RSN Fundraising Banner
FB Share
Email This Page
add comment

Pierce writes: "The question is how much of the turmoil we own - and how we're going to make good on our moral debts."

A toddler and the Mexican federal police. (photo: Getty Images)
A toddler and the Mexican federal police. (photo: Getty Images)

We Bear Responsibility for the Conditions in Honduras Causing Its People to Flee

By Charles Pierce, Esquire

28 November 18

The question is how much of the turmoil we own—and how we're going to make good on our moral debts.

od help us, we have handed government over to soulless lunatics. From the Washington Post:

A little girl from Honduras stares into the camera, her young features contorted in anguish. She’s barefoot, dusty, and clad only in a diaper and T-shirt. And she’s just had to run from clouds of choking tear gas fired across the border by U.S. agents. A second photograph, which also circulated widely and rapidly on social media, shows an equally anguished woman frantically trying to drag the same child and a second toddler away from the gas as it spreads.

The three were part of a much larger group, perhaps 70 or 80 men, women and children, pictured in a wider-angle photo fleeing the tear gas. Reuters photographer Kim Kyung-Hoon shot the images, which provoked outrage and seemed at odds with President Trump’s portrayal of the caravan migrants as “criminals” and “gang members.” Trump officials said that authorities had to respond with force after hundreds of migrants rushed the border near Tijuana on Sunday, some of them throwing “projectiles” at Customs and Border Protection personnel.

Bull. See also, Shit.

Before we get into this latest atrocity committed in our name, let's go back to October 23, 1998. On that date, the CIA declassified the report by its inspector general regarding what the CIA was doing in Honduras as part of the general (and bloody) Reagan Administration meddling in Central America in the previous decade. Thanks to the irreplaceable National Security Archive, we learned that the Honduran military was freed up to make war on its own people so that the United States could keep using the country as a staging area for its adventurism elsewhere in the region.

The report indicates that the CIA knew contemporaneously about the abuses which were occurring, and did not report on them as it should have even though Honduras was the linchpin of U.S. Central America policy during the Reagan administration. Despite CIA knowledge of Honduran military abuses, more than $1 billion in U.S. taxpayers money flowed to the Honduran military throughout the 1980s.

"The CIA knew there was blood on the hands of the Honduran military but covered it up, providing impunity for rights abusers and misleading the U.S. Congress and public," noted National Security Archive Research Fellow Susan Peacock. She called the release of the IG report "a step toward the disclosure which President Clinton promised vis-a-vis human rights abuses in Latin America." Despite the Clinton Administration's commitment to Congress to release the report to the fullest extent possible, major portions -- including critical sections on CIA involvement in "torture or hostile interrogations" and "possible accountability issues" -- are blacked out.

(An aside: No matter how critical, say, John Brennan is of the president*, the CIA is still a nightmare that has to be addressed seriously by the Congress.)

Using small nations for your own military purposes rarely works out well for the former, and such has been the case with Honduras. The military ran things for several decades, propped up by American aid and Cold War fantasies of Nicaraguan pick-up trucks invading Brownsville. (People really believed this stuff.)

As the years went by, the United States couldn't quit Honduras. And it was very much a bipartisan bit of business. In 2009, when a military coup deposed President Manuel Zelaya at the insistence of the country's Supreme Court, then-Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton supported the government that was installed by the coup. While Clinton was running for president, she argued, especially to Democracy Now's Juan Gonzalez, that the coup was at least nominally constitutional, and that supporting the deposing of Zelaya was the least-bad option. That remains debatable, but what does not remain debatable is that Honduras subsequently descended into the present chaos.

For the past several decades, the country's civilian government has been riven with corruption and the country itself has ripped its own entrails out in gang violence. It has become both a de facto and a de jure human rights nightmare, according to Human Rights Watch:

Lawyers and human rights defenders suffer threats, attacks, and killings. In 2016, CONADEH registered 16 violent attacks against lawyers, including 13 killings. The IACHR described Honduras in August 2016 as one of the “most hostile and dangerous countries for human rights defenders” in the Americas.

To date, eight men have been charged with the murder in March 2016 of environmental and indigenous rights activist Berta Cáceres, including an army major and the former environment manager of Desarrollo Energético S.A. (DESA), the company behind the Agua Zarca dam project that Cáceres was campaigning against at the time of her death. The Mechanism for the Protection of Journalists, Human Rights Defenders and Operators of Justice, created in 2015, suffered from a lack of adequate resources and staffing, according to local activists.

Meanwhile, the current administration*, because it is headed by a bigot who knows nothing about anything, has strangled aid to Central America as part of its Get The Brown People Out agenda. From Reuters:

Under a scheme to strengthen Central America launched in 2014 known as the Plan of the Alliance for Prosperity in the Northern Triangle, the United States pledged to put forward a dollar for every four invested by Honduras, Hernandez said. But that commitment has not materialized, he added. “That will obviously have repercussions,” he told Reuters. “Because the whole idea of the Alliance for Prosperity ... was to attack the migration problem at the root.” Between 2016 and 2018, combined U.S. foreign aid for Honduras, Guatemala and El Salvador declined by more than one third to $195 million, according to official U.S. data.

The people at the border literally are running for their lives. The idea that the United States is now actively hostile to asylum seekers is a nasty throwback to the 1930s.

Irish historian Liam Hogan, writing on the electric Twitter machine, unearthed a quote from Congressman James W. Taylor from that time when the United States was turning away Jewish refugees from Europe and sending them back into the maw of what would become the Holocaust. In 1939, shortly before his own death, Taylor said:

“The American people are not going to be deceived by this refugee bunk. This is just another scheme to bring additional thousands here who are not wanted in Europe.”

And there we are. The problem was that not enough people in America cared enough to understand why those Jews were fleeing, and from what they were fleeing in the first place. That is still the problem today. Radical Trumpists already are calling the weekend's violence a successful repelling of a horde of "invaders," as though gassing shoeless toddlers was the equivalent of Charles Martel's turning back the forces of the caliphate at Tours. That point of view will be taken immediately as the legitimate Other Side of the argument regarding using chemical weapons on impoverished children.

These are people being told through violence that they have to return to the violence that drove them out of their countries in the first place. The ones with longer memories will recall the days when the United States used Honduras to initiate violence in Guatemala and El Salvador for the purpose of initiating it in Nicaragua. The younger ones will simply hate us. The Imperial Prerogative comes with some very heavy dues.

Email This Page your social media marketing partner


A note of caution regarding our comment sections:

For months a stream of media reports have warned of coordinated propaganda efforts targeting political websites based in the U.S., particularly in the run-up to the 2016 presidential election.

We too were alarmed at the patterns we were, and still are, seeing. It is clear that the provocateurs are far more savvy, disciplined, and purposeful than anything we have ever experienced before.

It is also clear that we still have elements of the same activity in our article discussion forums at this time.

We have hosted and encouraged reader expression since the turn of the century. The comments of our readers are the most vibrant, best-used interactive feature at Reader Supported News. Accordingly, we are strongly resistant to interrupting those services.

It is, however, important to note that in all likelihood hardened operatives are attempting to shape the dialog our community seeks to engage in.

Adapt and overcome.

Marc Ash
Founder, Reader Supported News

+14 # AldoJay69 2018-11-28 11:06
I would wager that the readers who follow this storyline are already knowledgeable about it, and you're preaching to the choir.

She'd aspirated vomitus into her mask...

She THREW UP IN HER MASK. Let's cut the bullshit. Say it: She THREW UP IN HER MASK.

She threw up in her mask." -The Verdict

K.I.S.S. Keep it simple, stupid!
If you would dumb it down a bit, a wider audience, (aka, voters,) might grasp the reality that the rest of us grasp.
The typical American voter is a low-information intellectual hermit, suckered by slogans.

"Let's cut the bullshit. Say it:" YOU WOULD FLEE, TOO! WE MADE THE IMMIGRANTS!
+4 # lfeuille 2018-11-28 21:20
The original source was Esquire, not really a leftist publication. It's inching closer to MSM, so it might reach people who are not members of the choir.
-31 # rationalwinseverytime 2018-11-28 12:50
No, we don't. We don't own this chaos. the people of Central America built this. I have lived in Central America. Those governments have been riddled with corruption and bad intentions toward their people for centuries. The people of Honduras, Guatemala and El Salvador are not blameless in creating this condition either. They actively support the corruption, feeding gangs with information and getting paid off for favors. But, still, not all of these countries are unsafe. Americans are retiring in Honduras and Guatemala, mind you. I know many of them. Also, stop with the self-hatred. There must be something pretty good about America that so many of these people would crawl over barbed wire to get in here.
+20 # RussellB 2018-11-28 17:00
God, you are both stupid and blind! You know nothing of the history of US involvement in Latin America and I don't even think you read the article. Those bad governments riddled with corruption wouldn't last a year without US military support. Do you have any idea whatsoever how many times the peoples of Latin America have tried to rid themselves of this miserable situation only to be crushed by the iron boot of the US? How many heads of state deposed or assassinated. How many union organizers, peasants, journalists, priests, nuns and all sorts of activists have been murdered and brutalized trying to make a better life in their own country. What chutzpah to blame people for doing what they have to in order to survive! You should be ashamed but of course you're not, you're too ignorant and you obviously don't give a damn.
+15 # Texas Aggie 2018-11-28 21:02
I've lived there, too. What the article says in only a fraction of what the US foreign policy has done to those countries. We trained their military in torture and assassination techniques (see puentebr). We supplied and supported the dictators who caused the oppression that made people the way they are. We sent our military there to protect United Fruit's push to take away peasants' land for banana plantations. We are supplying their militaries even now with the wherewithal to continue oppressing people. So, yes, buddy, we DO owe them.

Our foreign policy made Castro inevitable. Our support of Somoza and the elite families, Rios Montt and his savages, and the military and elite families in Honduras are directly responsible for what is happening now.
+13 # Kootenay Coyote 2018-11-28 21:07
'Those governments have been riddled with corruption and bad intentions toward their people....'

& who supported those governments, with arms, CIA black work & selective funding? Not Finland, my friend.
+9 # goodsensecynic 2018-11-29 12:42
Central America has been under US economic, political and military control for at least a century. Yes, there is corruption! But it is a corruption involving military dictators, comprador capitalists, vast landowners and the Roman Catholic Church (Archbishop Romero notwithstanding ).

Add to that the CIA, Cola-Cola, the United Fruit Company, etc., and ... hey presto! ... you have a political economy of dependency and authoritarianism.

It's a symbiotic relationship in which the current drug trade is just a particularly nasty iteration.

As for "self-hatred," don't flatter yourself. No one gives a rodent's rectum about America's guilty conscience.

It isn'that "there's something pretty good about America," but that there's something pretty bad about what the USA has promoted and profited from.
+2 # ktony 2018-11-29 15:17
The people of Honduras, Guatemala and El Salvador are not blameless in creating this condition either. They actively support the corruption, feeding gangs with information and getting paid off for favors.Quoting rationalwinseverytime:
No, we don't. We don't own this chaos. the people of Central America built this. I have lived in Central America. Those governments have been riddled with corruption and bad intentions toward their people for centuries. The people of Honduras, Guatemala and El Salvador are not blameless in creating this condition either. They actively support the corruption, feeding gangs with information and getting paid off for favors. But, still, not all of these countries are unsafe. Americans are retiring in Honduras and Guatemala, mind you. I know many of them. Also, stop with the self-hatred. There must be something pretty good about America that so many of these people would crawl over barbed wire to get in here.

Your bigoted, ignorant response illustrates the success of US propaganda against indigenous peasant farmers. Any resistance to the brutal governments was taken as absolute evidence of, wait for it,
Communist Sympathies. So much for Self-Determinat ion, Democracy, and Freedom. Only corporate greed is bolstered and protected.
+25 # RussellB 2018-11-28 12:51
Thumbs up, excellent analysis. It should be mentioned that after the 2009 coup against Manuel Zelaya Hillary Clinton and Obama simply refused to call it a coup even after their own ambassador to Honduras reported it as such. All of the OAS and I believe without exception, the rest of the world called it a coup. If we had, we would have been legally obliged to suspend all military aid and cooperation. That's her "least bad option".
+3 # jamander4 2018-11-28 16:20
I do not know if the US is responsible for all the bad in Central America and I do not care. The only way that the US can hope to stem the immigrant tide is to improve the living conditions for the people of Central America. No amount tear gas or bullets or bombs can prevail over the suffering of people. There is a very strong moral case that can be made for economic development in Central America but I am not making that argument. Instead we need very practical policies that can affect the lives of people that suffer under current conditions.
+10 # puentebr 2018-11-28 16:29
Yes we do, not only for what has already been posted but add to it a fact not very well know before we condemned the citizens of those nations. Since that we forgot the fact that we trained those head of states and their military & police to torture and kill. To jail & make people disappear. we trained them at La Escuela de Las American in Panama for years before we were told to leave and then it went on to Georgia. Torture & kill and if you do not believe it here is my answer: I was one of the banker of those dictators back then!! Paz Garcia, Somoza & company, i.e. Guatemala & El Salvador. Yes we owe them we created the scenario and backed those people. In my last attempt to visit El Salvador the ambassador of the US via Telex advised that they could not guarantee that my visit would be agreeable to the government. Tell Trump that MS-13 began in the West Coast specifically by people that had left El Salvador for those reasons, the killings by armies & police trained and financed by us, and not as he now tells his followers that they derive from there. No sir, we owed them and add that our foreign policy sucks and if you do not believe it remember Iran, the Philippines, Cuba, Venezuela and many other nations whose dictators we backed and in the end we left them adrift. 'Permanent interests no permanent friends"
+5 # DongiC 2018-11-30 18:42
So many times the root cause for Central American horror shows is the American drive for money. Fueled by a national government like Reagan or Bush or Bush II or Clinton where the capitalists can use their capital to control elections and dictate a conservative foreign policy, the US has become the enabler of merciless regimes who suppress their own people and enrich American corporations. We even train these bastards at the School of the Americas in Fort Benning, GA. (Roman Catholics from Syracuse, NY protest at this military base every single year and, yes, I have been with the protesters there.)

So, we are now reaping what we have sewn. Numnutz in the White House should try reading about Central America. Maybe, he would do something to make us truly great again.  Instead of calling down upon us the wrath of God for our intrinsic evil in our quest for riches.

THE NEW STREAMLINED RSN LOGIN PROCESS: Register once, then login and you are ready to comment. All you need is a Username and a Password of your choosing and you are free to comment whenever you like! Welcome to the Reader Supported News community.