RSN Fundraising Banner
FB Share
Email This Page
add comment

writing for godot

Danger! Danger! 'Opportunity' Ahead.

Written by librarian1984   
Tuesday, 31 July 2018 18:20

Recently on CSPAN two opportunities arose to see exactly how the establishment, left and right, plans to screw us over next.

1) First, Lanae Erickson Hatalsky, Third Way VP in charge of social media and outreach, attempted to make the case for the latest organization to attack progressives. Ms. Hatalsky tried to justify another electoral foray into appealing to 'moderate Republicans', an idea that never seems to die among neoliberals. She correctly interpreted their Big New Poll to say that Americans are worried about the economy. Duh. But from there it went sideways.
Hatalsky was quite certain that 'old ideas don't work' -- not 1960s socialism or 1990s centrism or the New Deal. Summarily dismissed despite the New Deal having saved the country (and capitalism) in circumstances very like this and having propelled FDR into the presidency four times -- presumably five if he'd lived.
Instead, assured Ms. H, we need to appeal to red and purple voters (1), and to that end the TWers, under the umbrella of their initiative 'Opportunity 2020', had concocted a list of Ten Big Ideas, including privatized portable pensions and the creation of an American Investment Bank to spread venture capital to all fifty states. Oh good.
Then The Poll got trotted out. The TW poll, a masterpiece of guided testimony, which just happened to say all the things TWers want to hear. For instance, people don't want a blanket minimum wage of $15. No! They want wages indexed regionally, because an Alabaman doesn't need as much as a New Yorker, so TBD algorithms that we will never see will figure that all out -- so don't worry your pretty heads about it. Capice?
As I heard this I was thinking, Hmm. I bet Americans don't want single payer health care either and sure enough, that was next. People would rather have an improved ACA than a government plan (wink) like single payer (2). She said the difference was even more marked among Ds and D-leaning Independents, because improving the ACA garnered 36% approval generally while single payer got 29%, a difference of 7%, but the same numbers among Democrats had a 9-point differential (3).
This is when the Big Idea appeared. According to Ms. H the notion that automation will eliminate jobs is wrong. Technology will DISRUPT jobs, not DESTROY them -- and besides, Americans don't want free things. They want to EARN them. (Like we earned our 'entitlements'?) So the TW is going to give them the OPPORTUNITY to earn, rather than giving them 'handouts'. Oh! dignity! Yes, when a robot has your old job and your kids are hungry you are in no mood for universal basic income. That's just commie!
Ms. H tells us that because Republican voters are more ideological than Democrats the DP must be more of a big tent and so must appeal to a wider range of people -- therefore we can't move to the left. Ignore those stadia bursting at the seams -- that would just be silly!
There is absolutely no attempt to reach the generation of enthusiastic young people who want to vote progressive, and there is no acknowledgement that this same idea of trying to get GOP votes hasn't worked for the past two decades -- which is precisely why the GOP has 33 state houses, most state legislatures, the House, the Senate and the presidency.
Ms. Hatalsky concluded with a bit of TW wisdom and a threat: In 2020 we want 'an affirmative agenda providing every American everywhere the OPPORTUNITY TO EARN A GOOD LIFE' (emphasis mine). This sounds like GOP weasel-speak.
And when asked what kind of candidate could defeat Trump in 2020 it's just a total coincidence it sounds like TW honcho John Donnelly, the first 'Democrat' to declare his run. (He's already been to NH 24 times!) Ms. H says it should be someone who is an outsider and maybe 'new to politics'. Yeah, because outsider and new-to-politics Donald Trump is doing such a great job. Really? Bernie Sanders is more of a Democrat than this guy, no matter what letter is next to his name. (Let's give Donnelly an 'A' for Ass.)
2) The next guest was from Forbes Magazine, Steve Bertoni, talking about a bipartisan provision snuck into the GOP tax reform bill that provides for 'Opportunity Zones', devised ten years ago by philanthropist Sean Parker (Napster, Facebook) and concocted over the years by a benevolent mix of 'politicians (Cory Booker, Tim Scott), philanthropists and billionaires'. These zones would allow the do-gooders to invest unrealized gains in impoverished areas -- with a couple of incentives. If someone were to invest in one of these areas and keep the money there for ten years, not only would there be no capital gains tax on that money but after the ten years it would never EVER be taxed!
These impoverished areas are first selected by meeting one of two criteria: either the poverty levels are 20% or higher or the median income is less than 80% of surrounding areas -- but that results in 8700 (!) possibilities, at which point the GOVERNORS will choose who is included in the program (4)!
When asked if this wouldn't just result in high-speed gentrification Bertini said local safeguards would need to be in place. The CSPAN host said, 'Wouldn't that just raise rents and drive people out?' to which Bertoni replied, 'That's a reality anywhere, right?' (5) He even had the nerve to say that maybe home loans could be arranged.
Bertoni said this is collusion -- but in a good way -- and that mayors should 'have a package ready' to attract investors, as they hope to have program details in place in early 2019. He said 'money will flow'.
Mr. Bertoni got a GREAT call from a NJ man. It was so wonderful I quote it in its entirety:
"40 years ago I made $8 an hour. Here it is 40 years later and folks are still earning $9, 10, 11 an hour. Back then cars were $2500. Now they're $25,000. It's going to be the same thing. These 'opportunities' help the rich, the corporations and the money just doesn't trickle down.
"I feel like the greed of the elites in this country has destroyed our nation and until capitalism is tweaked so it benefitsmore people and it's a more fair system we're going to continue to see this over and over again, and watch our country be destroyed from the inside-out as we lose our neighborhoods and people become more despaired, on drugs -- they work every day but can't make a living -- and until this is addressed -- I don't care what you do -- with giving the elites and corporations more -- It's not going to save our nation. It's going to continue to destroy our people."
Bertoni: Is that a question? I don't know. The problem of poverty and inequality has been with humans since humans have been around. I don't know. But I want to get back to the Opportunity Zones law ...
One gets the feeling Frank Luntz has focus grouped the sh!t out of obfuscatory words and 'opportunity' came out the winner, a word that promises without guarantee, that hints at redemption while all benefits go to the same groups who always get them.
For the foreseeable future 'opportunity' is a word that should raise red flags and send you running in the other direction.
We can beat these opportunistic arseholes -- but they're not going to just lay down for us. Pay attention to what they say and what they're really offering.
'Opportunity', for now, seems to be the new bait-and-switch scam, a word future thesauruses may synonymize with 'Screw you -- and the horse you rode in on'. Beware!
(1) Why do we need to appeal to GOP voters rather than the big, energetic left wing of our own party?
(2) I imagine these numbers would change if you took ten minutes to explain the specifics, which is one reason Sanders' series of town halls is a bit of genius.
(3) Well within the margin of error, so no, not necessarily -- and an indicator we are being spun.
(4) Remember there are GOP governors in 33 states.
(5) Yeah but without the no-taxes-in-perpetuity bit. Oh, and there is no cap on the amount that can be invested either. your social media marketing partner


A note of caution regarding our comment sections:

For months a stream of media reports have warned of coordinated propaganda efforts targeting political websites based in the U.S., particularly in the run-up to the 2016 presidential election.

We too were alarmed at the patterns we were, and still are, seeing. It is clear that the provocateurs are far more savvy, disciplined, and purposeful than anything we have ever experienced before.

It is also clear that we still have elements of the same activity in our article discussion forums at this time.

We have hosted and encouraged reader expression since the turn of the century. The comments of our readers are the most vibrant, best-used interactive feature at Reader Supported News. Accordingly, we are strongly resistant to interrupting those services.

It is, however, important to note that in all likelihood hardened operatives are attempting to shape the dialog our community seeks to engage in.

Adapt and overcome.

Marc Ash
Founder, Reader Supported News

+2 # librarian1984 2018-08-02 05:52
I do not know why I have such trouble formatting this. I originally had spaces between each paragraph, which didn't show up here, so then I edited, adding lines between paragraphs, and it STILL doesn't show up. I don't understand why that happens, and apologize that this is difficult to read.
+1 # Depressionborn 2018-08-04 11:45
Hi lib 84.
Why not simply leave each other alone and in peace? As in "mind your own business" and "take responsibility for yourself"? Restrict gov to protecting us from enemies foreign and domestic-nothin g more except regulate Commerce.
+2 # librarian1984 2018-08-06 06:18
It sounds good on paper but I don't think it scales up.

We NEED to regulate banks because otherwise they cheat us.

We need to inspect food because otherwise they'll poison us.


That said, I have come to believe that laws and tax forms are overcomplicated because those in power want it that way. They can hire lawyers to take advantage of the complexities and confuse the rest of us.

I too am a strong believer in common sense, and think it lies somewhere in the middle of the two extremes. (I'm also an Aristotelian :-)

I'd be curious to see what other countries are like.
+1 # Depressionborn 2018-08-05 11:28
the plan from Califonio:

“what’s next?”:
This from California now
“Unfortunately, common sense is just not common. We have to regulate every aspect of people’s lives.”

O my, where is a copy of the Constitution and how we call up the the Militia? {now we find out why we have the 2d?)
+2 # librarian1984 2018-08-06 06:23
That IS a ridiculous statement.

I think violence is counterproducti ve. We would never win and they would use it as an excuse to impose martial law.

In the 20th century I think we found that peaceful protest is much more effective.

Guns are just for fun or food, imo.
+1 # Depressionborn 2018-08-07 02:38
Government is violence. It even has special laws for it's violence and profit.
+1 # Wise woman 2018-08-08 20:11
Lib - it's useless to get into a discussion with someone who "has all the answers to everything." Thank you for a well thought out, articulate article. I thoroughly enjoyed reading it and had no problems with your spacing issues. I hope you continue publishing in Writing for Godot.
0 # Depressionborn 2018-08-11 04:24
Someone should write on this. It could be big.

The first trial on whether the world’s most widely used herbicide causes cancer came to an explosive ending Friday — a San Francisco jury’s award of $289 million in damages to a man diagnosed with a lethal illness while spraying school grounds with a weed-killer manufactured by Monsanto Co.
0 # Depressionborn 2018-08-11 04:26
Quoting Wise woman:
Lib - it's useless to get into a discussion with someone who "has all the answers to everything." Thank you for a well thought out, articulate article. I thoroughly enjoyed reading it and had no problems with your spacing issues. I hope you continue publishing in Writing for Godot.

You might try searching for clarity instead of demanding agreement
0 # Depressionborn 2018-08-17 03:26
hey lib 84, though you might like this "the worm turns":
George Soros has been outwitted by Hungarian Prime Minister Orban, ceasing operations in Hungary. He is moving his subversive operations to Berlin, a city better suited to Soros Nazi-collaborat ion background.
Soros assisted the Nazis.

THE NEW STREAMLINED RSN LOGIN PROCESS: Register once, then login and you are ready to comment. All you need is a Username and a Password of your choosing and you are free to comment whenever you like! Welcome to the Reader Supported News community.