RSN Fundraising Banner
FB Share
Email This Page
add comment
Print

Excerpt: �We're publishing five stories that show the personal and material cost that the families and friends of the mentally ill must take on when caring for a loved one.�

 (photo: Alamy)
(photo: Alamy)


'If You're Mentally Ill in America, You are Shit Outta Luck'

By Ruth Spencer, Amanda Holpuch, Guardian UK

01 June 14

 

s part of the Guardian's ongoing investigation into American mental health care, we asked you to help us illustrate the effects of the lack of access to mental health treatment. We received an overwhelming response.

Today, we're publishing five stories that show the personal and material cost that the families and friends of the mentally ill must take on when caring for a loved one.

'My mother texts me every day to make sure I'm still alive'

I'm a junior at ASU studying Filmmaking and Fine Art, and I'm living with Bipolar Disorder Type Two Rapid Cycling. I see a psychiatrist and psychotherapist on a weekly basis; these appointments are an indispensable part of my treatment. My medications are constantly being adjusted to find a balance, and psychotherapy brings me awareness of the patterns of my illness. Medication and professionals, however, make up only half the arsenal to combat my illness. My family and friends are my greatest allies. They revitalize me from the eerie brokenness of depression, and effectively keep me grounded in the electric-fury of hypomania.

I've been diagnosed and seeing healthcare professionals for over 18 months now. My father is a police officer and receives great healthcare benefits. I'm still on his insurance plan and he covers the co-payments of the doctor�s visits.

The monthly cost of seeing both of my doctors once a week, is about $400. Additionally medication costs about $30 a month. That's nearly $8,000 for 18 months. Plus, $350 for a 10-day hospital stay after a suicide attempt.

Before I was diagnosed or received any sort of treatment I was dysfunctional, indifferent towards my future, suicidal, self-destructive, self-medicating, perpetually moody, agitated, and I increasingly isolated myself from society. Medical treatment provided me the capacity to counter my illness, my family and friends became the excuse I constantly told myself to keep fighting the affliction. I'm very convinced that I wouldn't be alive today if it wasn't for others looking out for me and showing kindness.

I try not to think of myself as a burden on other people, although I'm sure it's true to an extent.

I've cost my parents a small fortune, and I've seen it affect them financially. They've had to change their lifestyle, to take care of me, to be there for me. My mother texts me every day to make sure I'm still alive.

I'm not cured, mine isn't a story of transcendence. I don't believe I'll ever break out of my mental prison. I don't even know how many more years of life I have left, but I can say that I wasn't forgotten or ignored, my life was recognized by others as having enough value to at least try and fight. � John, Phoenix, Arizona

'When my daughter killed herself, I died too'

My daughter had been diagnosed with clinical depression as early as eight years old. Living in San Diego, we had access to outstanding healthcare. We took her regularly to therapists as she was on my excellent health insurance plan. Her depression, with medication, was manageable.

She did well in school, even though we had a number of problems with her moodiness. She went on to college, graduated, and no longer qualified for my health plan. She got a temp job as a teacher for a year, then was out of a work.

I started paying for her doctor�s visits and medication. After spending over $40,000 dollars that I�d borrowed from my IRA, I was tapped out.

She had to rely on our county�s public mental health care to get the treatment and meds she needed.

There are some excellent and well-meaning people that work for counties in mental health, but they are so overburdened and burnt out they can only do so much.

At the age of 33, my daughter committed suicide. I died too.

I was unable to continue working. I wanted to work till I was 75, but retired at 72 because I simply couldn't do it anymore. I worked for the Army Corps of Engineers and found myself just sitting and staring at a computer screen all day and accomplishing little. That was five years ago, and my nightmares are now just beginning to subside and I can function reasonably well now. � Jim Fawcett, Houston, Texas

'It was a miracle when we found my brother a place to live'

If you would have told me 25 years ago that my family and I would still be caring for my brother, I wouldn't have believed you. He suffers from schizophrenia and has wreaked havoc on our family emotionally, physically and financially.

When we found him Section 8 housing in San Rafael 12 years ago, it was a miracle and only happened because we knew somebody who knew somebody.

This year, the Non Smoking Ordinance rendered him homeless. The man who drafted this legislation told me he 'just didn't think about' how the law would impact the mentally and physically disabled people who simply are unable to quit.

The people who owned and managed the housing were so compassionate and tolerant toward him, and tried in vain to get him to stop smoking on the premises before he was kicked out. But he really didn't belong there. He belongs in institutionalized housing and care.

Now, we are housing him in a warehouse, trying to care for him. Families should not have to provide psychiatric care for their loved ones. It just doesn't work. I am trying to scrape together a loan to buy him a place so that he can't get kicked out again.

A person suffering from untreated schizophrenia simply does not have the capability to make decisions on their own to benefit them. I firmly believe in compassionate but forced medication followed by care.

People don't have a clue of the horror you have to go through to care for a loved one struggling with mental illness. I can't really talk to people about it because they just don't understand. Basically, if you are mentally ill in America, you are shit outta luck. � Robert Butlerman, Bay Area, CA

'In a nation with a better mental health care, I might have been relieved by the knowledge that my brother was being cared for, rather than the fact that he is dead'

My family was briefly involved in caregiving for my brother, before he tragically ended his own life. After he died, I read his journal and learned he was living a nightmare: convinced he was in hell, that we were demonic forces out to get him, and also suffering from visions of self-grandeur.

In his early twenties, he began exhibiting symptoms of schizophrenia and bipolar disorder, which exacerbated rapidly and aggressively. To our great distress, there was little we could do. John (not his real name) was paranoid and distrustful, and resistant to any form of contact from us.

In 2010, the police found John living in an airport. My mother was able to convince him to come home with her, and our family was reunited for Christmas, which would be our last together.

It was heartbreaking to witness him in such a state of misery and to not be able to help him. On Christmas Eve, in a fit of rage, John threatened to kill himself if my parents did not give him money for a plane ticket, we had the great relief of hearing the words that we knew could get him forcibly institutionalized. We called the police and were able to have him brought to the hospital by ambulance.

My brother was released from the hospital after 10 days, which is not even enough time for a proper medication schedule to take effect. A mere month and a half after he was released from the hospital, he turned up at a San Francisco hospital, where he checked himself in and was found to be dehydrated. He was given some sort of treatment and promptly released. From the hospital, he headed directly to the Golden Gate bridge, which he jumped off.

Only because of John's hospital visit, from which he was still wearing a wristband, were authorities able to identify his body.

While I would give anything to have my brother back, it is terrifying to imagine many more years of the stress we experienced that Christmas, trying to constantly chase John down and keep him alive. He was suffering horribly during that last year; life was torturous for him, and his inability to care for himself made everything even more painful. When he was alive, every minute of every day I wondered, "Where is he now? Is he in pain? Is he scared? Is he hungry or thirsty? Is he safe?" I worried about the long-term cost � financial and emotional � to my family to keep him alive. I am no longer plagued by those questions. In a nation with a better mental health care system, I might have been relieved of them by the knowledge that he was being cared for, rather than the knowledge that he is dead. � Amy, Chicago, Illinois

'I have given up my own business and we have been through bankruptcy'

I am the caregiver for a mentally ill daughter with severe OCD, PTSD, and depression. I am daily support for checking her moods, administering her medications, and driving her to appointments. I am the first line to call emergency services in crisis, or to take her to the emergency room at the hospital.

She has been ill for 10 years. She is a college graduate who had been holding down a job and living independently. Our experience with the mental health system is that it is uneven and inconsistent with support and providers. There is a lack of agreement as to her best treatment and what local services exist.

I left my job so I could provide 24/7 support for the last decade. I have had to give up my own business and we have been through bankruptcy. Some local services for "adult daycare" have come available in just the last year where I can get some breaks.

Conservatively we have been out $80,000 a year in my lost earnings and $60,000 in hers. Treatment and medication costs for her run approx. $2,000 monthly.

I have some elements of depression in my own life due to the massive shift in family lifestyle and goals. There has been tremendous strain on our marriage, and we have lost some friends who did not understand what we were going through. My career is dead-ended and now all I have waiting for me is eventual retirement.

Our daughter lives with us so there is constant tension in the home. Vacations have been non-existent for years now. We live very frugally.

It is very peculiar that there is still tremendous social stigma connected to mental health disorders and their treatment. Even though great strides have been made in understanding brain disease, there is still a persistent element in society that does not believe mental illness exists and that people just need to "snap out of it." It is viewed as some sort of moral failure, as opposed to a brain that has a distinct disease process going on that can be identified and treated. Thank God for NAMI and the work they do educating the public and supporting families. � Rob, Gresham, Oregon


e-max.it: your social media marketing partner
Email This Page

 

Comments  

We are concerned about a recent drift towards vitriol in the RSN Reader comments section. There is a fine line between moderation and censorship. No one likes a harsh or confrontational forum atmosphere. At the same time everyone wants to be able to express themselves freely. We'll start by encouraging good judgment. If that doesn't work we'll have to ramp up the moderation.

General guidelines: Avoid personal attacks on other forum members; Avoid remarks that are ethnically derogatory; Do not advocate violence, or any illegal activity.

Remember that making the world better begins with responsible action.

- The RSN Team

 
+18 # PhilO 2011-10-04 21:58
After graduating from college many years ago I moved back to my home town. That fall I tried to vote in a local election but was turned away because I hadn't changed my voter registration. I felt embarrassed and was treated like a criminal by the poll-watchers. That experience was traumatic enough to send a chill down my spine every time I ave gone to vote since.

I can imagine that the new voter laws will do nothing to curb voter fraud (as if it ever occurs!!), but will dissuade many people who are unsure about their voter registration.

Clearly these laws are a disingenuous ploy meant to keep people away from the polls.
 
 
-11 # MidwestTom 2011-10-05 09:19
When does one learn that one must register to vote? Without registration laws we would go back to the periods where in some districts more votes were cast than there were voters.
 
 
+16 # noitall 2011-10-04 22:40
You know what the republicans say, "we do very well in elections when the turnout is low". All you guys out there pissed off at the Repubs, the Teabaggers and their schenanigans, I know, we all vote for the worst of two evils, but this time the Dems guy is BAD but their guy (whoever that might be) will only be on the ballot because he's REALLY BAD. This is not a good time to demonstrate your pissed-off-dom by not voting. Its like rewarding the guy that gave you a crap sandwitch. I guess I'll vote for bad, I really don't have the stomach for really bad and he might turn out to be really, really bad. This is America today and they wonder why its the youth out there demonstrating. This is THEIR future that we're dealing with here. I was out there in the good old Nam days and it eventually did some good although you'd never know it today or by watching Kerry or any of those other one-time young people. I guess we just decided that we deserve YOURS too. Sorry.
 
 
+12 # Regina 2011-10-04 23:33
The Republican Party is committing the real voting fraud. It's time to blow whistles and get control over enfranchisement -- not in their way of denial but in the American way of inclusion. The noisiest "patriots" are the most criminal anti-patriots this country has ever had to cope with.
 
 
+10 # angelfish 2011-10-05 01:51
Wake up, America! These Fascist ReTHUGlicans will rig the Elections so NO Democrat can win! WHAT are they so afraid of and WHY don't they trust the American People to do the right thing? They rigged Bush's appointments to the Presidency, I hope they don't think that they'll be allowed to get away with that egregious Bull-Puckey again! As their god and mentor George W. Bush once said, "Fool me once, Shame on you. Fool me twice, Shame on ME!...and NO, Georgie, They WON'T fool us again!
 
 
+18 # maddave 2011-10-05 02:43
This coordinated drive by the GOP to pass nearly identical anti-voter laws in red-state after red-state is an naked, criminal conspiracy to disenfranchise targeted groups of voters.

Time & space preclude a history lesson, but think of the successful voter suppression in Florida & Ohio in 2000 & 2004 . . . before the roof fell in in 2008.

Vowing that "it will never happen again", the GOP embarked on a uniform, organized program to "clean house", and so far their shameless, immoral efforts are succeeding all across America.

So where is the DNC and the DOJ? Why are RICO laws NOT being invoked in this unified case of organized, naked criminal violation of the 1960's Voting Rights Act and the 15th Amendment to the Constitution?

Steal $50,000 and go to jail. Steal 500,000 votes and go to the White House.
 
 
+7 # fredboy 2011-10-05 07:45
The GOP/teabagger focus is on eventually ending voting altogether. They hate democracy, hate America, and prefer a regime that would dictate their fanatical beliefs.
 
 
+6 # ABen 2011-10-05 09:03
THE VOTE: use it or lose it! Vote Democratic in 2012!
 
 
+5 # fredboy 2011-10-05 09:15
The GOP sees voting as simply a manipulative game, while many of us see it as a cherished and essential right.
Let's make it a felony to deprive any citizen of their right to vote with a five year mandatory prison sentence and a $500,000 fine for each and every offense, with no statute of limitations.
 
 
-18 # MidwestTom 2011-10-05 09:16
Can a person who cannot read or write our language know the issues and cast an intelligent vote?
 
 
+5 # Uncle Joe 2011-10-05 13:24
In a real democracy (the real American Way) we have public education & we engage neighbors & friends to give direction in a positive way. If you KNOW someone who is going to the polls to vote who is incapable of making an informed choice then its up to you & me @ the grass-roots to make them aware and educate them.
 
 
+8 # Regina 2011-10-05 17:08
As the daughter, granddaughter, and niece of immigrants who were schooled in another language, and later qualified for American citizenship, I can tell you with authority that (1) translations are now routinely available for purposes of enhancing comprehension; (2) intelligent thought is not exclusive to literacy in English; (3) you're just flapping the Republican Party line, and none are more uneducable than the echo-chamber Republicans, who keep chanting their mantras even when disproven by the facts.
 
 
+7 # PGreen 2011-10-05 13:27
It may well be that this is the opening shot in a war to further control the political agenda through gerrymandering. It is not a new tactic, but given that the population is polarizing along class lines with an increasingly greater majority on one side, it may be a tctic whose time has come, so to speak. In a democracy, a small minority cannot control a majority without the manufacturing of consent; when this process breaks down, when there is no longer a coherent national narrative to manipulate, then I would expect to see a shift to this kind of tactic. Questions remain: Can we stop it? Will exposure (such as this) make a difference? Will the Democratic party fight it or fold? And what will come next?
 
 
+5 # ALinSTL 2011-10-06 23:01
What FOOLS we are deemed to be...All these years we thought it was the Commies & Al-Queda trying to destroy America, making us all slaves, stealing all our rights...Funny that all this time it has been the TRAITOROUS REPUBLICAN PARTY trying to close our schools, kill our elderly, starve the poor, murder your children, make us their factory slaves, take away all our rights, DESTROY OUR AMERICA FOR THEIR AMERICA. Time to stop them in every election & never let NONE of them EVER hold an American political office again...their motto:" A govt of "US" people, by "US" people & for "US" people..." their "US" will never include any of "us"...
 

THE NEW STREAMLINED RSN LOGIN PROCESS: Register once, then login and you are ready to comment. All you need is a Username and a Password of your choosing and you are free to comment whenever you like! Welcome to the Reader Supported News community.

RSNRSN