FB Share
Email This Page
add comment
Print

Ellison reports: "On Monday, Air Force Sergeant Luis Walker will face a court-martial in Texas, shining a harsh spotlight on the military's supposed 'zero-tolerance' policy toward sex offenders."

Female airmen march during graduation at Lackland Air Force Base in San Antonio, Texas. (photo: John L. Mone/AP)
Female airmen march during graduation at Lackland Air Force Base in San Antonio, Texas. (photo: John L. Mone/AP)



The Military's Rape Failure

By Jesse Ellison, The Daily Beast

16 July 12

 

The case's first court-martial shines a spotlight on the military's 'zero - tolerance' failure.

n Monday, Air Force Sergeant Luis Walker will face a court-martial in Texas - the first case in the military's biggest sexual assault scandal in 16 years, and one that is shining a harsh spotlight on the military's supposed "zero-tolerance" policy toward sex offenders.

In the year since Walker was first accused of rape, an internal investigation has discovered 31 more victims, at least five other instructors have been charged with rape or inappropriate relations with female trainees, and 35 more have been removed from their positions pending investigations. Walker has been charged with multiple counts of rape and aggravated sexual assault.

On June 28, California Congresswoman Jackie Speier addressed the Lackland case on the floor of the House of Representatives. "Nothing has changed," she said, calling for a hearing into the alleged abuse. "We need to know once and for all why instructors have been permitted to abuse power so freely and we need to know from the top that the phrase 'zero tolerance for sexual assault in the military' is a fact, not a talking point."

Quantcast

The military first pledged to crack down on sexual assault and harassment within its ranks in 1992, in the wake of a massive scandal that erupted at the Navy fliers' annual Tailhook Association convention in Las Vegas, where some 90 victims were allegedly assaulted by as many as 175 drunken officers. A year and a half later, a Pentagon report found that Tailhook was not an isolated incident, but the culmination of a "long-term failure of leadership." The Navy's chief of operations, Admiral Frank Kelso, pledged that the event would transform the institution. Tailhook "brought to light the fact that we had an institutional problem in how we treated women," he said. "In that regard, it was a watershed event that has brought about institutional change."

But just four years later, another scandal erupted - this time, at Maryland's Aberdeen Proving Grounds, where assault charges were brought against a dozen male officers for sexual assault on female trainees. Then, in 2003, the U.S. Air Force Academy was also accused of systemically ignoring an ongoing sexual assault problem on its premises.

In a phone interview with The Daily Beast, Speier called the similarities between the Lackland case and Aberdeen "chilling," and expressed her frustration with repeated but seemingly empty calls for "zero-tolerance." She estimated that half a million people have been sexually assaulted while serving in the U.S. military. "You have sexual predators that are on the prowl," she said. "I'm sick of the excuses."

A 2012 Pentagon report found that, last year, 3,192 incidents of sexual assault were reported within the U.S. military - up 1 percent from 2010. According to the Defense Department's own estimate, just 15 percent of actual incidents are reported, putting the real number at some 19,000 assaults each year. Under current policy, reports of sexual assault are handled directly within the military's chain of command. There's little incentive to investigate accusations, and as a result, cases are rarely prosecuted. According to the report, nearly 70 percent of substantiated, "actionable" cases did not go to trial because of lower-level command discretion.

These dismal statistics would surely not surprise Paula Coughlin. In late June 1992, as a 29-year-old Navy lieutenant, she appeared on ABC News to tell the nation about her horrific ordeal at Tailhook. She said that, along with dozens of others, she had been groped and manhandled in a "gauntlet" - and that, when she'd told her superiors about the incident, they'd done little more than shrug. (One reportedly told her, "That's what happens when you walk down the hall with a bunch of drunk aviators.")

But Coughlin was persistent, and took her complaints higher and higher up the chain of command, before ultimately going public with the ABC interview and an article in The Washington Post. Two days later, she was summoned to a meeting with then-president George H.W. Bush. She thought it was a sign that she was finally being heard.

"When you get the call that the Secretary of Defense is going to take you over to see the president? I'm thinking 'oh my God. These are the big guys. This is serious. We're really finally going to solve this problem.'" she told The Daily Beast. But her greeting from then-Defense Secretary Dick Cheney wasn't exactly warm. He looked at her, she says, and told her, "You know, I just had to fire the secretary of the Navy because of you." "I'm like, oh, this is not the healthy environment I thought it would be."

Twenty years later, Cheney's purported dismissiveness seems all the more ominous.

That was hardly the worst of it, though. "It was a horrible experience," she says of coming forward with her accusations. "I'm part of this Naval aviation community, or I was. But what I endured day-to-day from fellow aviators, from commanding officers…[they] looked at me like such a huge liability. The Navy really wanted me to go away quietly. It became an endurance test to see how many days I could get up and go to work."

That experience is not an uncommon one. As survivors of military sexual harassment and their advocates say, when it comes to rape within the ranks, the attacks themselves are just the tip of the iceberg. More damaging still is the way the assault cases are handled. "Congress has done a number of hearings and in each of them, the victims and their heartbreaking stories of their experiences with the military are equally as disturbing as their stories of sexual assaults," says Congressman Mike Turner of Ohio. "Many times, they say they were re-victimized."

Congressman Turner and Representative Niki Tsongas, who formed a Congressional caucus on military sexual assault this year, wrote a letter last week requesting that the Air Force brief their caucus on its response to the Lackland scandal. "[Secretary of Defense Leon] Panetta has said that the military has a 'zero-tolerance' policy," Tsongas said. "Well, we've heard those words before."

The military's emphasis on hierarchy and authority means that many officers are more inclined to protect the institution than the victim, says Elizabeth Hillman, president of the National Institute for Military Justice. "Look at Penn State," she says. "What happened there is just what happened in the Catholic Church and the U.S. military."

Coughlin, who now goes by her married name Puopolo, is speaking out for the first time in years, joining Speier and an advocacy organization called Protect Our Defenders in calling for an immediate congressional hearing. "Twenty years ago, this issue came to light," Coughlin says. "I'd been living in a little bubble - thinking that the 7 to 10 years I'd fought to make some changes in the military had affected some change. I don't think I changed anything. It's extremely disappointing."

 

Comments   

We are concerned about a recent drift towards vitriol in the RSN Reader comments section. There is a fine line between moderation and censorship. No one likes a harsh or confrontational forum atmosphere. At the same time everyone wants to be able to express themselves freely. We'll start by encouraging good judgment. If that doesn't work we'll have to ramp up the moderation.

General guidelines: Avoid personal attacks on other forum members; Avoid remarks that are ethnically derogatory; Do not advocate violence, or any illegal activity.

Remember that making the world better begins with responsible action.

- The RSN Team

 
-17 # Doubter 2012-07-16 21:13
I don't want to use the "boys will be boys" excuse, but when I read the numbers I had to laugh out loud. I mean you have to imagine a herd of Neanderthals raiding a human camp and raping and carrying off the women. I suspect quite a few of the girls are (nearly?) as liberal minded as the guys. On the other hand: are soldiers expected to be monks and nuns? We are the HUMAN, not the ANGELICAL race. These gals must have some reason for invoking rape all the time, and it might have something to do with semantics and the definition of rape. I mean, with that many rapes going on, no one could sleep for all the shouting for help!
 
 
+5 # Majikman 2012-07-17 08:06
If you cannot differentiate between consensual sex and rape, you are more a Neanderthal than you readily admit.
 
 
+11 # Phlippinout 2012-07-16 21:45
No wonder the morals of this country are in the toilet, for some, rape is acceptable whether you be a soldier, an athlete or a coach. How can we expect to be a civil society when there are so many who are free to harm others because of their status. The double standard made me give up watching sports, supporting military involvement and looking the other way when something wrong is going on.
 
 
+3 # Texas Aggie 2012-07-17 07:46
For proof of your statement, see Doubter above.
 
 
0 # Doubter 2012-07-20 19:52
Guess you never heard of irony.
 
 
+14 # lorenbliss 2012-07-17 05:34
Note how the imperial U.S. military machine with its unwritten policy of coddling rapists is equally notorious for its unwritten but nevertheless mandatory Christian fanaticism.

Coincidence? Given the hatred of woman and Nature at the heart of Christian Fundamentalism, surely not.

Despite the outcry by a few politicians, the military's longterm protection of rapists proves it to be a policy demanded by the Ruling Class.

Why? As part of the broader effort to force women back into their traditional roles as household slaves and brood mares.

Note too how a similar combination of theocratic tyranny and misogynistic hatefulness is being imposed on women throughout the nation by the radical new restrictions on reproductive freedom.

Such is capitalism: unlimited wealth and power for the One Percent, abject slavery for the rest of us.
 
 
+8 # maddave 2012-07-17 06:21
There is no excuse for forceable sexual encounters, but - if history tells us anything - there is no avoiding such behavior in organizations wherein the use of force is the basis of the organizations' very existence. It's estimated that almost HALF of all military females have been raped at least once - and not always by men - and certainly 100% have been the objects (or perpetrators) of crude, suggestive sexually-orient ed "humor".

Speaking from my almost 60 adult year' experience in-uniform-and- retired, military and paramilitary (law enforcement, etc.) organizations attract some percentage of domineering, aggressive folks with strong appetites. Consequently, physically and psychologically weaker individuals will invariably be marginalized and bullied until they "man up", leave the service or go crazy & kill themselves or someone else.

That female "groupies", both in and out of the service, encourage male service members in this "inappropriate" behavior is a very real situation---wel comed by some troglodytic idiots---that the DOD dares not address (openly).

And don't even THINK about the possibility of intra-service prostitution ... and especially not on USN ships at sea on long deployments.

Why do you think that the military medical facilities ALL stock and dispense birth control meds? Hint: it ain't to stop STD's.
 
 
0 # shraeve 2012-07-20 11:10
When people are completely deprived of sex they do crazy things.

Why shouldn't prostitution be an option? I think part of the rape problem is the total ban on prostitution for members of the US armed forces.
 
 
+3 # mdhome 2012-07-17 08:33
Sorry to say I doubt things will ever change in the military, the powers that be are too lazy to make changes.
 

THE NEW STREAMLINED RSN LOGIN PROCESS: Register once, then login and you are ready to comment. All you need is a Username and a Password of your choosing and you are free to comment whenever you like! Welcome to the Reader Supported News community.

RSNRSN