RSN Fundraising Banner
FB Share
Email This Page
add comment

Bernstein writes: "Thirty-two years ago, in 1984, I was teaching media activism in an alternative high school in the South Bronx with filmmaker Chela Blitt. We were getting ready to begin a documentary with the kids on the social, political, and economic reasons why their neighborhood looked more like Hiroshima after the war than a neighborhood in New York City. But instead, we changed gears and produced with the kids the documentary film '12-Gauge Eviction,' which chronicles the close-range gunning down of a 67-year-old, arthritic grandmother named Eleanor Bumpurs."

Eleanor Bumpurs. (photo: unknown)
Eleanor Bumpurs. (photo: unknown)

Remembering the 12-Gauge Police Eviction of a 67-Year-Old Grandmother in the South Bronx

By Dennis J Bernstein, Reader Supported News

18 July 16


hirty-two years ago, in 1984, I was teaching media activism in an alternative high school in the South Bronx with filmmaker Chela Blitt. We were getting ready to begin a documentary with the kids on the social, political, and economic reasons why their neighborhood looked more like Hiroshima after the war than a neighborhood in New York City. But instead, we changed gears and produced with the kids the documentary film “12-Gauge Eviction,” which chronicles the close-range gunning down of a 67-year-old, arthritic grandmother named Eleanor Bumpurs, in the Sedgwick housing project in the Highbridge Section of the South Bronx.

And we got off to a swift start. One of my students had heard the shotgun blasts through the walls and halls of the high-rise. In no time, with our cameras and recording equipment in tow, we were filming through the broken keyhole into the murder scene, where Eleanor Bumpurs was snuffed out of this world for being late on her rent. She owed the city about $400 dollars back rent, which she claimed she was withholding until the city came in and did some necessary plumbing and heating repairs.

Social Services called in the police, and what unfolded next was obscene, extremely brutal, but not all that uncommon. A half-dozen special duty New York City cops arrived at the front door of her small apartment, armed with mace, tear gas, shields, nets, clubs and side arms, but finally decided that nothing less than a 12-gauge pump shotgun fired at close range would do the trick. The first blast from the shotgun took Bumpurs’ hand off. The final blast blew the back of her head off.

The cops claimed they had no choice. They were facing mortal danger, claiming Eleanor Bumpurs, mother of seven and grandmother, was wielding a butcher knife. They claimed the shoot was clean. The local corporate press took it from there. Many press accounts, informed by the police of course, characterized Bumpurs as being “emotionally disturbed” and “deranged.”

My students jumped all over this. One student, a Junior named Douglas, who lived in the projects and had ear-witnessed the shots through the walls – led us to the crime scene. He guided us to the floor where Bumpurs had lived and died, and to the senior citizen center, the library, and other parts of the projects where the residents would congregate. And the kids started to ask questions and interview residents about the police killing of Mrs. Bumpurs.

“If the lady was so mentally disturbed,” pointed out one resident, “people wouldn’t have asked her to babysit their kids.” The resident knew of several parents who had entrusted Bumpurs to babysit their kids for them, until her arthritis became too severe to “chase the little ones around.” One Housing Authority supervisor, Michael Pierson, told the kids, “She just seemed like a quiet individual to me.”

That evening, my students carried their cameras to an outdoor prayer vigil at the projects and interviewed friends and relatives of Bumpurs, as well as a few local politicians who had come to pay their respects to the slain grandmother. “It’s amazing that any time a black or Hispanic is killed like this, it’s police procedure,” said the Rev. Wendell Foster, who was then a Bronx City councilman. Sound familiar? One resident told the student investigators, “A couple of weeks ago a dangerous animal escaped from the Bronx Zoo, and they captured it with a sleep dart and brought it safely back to its cage in the zoo. Around here” said the resident, who requested anonymity for fear of police retribution, “cops treat black folks worse than zoo animals. They’ll risk their white skin to save an animal, but they’ll murder us on the spot.”

I have to believe that it was the thorough and unrelenting investigative work of the students, along with a local independent newspaper, The City Sun, that forced the court’s hand, making them deal with some of the real facts of the case, rather than let most of the local the racist corporate press marginalize Bumpurs as a community danger, a crazed black woman who was willing to kill a cop to avoid paying her back rent.

After reviewing extensive testimony, a grand jury indeed voted for an indictment for second-degree manslaughter against Officer Stephen Sullivan, who cut down Bumpurs at close range with two quick blasts from his department issued pump-style shotgun. However, subsequently, a state judge dismissed the indictment against Sullivan, asserting the evidence was “legally insufficient” to indict Sullivan for manslaughter or any other offense.

In an interview after the ruling, when asked if under similar circumstances he would do the same thing, Sullivan replied, “Yes, I would,” according to The New York Times. And New York City cops have been killing people of color non-stop before and since. Here’s a partial list published by The New York Times:

  • Jose (Kiko) Garcia, July 3, 1992: During a struggle with police officers in the lobby of an apartment building, Mr. Garcia, a 23-year-old Dominican immigrant who the police said was carrying a revolver, was shot twice by Officer Michael O’Keefe.
    What happened: Later that year, a grand jury cleared Officer O’Keefe, supporting the officer’s assertion that Mr. Garcia reached for a gun before he was shot.

  • Ernest Sayon, April 29, 1994: Mr. Sayon, 22, was standing outside a Staten Island housing complex when police officers on an anti-drug patrol tried to arrest him. Mr. Sayon suffocated because of pressure on his back, chest and neck while he was handcuffed on the ground.
    What happened: A grand jury declined to file criminal charges against any of the three police officers involved, apparently concluding that the officers had used reasonable force in subduing Mr. Sayon.

  • Nicholas Heyward Jr., Sept. 27, 1994: Nicholas, 13, was playing cops and robbers with friends in a Gowanus Houses building stairwell when Officer Brian George, mistaking the teenager’s toy rifle for a real gun, shot him to death.
    What happened: The Brooklyn district attorney decided not to present the case to a grand jury, saying the real culprit was an authentic-looking toy gun.

  • Anthony Baez, Dec. 22, 1994: Mr. Baez, 29, a security guard, was playing football outside his mother’s Bronx home when a stray toss landed on a police car. Mr. Baez died after an officer applied a chokehold while trying to arrest him.
    What happened: Francis X. Livoti, who had been dismissed by the force for using an illegal chokehold, was convicted on federal civil rights charges and sentenced to seven and a half years in prison, two years after he won acquittal in a state trial.

  • Amadou Diallo, Feb. 4, 1999: Mr. Diallo, a 22-year-old immigrant from Guinea, was killed by four officers who fired 41 times in the vestibule of his apartment building in the Bronx. They said he seemed to have a gun, but he was unarmed.
    What happened: In February 2000, after a tense and racially charged trial, all four officers, who were white, were acquitted of second-degree murder and other charges, fueling protests. The city agreed to pay the family $3 million.

  • Patrick Dorismond, March 16, 2000: Mr. Dorismond, 26, an unarmed black security guard, was shot dead by an undercover narcotics detective in a brawl in front of a bar in Midtown Manhattan, after Mr. Dorismond became offended when the detective asked him if he had any crack cocaine.
    What happened: By late July, a grand jury declined to file criminal charges against the detective, Anthony Vasquez, concluding that the shooting of Mr. Dorismond was not intentional. The city agreed to pay $2.25 million to his family.

  • Ousmane Zongo, May 23, 2003: Mr. Zongo, 43, an art restorer, was shot and killed by a police officer during a raid at a Chelsea warehouse that the police believed was the base of a CD counterfeiting operation.
    What happened: In 2005, Officer Bryan A. Conroy was convicted at the second of two trials and sentenced to probation. The judge placed the blame for the killing primarily on the poor training and supervision by the Police Department. The city agreed to pay the family $3 million.

  • Timothy Stansbury Jr., Jan. 24, 2004: Mr. Stansbury, 19, a high school student, was about to take a rooftop shortcut to a party when he was fatally shot by Officer Richard S. Neri Jr., who was patrolling the roof.
    What happened: A grand jury decided not to indict Officer Neri. In December 2006, he was suspended without pay for 30 days, permanently stripped of his gun, and reassigned to a property clerk’s office. The city agreed to pay the Stansbury family $2 million.

  • Sean Bell, Nov. 25, 2006: Five detectives fired 50 times into a car occupied by Mr. Bell, 23, and two others after a confrontation outside a Queens club on Mr. Bell’s wedding day. He was killed.
    What happened: After a heated seven-week nonjury trial in 2008, the judge found Detectives Gescard F. Isnora, Michael Oliver and Marc Cooper not guilty of all charges, which included manslaughter and assault. In 2012, Detective Isnora was fired, and Detectives Cooper and Oliver, along with a supervisor, were forced to resign. The city agreed to pay the family $3.25 million.

  • Ramarley Graham, Feb. 2, 2012: Mr. Graham, 18, was shot and killed by Richard Haste, a police officer, in the bathroom of his Bronx apartment after being pursued into his home by a team of officers from a plainclothes street narcotics unit. Mr. Graham was unarmed.
    What happened: A grand jury voted to indict Officer Haste on charges of first- and second-degree manslaughter, but a judge dismissed the indictment a year later. Prosecutors sought a new indictment. In August 2013, a grand jury decided not to bring charges in the case. The city agreed to pay the family $3.9 million.

  • Eric Garner, July 17, 2014: Mr. Garner, 43, died after Officer Daniel Pantaleo restrained him using a chokehold, a maneuver that was banned by the New York Police Department more than 20 years ago. The officers were trying to arrest Mr. Garner, whose death was attributed in part to the chokehold, on charges of illegally selling cigarettes.
    What happened: A grand jury, impaneled in September by the Staten Island district attorney, voted not to bring charges against Officer Pantaleo. The city agreed to pay the family $5.9 million.

  • Akai Gurley, Nov. 20, 2014: Mr. Gurley, 28, was entering the stairwell of a Brooklyn housing project with his girlfriend when Officer Peter Liang, standing 14 steps above him, shot Mr. Gurley in the chest. The police described the fatal shooting of Mr. Gurley, who was unarmed, as an accident.
    What happened: Officer Liang was found guilty of second-degree manslaughter on Feb. 11, 2016. He was then fired from the department. The Brooklyn district attorney did not seek jail time.

Dennis J Bernstein is the executive producer of Flashpoints, syndicated on Pacifica Radio, and is the recipient of a 2015 Pillar Award for his work as a journalist whistleblower. He is most recently the author of Special Ed: Voices from a Hidden Classroom.

Reader Supported News is the Publication of Origin for this work. Permission to republish is freely granted with credit and a link back to Reader Supported News. your social media marketing partner


A note of caution regarding our comment sections:

For months a stream of media reports have warned of coordinated propaganda efforts targeting political websites based in the U.S., particularly in the run-up to the 2016 presidential election.

We too were alarmed at the patterns we were, and still are, seeing. It is clear that the provocateurs are far more savvy, disciplined, and purposeful than anything we have ever experienced before.

It is also clear that we still have elements of the same activity in our article discussion forums at this time.

We have hosted and encouraged reader expression since the turn of the century. The comments of our readers are the most vibrant, best-used interactive feature at Reader Supported News. Accordingly, we are strongly resistant to interrupting those services.

It is, however, important to note that in all likelihood hardened operatives are attempting to shape the dialog our community seeks to engage in.

Adapt and overcome.

Marc Ash
Founder, Reader Supported News

+95 # CL38 2016-07-18 13:47
Couldn't bear to read through this partial list of those murdered by 'police'. If I can't bear to read it, what must it be to have been one of their victims?

If I had the means, I would leave this country I was born in, move to a saner part of the world, where people's rights are intact and we could live with humane economic and other life-affirming polices.
+34 # Missrayraythegreat 2016-07-18 17:54
I have mentioned this numerous times before and people look at me like I'm crazy. I've said this country is going to the shitter for years. Dual citizenship or renunciation... ? Decisions, decisions
+45 # Diane_Wilkinson_Trefethen_aka_tref 2016-07-18 18:08
The more I read about how our police have been killing people of color, the less I care when they are killed. I know I shouldn't feel that way but damn. They've been getting away with murder all these years. It is hard not to be cheered when what goes around finally comes back around.
-9 # Femihumanist 2016-07-18 18:36
Quoting tref:
The more I read about how our police have been killing people of color, the less I care when they are killed. I know I shouldn't feel that way but damn. They've been getting away with murder all these years. It is hard not to be cheered when what goes around finally comes back around.

All police are no more responsible for what some police than all Christians are responsible for what some do, all Jews are responsible for what some Jews (even those in Israel) do, all Americans are responsible for what the American Government does (including in the Middle East), etc. etc. etc.

What some, many, or even most people in any one demographic category do does not say anything about all or other members of the same demographic group.
+59 # Ted 2016-07-18 19:32
True, and well said.

However we are not facing a situation where a few rogue individual officers are occassionally acting against the expressed and clear position of the law enforcement community, this situation is long-term and systemic, and it IS the responsibilty of the entire law enforcement community to take quick and effective action to put an end to it now, if not long ago.

Anything less DOES make the entire police demographic complicit.

These ARE crimes, after all.
+44 # Ted 2016-07-18 19:35
And yes, we as Americans ARE all responsible for what our 'elected' government does.

It's way past time we took OUR responsibilitie s as citizens of a democracy seriously too.
+15 # Kootenay Coyote 2016-07-18 21:00
I guess the same went for all those poor, abused SS officers, eh?
+1 # Karlus58 2016-07-19 11:31
Hey...keep your head in the sand why don't ya!
+62 # Skyelav 2016-07-18 18:50
The horriffic thing is this: The police are gaining more power, not less, much to the joy of a certain population. The Media has convinced half of the American people that black men are the problem and people are scared and they don't care how it is cleaned up. The lynch mob is back. That demographic is meeting in Cleveland this week and one of their speakers in their theme of "Make America Safe," is "law and order" Guiliani. The results will be to divide the country in half with little chance of righting that wrong. The world has gone mad today, to quote a line from a song. I am sad.
+56 # Ted 2016-07-18 19:06
This has got to end.

I am begging the few sane people left in this nation to gather any strength we have and PULL THIS COUNTRY TO THE LEFT AS HARD AS WE CAN.

We cannot stop.
We cannot afford any more apathy.
We cannot go on like this.
+44 # lorenbliss 2016-07-18 22:17
I was still in the City when Eleanor Bumpurs was murdered, and I remember the case vividly.

As I recall, for us whites in Manhattan, the only accurate reporting -- that is, reporting that made it clear to us honkies she had been lynched by the cops -- was in the (pre-Murdoch) Village Voice and probably in The Guardian, a radical socialist weekly for which I sometimes worked as a freelancer.

(Historical note: this Guardian, an NYC publication, had no connection to The Manchester Guardian and died in 1992.)

Though Ms. Bumpurs never got justice, may she rest in peace. It is entirely proper she be remembered and eulogized again in this time of strife.

Hence my special thanks, one journalist to another, to Mr. Bernstein: well done.
+27 # CL38 2016-07-19 05:09
today's police are engaged in 21st century lynching.
+13 # janie1893 2016-07-19 00:00
Regrettably, as ye sow, so shall ye reap.
Who here is innocent?
+28 # tm7devils 2016-07-19 00:59
It seems that the belief of the police is to shoot first and then let God(the 'criminal' justice system) sort it out...which it does - by holding the police blameless. If this keeps up, fairly soon color won't be a consideration. Ignore the problem at your own peril.
+9 # runningtab 2016-07-19 06:02
I hope the NRA os feeling deep bite marks on its despicable ass. "Everyone gets to have a gun! Wait, we didn't mean black people ..."

I don't want more killing, of anyone, but as Janie reminded us, so shall ye reap. I won't be too sorry if the NRA leadership reaps a flesh wound or two ... and a barrage of terrifying moments of looking mortal fear in the face.
-1 # Ted 2016-07-19 10:34
"I hope the NRA os feeling deep bite marks on its despicable ass."

(between you and me I hope the nra decides that a nifty way to sell more guns is to promote russian roullette to the gun nuts as a popular "sport").
+13 # Nancy Jakeman 2016-07-19 07:37
I am troubled as to why people with beautiful dusky skin can be considered less equal. Remember the good Samaritan! It's time we loved each other without condition, don't you think? But I believe that the justice system in America has let everybody down. Private for profit prisons encourage incarceration and drop the humanitarian abilities, essence of goodness, of the police.
+7 # Johnny 2016-07-19 12:06
Killer cops are merely one aspect of imperialist U.S. political culture, in which violence is the answer to every question. It is interesting to note that in the list of police murders above, the only prosecutions of police occurred under Republican presidents.
-1 # Dr. Zinoviev 2016-07-19 18:23
Mr. lorenbush, When did you write for the Guardian (E 4th street or 17th)?
Did you contribute to the short lived "Liberated" Guardian?
+13 # Edwina 2016-07-20 08:55
Mr. Bernstein: Thank you for the list, grim as it is. Reminding us that these are human beings, with very human stories, makes it harder for police & politicians to promote the notion that "they got what they deserved". Recent rhetoric about respecting the police doesn't answer the challenge of Black Lives Matter, the ACLU, NAACP, and community groups: we must stop violent policing, which is exercised especially in communities of color.
+15 # librarian1984 2016-07-20 11:49
Most of us have never even heard these names. Even now it takes only a moment to read their story and then move along. But each one of them is a life that ended, affecting other lives and communities, rippling out into our society. All the violence and intimidation.

Instead of buying military equipment these police departments should spend that money on officers' mental health.
+8 # CL38 2016-07-20 23:03
+14 # Spud 2016-07-20 12:48
The problem that I see is that fellow police officers refuse to demand that racist, bigoted officers be fired. They don't want to
rat them out. Also, in general, the majority of citizens in the USA do not demand that racists and bigots be fired from the police departments of the USA. They might not be racists, but they tolerate racists in their police departments and in their neighborhoods and in their legislative bodies. Racists are not called on the carpet for their attitudes and behaviors.
I don't know if Donald Trump is a racist or not, but I do know that he very much wants the votes of the racists around the USA.
+15 # Jump Off Joe 2016-07-20 13:29
If Trump isn't a racist, he's certainly doing a fine job imitating one!
+1 # John S. Browne 2016-07-27 19:15

What have we seen since the murderous abuses at the hands of police that took place across the country in the time of this defenseless black American woman, Eleanor Bumpurs, but increasing police and U.S. federal government abuses, especially since 9-11 and its being used as a major pretext to lock the entire U.S. down more and more, and outwardly eliminate our human rights and civil liberties? In other words, it has only gotten worse and worse and worse; and, as long as the U.S. continues to increasingly deteriorate into a corporate-fasci st totalitarian militarized police state as it is doing, we will only see the abuses of the federal, state and local governments and their police agencies and forces continue to increase, and get more and more oppressive and repressive.

The U.S. federal, state and local governments are already getting increasingly repressive, as seen by the escalation rather than abatement of federal, state and local police forces' murders of unarmed citizens; and, in the cases of those they don't outright murder, torture of suspects, as well as coerced "confessions" and pleas of "guilt", criminalization , railroading and imprisonment of same, nationwide; all of which is only getting much worse as time goes on.

(Continued below)
0 # John S. Browne 2016-07-27 19:15

We as a people are thus without a doubt being increasingly locked-down and imprisoned all across the country in a vast open-air prison surrounded mostly by "invisible" walls and/or fences. And our minds are being imprisoned more and more as well, as our liberty(ies), freedom(s) and rights are being outwardly eviscerated. As a result, most Americans are blind to what is really going on; and, because they are so acclimated and brainwashed, and/or conditioned, dumbed-down, false-propagand ized, indoctrinated and programmed, to accept this completely-into lerable state of affairs, most of them are willingly surrendering to, and even supporting, our demise as a free country, and to our increasing "totalitarianiz ation", enslavement, imprisonment and complete subjugation.

(Continued below)
0 # John S. Browne 2016-07-27 19:16

It is absolutely disgusting to watch this rapidly escalating degeneration of our once relatively-free country into a corporate-fasci st totalitarian militarized police state, and its people's acceptance thereof, bowing-down and capitulation thereto, and even support thereof. It is truly disheartening and scary to observe this cowardly surrender to total subjugation and enslavement (the opposite of Truly Free), as the entire country is speedily heading towards hell on earth on an express train to same; and it leaves the minority of those who are facing this deterioration, and the capitulation thereto as if it's "acceptable", "inevitable" and "normal", gasping at the sheer rapidity and apparent finality of it all.


THE NEW STREAMLINED RSN LOGIN PROCESS: Register once, then login and you are ready to comment. All you need is a Username and a Password of your choosing and you are free to comment whenever you like! Welcome to the Reader Supported News community.