86-Year-Old Ohio Veteran Denied Vote Under ID Law

By Travis Waldron, ThinkProgress

07 March 12

aul Carroll, an 86-year-old World War II veteran who has lived in the same Ohio town for four decades, was denied a chance to vote in the state's primary contests today after a poll worker denied his form of identification, a recently-acquired photo ID from the Department of Veterans Affairs. The poll worker rejected the ID because it did not contain an address, as required by Ohio law.

Carroll told the Cleveland Plain Dealer that he got the ID from the VA after his driver's license expired because he doesn't drive anymore:

“My beef is that I had to pay a driver to take me up there because I don’t walk so well and have to use this cane and now I can’t even vote,” said Paul Carroll, 86, who has lived in Aurora nearly 40 years, running his own business, Carroll Tire, until 1975.

“I had to stop driving, but I got the photo ID from the Veterans Affairs instead, just a month or so ago. You would think that would count for something. I went to war for this country, but now I can’t vote in this country.”

A local Veterans Affairs employee told the Plain Dealer that the decision not to include the address was likely made at the federal level, and because VA IDs are accepted at any location, "the actual address of a veteran isn't as critical to us." Carroll was offered a provisional ballot, but the type was too small for him to read and "I was kind of perturbed by then," he said.

Republicans across the country have pushed voter ID laws to address a voter fraud "problem" that rarely, if ever, exists. Multiple laws have been challenged in court over claims that they disenfranchise voters, particularly minorities and the elderly. Carroll's story isn't altogether unique - Tennessee voter authorities denied a 96-year-old woman a voter ID last year because she didn't have an original copy of her marriage license.