RSN Fundraising Banner
FB Share
Email This Page
add comment

Cummins writes: "Monsanto has begun secretly lobbying its Congressional allies to attach one or more “Monsanto Riders” or amendments to the 2013 Farm Bill that would preempt or prohibit states from requiring labels on genetically engineered (GE) foods."

 Genetically modified (GM) crops. (illustration: Melvyn Calderon/Greenpeace)
Genetically modified (GM) crops. (illustration: Melvyn Calderon/Greenpeace)

Genetically Modified Democracy

By Ronnie Cummins, Organic Consumers Association

20 May 13


eliable sources in Washington D.C. have informed the Organic Consumers Association (OCA) that Monsanto has begun secretly lobbying its Congressional allies to attach one or more "Monsanto Riders" or amendments to the 2013 Farm Bill that would preempt or prohibit states from requiring labels on genetically engineered (GE) foods.

In response to this blatant violation of states' rights to legislate, and consumers' right to know, the OCA and a nationwide alliance have launched a petition to put every member of Congress on notice: If you support any Farm Bill amendment that would nullify states' rights to label genetically modified organisms (GMOs), we'll vote - or throw - you out of office.

On Wednesday, May 15, an amendment to the House version of the Farm Bill, inserted under the guise of protecting interstate commerce, passed out of the House Agricultural Committee. If the King Amendment makes it into the final Farm Bill, it would take away states' rights to pass laws governing the production or manufacture of any agricultural product, including food and animals raised for food, that is involved in interstate commerce. The amendment was proposed by Rep. Steve King (R-Iowa), largely in response to a California law stating that by 2015, California will allow only eggs to be sold from hens housed in cages specified by California. But policy analysts emphasize that the amendment, broadly and ambiguously written, could be used to prohibit or preempt any state GMO labeling or food safety law.

Will the King Amendment survive the Senate? No one can be sure, say analysts. However few doubt that Monsanto will give up. We can expect that more amendments and riders will be introduced into the Farm Bill--even if the King Amendment fails-over the next month in an attempt to stop the wave of state GMO labeling laws and initiatives moving forward in states like Washington, Vermont, Maine, Connecticut and others.

Monsanto and the Grocery Manufacturers Association (GMA) have admitted privately that they've "lost the battle" to stop GE food labeling at the state level, now that states are aggressively moving forward on labeling laws. On May 14, Maine's House Ag Committee passed a GMO labeling law. On May 10, the Vermont House passed a labeling bill, 99-42, despite massive lobbying by Monsanto and threats to sue the state. And though Monsanto won a razor-thin victory (51 percent to 49 percent) in a costly, hard fought California GMO labeling ballot initiative last November, biotech and Big Food now realize that Washington State voters will likely pass I-522, an upcoming ballot initiative to label GE foods, on November 5.

If Monsanto can't stop states from passing laws, then the next step is a national preemptive measure. And all signs point to just such a power grab. Earlier this year, Monsanto slipped its extremely unpopular "Monsanto Protection Act," an act that gives biotech immunity from federal prosecution for planting illegally approved GE crops, into the 2013 Federal Appropriations Bill. During the June 2012 Farm Bill debate, 73 U.S. Senators voted against the right of states to pass mandatory GE food labeling laws. Emboldened by these votes, and now the House Ag Committee's vote on the King Amendment, Monsanto has every reason to believe Congress would support a potential nullification of states' rights to label.

The million-strong OCA and its allies in the organic and natural health movement are warning incumbent Senators and House members, Democrats and Republicans alike, that thousands of health and environmental-minded constituents in their Congressional districts or states will work to recall them or drive them out of office if they fail to heed the will of the people and to respect the time-honored traditions of shared state sovereignty over food labels, food safety laws, and consumers' right to know.

Trouble in Monsanto Nation.

Over the past 20 years Monsanto and the biotech industry, aided and abetted by indentured politicians and corporate agribusiness, have begun seizing control over the global food and farming system, including the legislative, patent, trade, judicial and regulatory bodies that are supposed to safeguard the public interest.

In the U.S., despite mounting evidence of the damage GE crops inflict on human health and the environment, approximately 170 million acres of GE crops, including corn, soybeans, cotton, canola, sugar beets, alfalfa, papaya, and squash, are currently under cultivation. These crops, untested and unlabeled, comprise 41 percent of all cultivated cropland, or 17 percent of all cropland and pastureland combined. According to the GMA, at least 70 percent of non-organic grocery store processed foods contain GMOs. And GE grains and mill byproducts now supply the overwhelming majority of animal feed on the factory farms that supply 90 percent to 95 percent of the meat, eggs and dairy products that Americans consume.

Yet despite their marketplace dominance, record profits and enormous political clout in Washington D.C., Monsanto and the biotech industry are in deep trouble. Evidence is mounting that Monsanto's top-selling herbicide, Roundup, is a deadly poison, destroying important human gut bacteria and likely contributing to the rapid increase of food allergies and serious human diseases including cancer, autism, neurological disorders , Attention Deficit Hyperactive Disorder (ADHD), dementia, Alzheimer's, schizophrenia and bipolar disorder. Those most susceptible to poisoning by Monsanto's Roundup are children and the elderly.

Scientists aren't the only ones raising new questions about Roundup. Farmers are complaining that they're being forced to spray more and more chemicals on crops increasingly under siege from a growing army of herbicide-resistant weeds. The situation is so bad that the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) just raised the limits of Roundup residue allowed on grains and vegetables to even more dangerous levels. But just in case the EPA someday stops raising the limits, Monsanto, Dow and the biotech industry are working on a new "solution" to the onslaught of herbicide-resistant Superweeds: They've applied for approval of a new and highly controversial generation of super toxic herbicide-resistant GE crops, including "Agent Orange" (2,4-D and dicamba-resistant) corn, soybeans and cotton.

As a recent widely-circulated article points out,

"The use of 2,4-D is not new; it's actually one of the most widely used herbicides in the world. What is new is that farmers will now 'carpet bomb' staple food crops like soy and corn with this chemical at a previously unprecedented scale-just the way glyphosate has been indiscriminately applied as a result of Roundup Ready crops. In fact, if 2,4-D resistant crops receive approval and eventually come to replace Monsanto's failing Roundup-resistant crops as Dow intends, it is likely that billions of pounds will be needed, on top of the already insane levels of Roundup being used (1.6 billion lbs were used in 2007 in the US alone)."

In addition to these Agent Orange crops, an expanded menu of genetically engineered organisms are awaiting approval. Next on the menu? GE apples, trees, and salmon.

State Labeling Laws: The 'skull and crossbones' that terrify Monsanto

Monsanto's greatest fear isn't a federal government charged with protecting the health and safety of its citizens. Congress and the White House seem only too happy to oblige the biotech industry's unquenchable thirst for growth, power and dominance. No, it's the massive, unstoppable (so far) grassroots movement of Millions Against Monsanto that strikes fear in the heart of the Biotech Bully. U.S. citizens are waking up. They're demanding labels on genetically engineered foods, similar to those already required in the European Union. They're calling for serious independent safety-testing of GE crops and animals, both those already approved (especially Monsanto's Roundup-resistant crops) and those awaiting approval.

The anti-GMO movement has finally figured out, after 20 years of fruitlessly lobbying Congress, the FDA and the White House, that the federal government is not going to require labels on GE foods. Instead the movement has shifted the battleground on GMO labeling from Monsanto and Big Food's turf in Washington D.C. to the more favorable terrain of state ballot initiatives and state legislative action-publicizing the fact that a state GMO labeling law will have the same marketplace impact as a national labeling law.

State laws spell doom for Monsanto. Companies like Kellogg's, General Mills, Coca-Cola, Pepsi/Frito-Lay, Dean Foods, Unilever, Con-Agra, Safeway, Wal-Mart and Smuckers are not going to label in just one or two states. Monsanto knows that U.S. food companies will go GMO-free in the entire U.S., rather than admit to consumers that their products contain GMOs.

As Monsanto itself has pointed out, labels on genetically engineered foods are like putting a "skull and crossbones" on food packages. This is why Monsanto and their allies poured $46 million into defeating a California ballot initiative last year that would have required labels on GMO foods. This is why Monsanto has lobbied strenuously in 30 states this year to prevent, or at least delay, state mandatory labeling laws from being passed. This is why Monsanto has threatened to file federal lawsuits against Vermont, Connecticut, Maine and Washington if they dare grant citizens the right to know whether or not their food has been genetically engineered or not.

And this is why Monsanto's minions are trying to insert amendments or riders into the Farm Bill that will make it nearly impossible, even illegal, for states to pass GMO labeling laws. And there's nothing to stop them when Congress is filled with pro-biotech cheerleaders who could care less that 90 percent of U.S. consumers want mandatory labels and proper safety testing of genetically engineered crops and foods.

Countering Monsanto's Final Offensive: Throw the Bums Out!

Only a massive grassroots resistance will deter the U.S. Senate and House from stomping on our rights. Only an unprecedented campaign of public education, petition-gathering and grassroots pressure will be able to convince the ever-more corrupt and indentured politicians in Washington D.C. to back off.

Eighteen state constitutions have century-old provisions for state registered voters to collect petitions and recall state and local officials, forcing them to either resign or stand for reelection. But what very few Americans, and even members of Congress, realize is that 11 states have constitutional provisions to recall U.S. Senators and House of Representative members, as well as state elected officials.

It's time we exercise the full power of direct democracy, not just state and municipal ballot initiatives. We must continue to support efforts like the current state ballot initiative to label GMOs in Washington state, and county ballot initiatives to ban GMOs, factory farms and other corporate crimes, in the 24 states and hundreds of counties and municipalities where these are allowed. But we also need to use the power we have to recall and throw out of office our out-of-control Congressional Senators and Representatives as well.

If our elected officials in Congress continue to represent Monsanto and big corporations, rather than their constituents, then let's throw the bums out! If the Washington political Establishment, both Democrats and Republicans, continue to trample on our inalienable constitutional rights and contemptuously disregard the 225-year principle of a shared balance of power between the federal government, the states and local government, then we have no choice but to recall them or throw them out of office.

Please join the nation's organic consumers and natural health advocates in this strategic battle, the Food Fight of Our Lives. Please join this campaign to save, not only our right to choose what's in our food, but our basic right to democratic representation and self-determination as well. Sign the petition. Tell your Congressmen and women, especially the 73 incumbents who voted last year to eliminate states rights' to legislate on GMO labels, and those in the House this week who voted to support the King Amendment that "enough is enough," " basta ya." Power to the People! your social media marketing partner


A note of caution regarding our comment sections:

For months a stream of media reports have warned of coordinated propaganda efforts targeting political websites based in the U.S., particularly in the run-up to the 2016 presidential election.

We too were alarmed at the patterns we were, and still are, seeing. It is clear that the provocateurs are far more savvy, disciplined, and purposeful than anything we have ever experienced before.

It is also clear that we still have elements of the same activity in our article discussion forums at this time.

We have hosted and encouraged reader expression since the turn of the century. The comments of our readers are the most vibrant, best-used interactive feature at Reader Supported News. Accordingly, we are strongly resistant to interrupting those services.

It is, however, important to note that in all likelihood hardened operatives are attempting to shape the dialog our community seeks to engage in.

Adapt and overcome.

Marc Ash
Founder, Reader Supported News

+18 # jwb110 2013-05-20 09:44
Chances are if you cut out Wheat, Corn, Soy, eggs, dairy, peanuts and sugar you are just going to feel better anyway. There are many items to fill in what "gaps" people merely believe are there.
I think that boycotting businesses outside of Monsanto products might bring pressure to bear from inside the Agro business. When goods like CA Wines, All Wheat Products not for the final product but for the source of the wheat, never use soy in any form not merely bean curd, if you must use herbicides switch from Round-Up to some other product, no more Sarah Lee and then let these many companies know. Be sure to check all labels for ingredients that include the above and right them off your list.
A couple of things will happen: you'll loose weight because much of this GE food makes for weight gain, you'll probably feel better as a human and as a citizen who is taking back their Right to Know.
If we can get Agro-Corps by the wallet their hearts and minds will follow.
+26 # moonrigger 2013-05-20 10:05
Finally, after decades of struggling against these behemoths, the people are gaining. Go to to find out more about how Monsanto and the biopirates have been trying to take complete control of our food supply in ever-increasing ly underhanded ways. Yes, let's VOTE OUT any congressperson who goes along with this travesty. The power is ours, but only if we take it.
+7 # czechmate53 2013-05-20 10:20
which 11 states have constitutional provisions to recall U.S. Senators and House of Representative members?
+2 # Thirdeye 2013-05-20 14:29
[Senators]: "The 18 states allowing for recall are as follows: Alaska, Arizona, California, Colorado, Georgia, Idaho, Kansas, Louisiana, Michigan, Minnesota, Montana, Nevada, New Jersey, North Dakota, Oregon, Rhode Island, Washington and Wisconsin."
-http://www.dem ocraticundergro /duboard.php?az =view_all&addre ss=389x2201861
0 # Thirdeye 2013-05-20 14:35
I can find references to "11 states have provisions to recall members of congress", but not a list. Anybody?
+13 # RLF 2013-05-20 10:36
We need to get the names and addresses of Monsanto bosses and investors out there so we can picket their houses and embarrass them in their neighborhoods. These people are all about prestige and anything that removes that will get action.
+17 # George Orwell 2013-05-20 11:43
We must now face the fact that our government has become corporate/milit ary controlled. The only way to bring back democracy is to let everyone know what's going on. Join the May 25 world-wide march against Monsanto. Google it for the location in your area. And, yes, boycot GMO companies, write your pols to tell them you won't stand for any support of Monsanto, and please do support any state with labeling laws up for votes.
+5 # James Marcus 2013-05-20 11:45
Monsanto, all the other 'Big' Corps, together with Their Representatives in Congress (majority of House and Senate), most all The Big Banks, and Major Media , are ALL ...working for 'The Big Money'. Just 'doing their jobs' (for a Cut of the Booty)....
The Big Money Folk work through their 'Conduits', never really liking the Lime -Light, Themselves.
Just saying, because 'Monsanto' is expendable/repl aceable, Just like all individual 'conduits'.
Terminate one, The Game.... Still Goes On.....
The Heart of the Beast....anothe r matter!
+9 # Todd Williams 2013-05-20 12:23
I'd like to force feed Roundup to all Monsabnto execs. Tie the fuckers up and shove that crap down their throats. I'm mad as hell. When in the hell are we going to wake up and stop these a-holes from destroying our planet and our lives? People who go along with Monsanto and other big ag businesses are fools. And they could care less about the average person.
0 # RnR 2013-05-23 07:50
I agree. These pieces of festered human waste have an outstanding history of lying, falsifying test results, destroying scientists who will not bow to them and generally not giving a crap about anything but their profits. They will stop at nothing.
+1 # ecovortx 2013-05-20 13:21
Watched Moyers Journal. There were two woman being interviewed. One was from and the other (interview on that sight). If we are to bring power back to the common man, we have to be involved and work as 1. 1and1is1.
+4 # SheilaParks 2013-05-20 13:29
Organic Consumers Association has done great work over the years and I gave money to them for some time.I stopped when I realized that no matter what many of us said to OCA and Cummins - that many of our elections are rigged and there is no way of knowing what is going on - even our recounts are rigged. It is most likely that Prop 37 in CA was rigged, and as far as I can tell right now, the recount was bungled from our side. Feh. We cannot throw the bums out unless we have honest elections. No money from me for yet another worthless exercise on futility that wants even more money from us now.
+6 # AMLLLLL 2013-05-20 19:30
I'm not sure Prop 37 was rigged, but Monsanto spent $millions in CA making scare tactic ads. If another ballot initiative comes up it will probably pass, especially if WA passes theirs. There needs to be push back on negative ads, calling them out for their deception.
+2 # ce429 2013-05-20 16:42
Time to reissue Michael Clayton. We're living it now.

THE NEW STREAMLINED RSN LOGIN PROCESS: Register once, then login and you are ready to comment. All you need is a Username and a Password of your choosing and you are free to comment whenever you like! Welcome to the Reader Supported News community.