a hero, and if push came to shove, he always had his handgun to fall back on.
Thus he was not only no longer a watch commander, but he was a lone vigilante, seeking to illegally invade the childs privacy, for absolutely no legal reason.
Zimmerman should have gone home, or talked again with 911, to see if more information might have changed their minds. In which case they would have sent a full fledged peace officer to investigate the complaint. Zimmerman had no authority to do anything but observe and report, that's all a "neighborhood watcher" is legally empowered to do, not put themselves in harms way by approaching anyone for any reason!
So, his report to the police warranted no further action! He was told to leave it alone, he did not and an unarmed child was killed, simply because Zimmerman did not follow police instructions and leave! Case Closed!!!
racism, and the concept of “might makes right,” supported and reinforced by
weapons. Those who kill animals for sport (or murder young black men carrying
candy and skittles ) are despicable, cowardly, spiritually bereft beings. It is bla04nDecp9vio us that men obsessed with guns feel sexually inferior, needing to shore up their inadequate penile power with gun-power, often concealed in their pocket right next to their inept sexual organs.
Unfortunately, this is typical for our politics these days. Think about how many times the last few years polls indicated the public supported one position, but our legislatures voted the other way. Examples, would be the "public option" and all the war on women stuff coming up right now.
We need to get money out of our politics. We need real democracy.
I share the thanks of many for Charles Pierce's article, but if this country's going to get any better we ALL have to take responsibility for demanding it. Posting comments is a start but it's not enough.
What difference will that make? Z is not claiming he did not shoot T, he's not claiming that is not his gun. The issue will be 'was he in fear of his life' and did he have a right to be there.
If he was a cop, he would have had to surrender his weapon in most urban situations, pending administrative review of the "officer involved killing."
Agreed, and I take issue with his claimed "right to be there". As the line between "neighborhood watch" and "illegal vigilante" is a fine one, Zimmerman climbs over that wall when he refuses to follow the direction of his superiors.
Firstly he has more responsibilitie s than a mere bystanding civilian would have, by nature of his being a "N.W." to not be a vigilante, he needs to follow the guide of his superiors, which is why he called 911. When they instructed him to break off, cease and not follow, they also ended his right to "be there". They took away any reason he had to approach at all. So, what he did, he did as a vigilante acting alone, and illegally, because he'd been told by the police dept., not to engage! Thus any need to kill anyone was caused by his own actions!
Police Chief Bill Lee said there was not enough evidence to arrest George Zimmerman, who followed Martin in his SUV and ended up confronting the teen before shots were fired.
http://theattackmachine.wordpress.com/2012/03/20/320-trevon-martin-stand-your-ground-and-bama-government-gets-a-c/
BD, on March 20, 2012 at 11:06 pm said:
http://theattackmachine.wordpress.com/2012/03/20/320-trevon-martin-stand-your-ground-and-bama-government-gets-a-c/#comment-11388
Zimmerman was driving a car, he had a weapon and he was not 100 lbs heavier than this kid Trevon but at least 200 lbs. Trevon was walking, talking on a cell phone and had a bag of candy. We know that George was following him in his car, George got out of his car and confronted Trevon, Trevon was shot and murdered.
I know my family WILL NOT be returning to Florida until a lot of things have changed. Florida needs to know that black folks, and people concerned with justice spend a lot of money on vacations too.
To: Corals33
Where from your ancestors immigrated to the US? Unless you are native American you are descendant of immigrants. The only NATIVE Americans either assimilated or are living in reservations.
Afterall he got out of his truck/car/whate ver and was in hot pursuit. Trayvon defended himself against the assualt and in the ensuing fight, Zimmerman shot Trayvon dead.
That's the way I piece together all the stories I've read in the last 2 weeks. Zimmerman should be in jail having been charged with assualt with a deadly weapon and possibly involuntary manslaughter or out on bail awaiting the findings of the Grand Jury.
That's when the brown stuff will really hit the fan.
RSS feed for comments to this post