RSN Fundraising Banner
FB Share
Email This Page
add comment
Print

Boardman writes: "The madness of the day is this: thousands of peaceful migrants are headed toward the US to seek humanitarian asylum and the US president reacts by inciting panic, rage, and hate. The president warns hysterically of a 'national emergency' as his deceitful ranting works like a self-fulfilling prophecy, stoking a real emergency from the fevered imaginings of his soul-deep bigotry."

A caravan of more than 1,500 Honduran migrants moves north after crossing the border from Honduras into Guatemala on Monday in Esquipulas, Guatemala. (photo: John Moore/Getty)
A caravan of more than 1,500 Honduran migrants moves north after crossing the border from Honduras into Guatemala on Monday in Esquipulas, Guatemala. (photo: John Moore/Getty)


Shouting Fire in Crowded Theatre, President Courts Votes With Lies

By William Boardman, Reader Supported News

25 October 18


The fact that this president has been so obsessed with immigrants and immigration as a key component of his message, from the day he announced his desire to become president of the U.S. in 2015, should not make any one of us surprised that he’s using the caravan, essentially, to further advance his well-established line against immigrants by demonizing them, by dehumanizing them.

… we should not be surprised—if I regret one thing, it’s that there is no strong counter-narrative from the Democratic Party about an event like this caravan or migration altogether. And I believe that that’s a flaw that we need to deal with and find a way of fixing in the U.S.

Oscar Chacon of Alianza Americas on Democracy NOW, October 23


he madness of the day is this: thousands of peaceful migrants are headed toward the US to seek humanitarian asylum and the US president reacts by inciting panic, rage, and hate. The president warns hysterically of a “national emergency” as his deceitful ranting works like a self-fulfilling prophecy, stoking a real emergency from the fevered imaginings of his soul-deep bigotry.

The migrant caravan has been demonstrably peaceful. Mexicans along the caravan route provide food, water, and support. The caravan is estimated at 7,000 people of all ages, mostly whole families. No one has even tried to make an accurate count, but it’s reasonable to believe most of the migrants are fleeing from Honduras.

Honduras presents another face of the present madness, but a much older, bipartisan, imperial face. The US has been kicking Honduras around since before the US government in Honduras was just an extension of the foreign policy of the United Fruit Company. The current state of Honduras as a country that terrorizes its own population dates from the Reagan presidency, when ambassador Negroponte was running Salvadoran death squads out of Tegucigalpa. There followed a brief and uneasy Honduran flirtation with democratic government and an excess of national independence that came to an abrupt end in a military coup. Satisfied with that outcome, Barack Obama and Hilary Clinton officially certified that no coup had taken place (wink wink), and that the US would continue helping the Honduran government to militarize itself, a policy that continues today. The US is happy with the state of affairs, but Hondurans by the thousands can’t find a safe and decent way to live there, so they head north, much to the annoyance of our el Presidente, who, in a remarkably obtuse response, threatens to cut off US military aid to Honduras.

However demagogic politicians may misrepresent this caravan, it has literally nothing to do with illegal immigration. The president falsely claims the people in the caravan are trying to come into the US illegally. They are not. These are asylum seekers. They have standing under international law to seek asylum in another country. The irony is that they’re seeking asylum in the country most responsible for creating the conditions that drove them from their homes.

A sensible leader with a human concern for other human beings might have seen something like this coming, since it’s been happening more or less twice a year for decades. To be fair, the current caravan is one of the larger ones, but still not the largest ever. But the US doesn’t act in good faith when it comes to immigration. The US has a legal obligation to process claims for asylum fairly and promptly. Instead, the US uses force to keep migrants in Mexico, leaves them exposed at border crossings for days, understaffs asylum courts whose backlogs are out of control, and kidnaps children from their parents in a thuggish attempt at deterrence. Now the US president is threatening to meet peaceful asylum seekers at the border with military force. And he’s lying about the migrants, providing no evidence to support his lies:

Go into the middle of the caravan, take your cameras and search. OK? … You’re going to find MS-13. You’re going to find Middle Eastern. You’re going to find everything. And guess what. We’re not allowing them in our country. We want safety. We want safety.

And more of the same demagoguery with no support in fact at another campaign performance, where he refers to a caravan that is more than 1,000 miles from the US border, where it might arrive in late November or much later:

That is an assault on our country and in that caravan you have some very bad people and we can’t let that happen to our country…. I think the Democrats had something to do with it.  

The president’s rhetoric is of a piece with official Republican bigotry in defense of white people. His surrogates accuse George Soros of funding the caravan, of course. Examples of hate speech abound at the state and local level, wherever there are Republicans running scared. The two Republicans indicted for corruption, Chris Collins of New York and Duncan Hunter of California, have made especially racist appeals to get re-elected. And when they’re not overtly bigoted, Republicans are busy lying about policies no Democrat supports (open borders, more crime). When called out for their dishonest tactics they whine about civility.

Legitimate coverage of the caravan reveals no gang members, no Islamic terrorists, no violent people at all. Oh yeah, what about the internet coverage of those “Mexican Police Officers Brutalized by Members of a Migrant Caravan?” It’s a lie peddled by people on Facebook and Twitter without reliable sourcing. Turns out the police were brutalized several years ago (2011, 2012, 2014), but by Mexican students and teachers, not by any immigrants in any caravan (as documented by Snopes). The false meme purveyors are presumably the Republican equivalent of Russian bots. One of those spreading this garbage online was Virginia Thomas, wife of Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas.

In Mexico, official treatment of the caravan is civil and helpful. Popular response has been mixed, but mostly sympathetic along the caravan route. One Mexican along the route, Ana Gamboa, offered a more sensitive, textured response than anything we’ve heard from the US president:

The only thing I can say to people is that they should be more human, that we should look into our hearts and imagine ourselves in the migrants’ shoes, because it isn’t easy, what the migrants are doing. We Mexicans like to criticize Donald Trump for the way he treats Mexicans in the United States, and now we’re acting just like him. We don’t have any walls on our border, but sometimes we ourselves are the wall.

Americans are all too often swayed by fear of imaginary threats. The migrant caravan is an imaginary threat. It’s easy enough to find the facts about this caravan at this time. It’s probably easier to find the falsehoods and the lies, given the media megaphone attached to the presidential tweeter. Once more we’re at the perennial crisis of American democracy: whether enough voters will both learn the truth and vote on it. 

Email This Page


William M. Boardman has over 40 years experience in theatre, radio, TV, print journalism, and non-fiction, including 20 years in the Vermont judiciary. He has received honors from Writers Guild of America, Corporation for Public Broadcasting, Vermont Life magazine, and an Emmy Award nomination from the Academy of Television Arts and Sciences.

Reader Supported News is the Publication of Origin for this work. Permission to republish is freely granted with credit and a link back to Reader Supported News.

e-max.it: your social media marketing partner
 

Comments   

A note of caution regarding our comment sections:

For months a stream of media reports have warned of coordinated propaganda efforts targeting political websites based in the U.S., particularly in the run-up to the 2016 presidential election.

We too were alarmed at the patterns we were, and still are, seeing. It is clear that the provocateurs are far more savvy, disciplined, and purposeful than anything we have ever experienced before.

It is also clear that we still have elements of the same activity in our article discussion forums at this time.

We have hosted and encouraged reader expression since the turn of the century. The comments of our readers are the most vibrant, best-used interactive feature at Reader Supported News. Accordingly, we are strongly resistant to interrupting those services.

It is, however, important to note that in all likelihood hardened operatives are attempting to shape the dialog our community seeks to engage in.

Adapt and overcome.

Marc Ash
Founder, Reader Supported News

 
+7 # lfeuille 2018-10-25 23:10
The Democrats bear too much responsibility for current conditions in Honduras to engage with this issue. They would have to explain why the US supported the coup that led to the chaos under Secretary of State Clinton and President Obama.
 
 
+4 # janie1893 2018-10-26 01:11
I feel like I am watching a really bad movie entitled "Death of a Nation". Where are the people who love America enough to do something about these indecent acts of a madman?
 
 
-16 # rationalwinseverytime 2018-10-26 04:45
I am so glad I have eyes. I do not see a caravan of "peaceful migrants". Peaceful migrants do not paint swastikas on the US flag and burn it. From such raw material good citizens are not made. I have travelled extensively and lived abroad. Europe currently is facing a crisis of historic proportions because of so-called "peaceful" asylum seekers. The caravan coming to the US includes Central Americans, Bangladeshis and others, many of whom have admitted on video (look around) that they "need to find work" because there "is no work" in their countries. This makes them economic migrants, worthy of our sympathy, but not entitled to skip to the head of the line for benefits and settlement in the US.
 
 
+6 # economagic 2018-10-26 20:00
"I do not see a caravan of 'peaceful migrants'. Peaceful migrants do not paint swastikas on the US flag and burn it."

I call bullshit, in this case fake news. When making claims that you know--or that your readers (such as me) have reason to believe that you know--are inflammatory at best, the very least you can do is cite your source so we can decide for ourselves whether it might have some credibility.

I'm pretty sure you have not seen ANYONE in the so-called "caravan" doing either of those things. If you cannot or will not cite the source of your claim--to say nothing of verifiable evidence--you are a troll, in which case your best move is to sit down and shut up.
 
 
+1 # Lisa Simeone 2018-10-28 05:53
Quoting rationalwinseverytime:
I am so glad I have eyes. I do not see a caravan of "peaceful migrants". Peaceful migrants do not paint swastikas on the US flag and burn it. From such raw material good citizens are not made. I have travelled extensively and lived abroad. Europe currently is facing a crisis of historic proportions because of so-called "peaceful" asylum seekers. The caravan coming to the US includes Central Americans, Bangladeshis and others, many of whom have admitted on video (look around) that they "need to find work" because there "is no work" in their countries. This makes them economic migrants, worthy of our sympathy, but not entitled to skip to the head of the line for benefits and settlement in the US.


Did you even bother reading the column?? Do you understand why these people are fleeing??

My god, the stupidity -- it burns.
 
 
+5 # wrknight 2018-10-26 08:55
"--if I regret one thing, it’s that there is no strong counter-narrati ve from the Democratic Party about an event like this caravan or migration altogether. And I believe that that’s a flaw that we need to deal with and find a way of fixing in the U.S." Oscar Chacon

No truer words were ever spoken. The only counter-narrati ve the Democrats are offering is "Vote for Democrats!" Their sole objective is to win. Their agenda is no different than the Republican agenda except the they will be ones pulling the strings and reaping the rewards. They offer you and I nothing in return for our vote.

The two party system in our country is a farce. They differ only in the nameplates that adorn the seats of power. To restore anything resembling a democratic republic in our country we must either establish a viable third party or take over the Democratic party by removing those at the top.

It is ironic that the official name of the political party formed by Thomas Jefferson was the Democratic-Repu blican Party. The party split into two groups, the National Republicans and the Democrats in the 1820's, but one wonders if they are not simply branches of an unnamed super-party, much as the AFC and NFC are part of the NFL.
 
 
+1 # economagic 2018-10-26 20:12
Right on as always, and thanks for the reminder of the origin of the Democratic Party. There is a sophistic battle raging on another news aggregator website over whether a republic (an indirect democracy) is a democracy.

BTW, it's "They offer you and ME nothing in return for our vote." Sorry; my mother was a schoolteacher and a grammar cop!
 
 
+10 # jwb110 2018-10-26 09:36
Why has the UN not been asked for aid in solving this problem. If someone would take it out of you know who's mouth then it would assist everyone in solving a real problem. This is an international crisis and should be treated as such. These situations will accelerate in the face of climate change displacing whole countries because of rising sea levels, etc. This could offer a chance to save these Hondurans from a potential killing spree and give the world a chance to see what will have to be done in the future.
I suppose I am asking for too much wisdom from all the wrong people. Sorry about that.
 
 
+7 # Elroys 2018-10-26 10:01
We have a filthy, lying mind and spirit masquerading as a president of the U.S. if you see some moron with orange hair, white circles under his fake-tanned face, please alert the nearest peace officer and have this foreign virus of a human removed from our property in Wash. DC. Keep your eyes, mind and spirit open and be on the lookout for this very strange and dangerous person. He is armed and dangerous to all human beings, especially our children. Call 911 upon seeing this pervert. Thank you
 

THE NEW STREAMLINED RSN LOGIN PROCESS: Register once, then login and you are ready to comment. All you need is a Username and a Password of your choosing and you are free to comment whenever you like! Welcome to the Reader Supported News community.

RSNRSN