The Internet Giants Oppose Surveillance - But Only When the Government Does It

By Zoe Carpenter, The Nation

17 December 13

ight prominent Internet technology companies unveiled an open letter last week calling for reforms to the government surveillance programs revealed by Edward Snowden. "The balance in many countries has tipped too far in favor of the state and away from the rights of the individual - rights that are enshrined in our constitution," reads the letter, published on a website that lays out five principles for reform, including greater oversight and transparency, as well as an end to bulk data collection.

Executives from seven of the firms will meet with President Obama on Tuesday, in the shadow of a federal judge's ruling that the collection of domestic phone records is unconstitutional. The opinion from US District Judge Richard Leon reinforces the impression that NSA overreach constitutes a primary threat to privacy and civil liberty. But some privacy advocates caution that even if the NSA's programs are scaled back, surveillance infrastructure will persist in the private sector—thanks to the same companies now calling for reform, whose business models depend on the collection and sale of vast quantities of personal information.

"It's one-stop shopping for the NSA," warned Jeffrey Chester, the executive director of the Center for Digital Democracy, a consumer privacy advocacy group. "What they've done is create a global commercial surveillance system that is engaged in the same kind of pervasive tracking and analysis [as the NSA]."

Continue Reading: Google is quick to condemn government surveillance, but...