RSN Fundraising Banner
FB Share
Email This Page
add comment

Fischer reports: "As Cruz addressed the conference, around 200 activists marched outside, waving signs reading 'A Legislator for Every Corporation' and chanting 'you can hear us loud and clear - we want ALEC out of here!'"

Sen. Ted Cruz told ALEC to 'stand its ground.' (photo: Carolyn Kaster/AP)
Sen. Ted Cruz told ALEC to 'stand its ground.' (photo: Carolyn Kaster/AP)

ALEC Stands Its Ground, but Stumbles

By Brendan Fischer, PR Watch

07 December 13


I'm proud to stand with ALEC today," declared Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas) on Thursday, as he addressed the American Legislative Exchange Council in Washington D.C.

"I first came to ALEC over a decade ago. When I was serving in the Bush administration, I'd been privileged to work with ALEC in the federal government," Cruz said. "I've been privileged to work with ALEC when I was back in Texas with the Texas Public Policy Foundation, leading the 10th Amendment Center."

As Cruz addressed the conference, around 200 activists marched outside, waving signs reading "A Legislator for Every Corporation" and chanting "you can hear us loud and clear -- we want ALEC out of here!"

Cruz (who became notorious for his effort to shutdown the government) was at ALEC to give its corporate lobbyists and state legislator members a pep talk. It was a rough week for the organization that has become known as a "corporate bill mill."

This week, The Guardian published ALEC documents demonstrating that the group has recently lost around 60 corporate members, largely as a result of its role in facilitating corporate influence over state legislators, and for pushing voter ID restrictions, climate change denial, and an array of other controversial, corporate-friendly bills. The documents show that ALEC misled its members about the strength of the organization, and misled the press about its plans for forming a 501(c)(4), and suffered a $1.4 million budget shortfall in the first half of 2013, largely as a result of losing corporate funders.

The corporate exodus began after revelations about ALEC's role in pushing "Stand Your Ground" legislation modeled after the law that helped George Zimmerman walk free after killing Trayvon Martin.

"My advice to ALEC is very, very simple," Sen. Cruz said, reflecting on public backlash against the organization. "Stand your ground."

"Sen. Cruz also recently insisted to the mothers of Trayvon Martin and Jordan Russell Davis that Stand Your Ground is good for Black people," said Rashad Robinson, Executive Director of ColorOfChange. "The Senator's doubling down on his ignorant and tone-deaf defense of these deadly laws -- and ALEC's responsibility for spreading them nationwide -- shows how disconnected ALEC's champions have become from reality."

"We Became More Transparent." Really?

ALEC does appear to be "standing their ground."

Rather than addressing many of the issues that have made ALEC so controversial, it has instead focused more aggressively on public relations. Last year, the group hired global PR firm Edelman, which made its mark representing the tobacco industry, and now represents oil and pharmaceutical interests. ALEC paid Edelman nearly $500,000 last year, according to tax filings. ALEC disbanded the Public Safety and Elections Task Force responsible for the spread of Stand Your Ground and voter ID, but has done nothing to promote the repeal of those laws.

ALEC has also hired a former Edelman executive, Bill Meierling, as their in-house Director of Public Affairs, and paid $118,000 to "public affairs" consultants during the first six months of 2013, according to a budget published by The Guardian.

Oddly, as ALEC tried to weather the storm this week, the notoriously secretive organization tried to change the discussion by touting its "transparency."

"We became more transparent" in 2013, reads the first page of the meeting agenda. ALEC is "focused on transparency," ALEC said in a statement released this week.

ALEC is "moving towards transparency," said its spokesperson Meierling, as he refused press credentials to Mother Jones reporter Andy Kroll.

ALEC's Meierling also touted the organization's "transparency" as it barred Washington Post reporter Dana Milbank from attending the task force meetings where corporate lobbyists and state legislators vote as equals on model bills. "Our business meetings are not open, and so the subcommittee meetings and task force meetings are not open," Meierling told Milbank.

"What you fundamentally need to know about this organization is it's completely legislator driven," Meierling told him.

"Uh-huh," Milbank wrote. "And ALEC is proving that by keeping reporters from the rooms where the legislators are or are not receiving their marching orders from corporate patrons."

The Guardian also revealed new angles to ALEC's effort to evade state transparency laws.

Legislators who serve as ALEC State Chairs would be required to "inform ALEC of any public records/FOIA requests that include ALEC documents," according to a draft agreement.

As CMD has previously reported, this fits into a larger pattern of ALEC trying to keep its communications with lawmakers secret.

Despite ALEC's claims that "we became more transparent" in 2013, this year, ALEC began stamping the materials it gives to legislators with a "disclaimer" asserting that the documents are not subject to any state's open records law. ALEC has also been sending communications to legislators via an online dropbox, which it admitted in June was an effort to try to evade disclosure under open records laws. In Texas, ALEC even went so far as to formally ask that its communications with lawmakers be exempt from the state's Public Information Act, making the absurd claim that sunshine laws threaten its "freedom of association" rights. Attorney General Greg Abbott, a Republican, rejected this claim in September.

ALEC Supports Local Control?

Another odd piece of spin from ALEC was its stated commitment to local control. "People are better served by local leaders," said American Legislative Exchange Council National Chair Linda Upmeyer, a State Representative from Iowa, at Wednesday's luncheon.

ALEC's record sure doesn't suggest much faith in local democracy -- at least when local governments threaten the profits of ALEC's corporate backers. For example:

  • The ALEC "Municipal Telecommunications Private Industry Safeguards Act" would thwart local control by prohibiting city and county governments from establishing municipal broadband; the bill, which is a boon for ALEC members like AT&T, has become law in nineteen states.
  • At ALEC's August 2011 meeting, legislators were handed a Wisconsin bill to preempt local efforts to guarantee paid sick days for workers; after that, paid sick days preemption bills have spread across the country and been introduced in twelve other states, in most cases sponsored by an ALEC legislator, and with the backing of ALEC members like the National Restaurant Association.
  • The ALEC "Living Wage Mandate Preemption Act" would prohibit local governments from enacting a minimum wage ordinance that exceeds the statewide minimum; a discussion on minimum wage was also on the agenda for this year's meeting, as workers across the country walk out of fast food jobs to advocate for a minimum wage increase.
  • The "State Pesticide Preemption Act" would bar local leaders from protecting the health of their communities by limiting the types of pesticides that can be used within city or county limits, and the "Biotechnology State Uniformity Resolution" calls for preemption of local GMO bans, both of which protect the profits of the corporations represented by ALEC member CropLife America.
  • ALEC also has adopted legislation to preempt local leaders from enacting labor peace agreements and rent controls.
  • In one of the last acts of the now-disbanded Public Safety and Elections Task Force, ALEC even adopted a bill to prohibit local governments from banning machine guns or other firearms in their communities.

Perhaps not surprisingly, there are some indications that ALEC's claimed dedication to "local control" may actually have nothing to do with support for local democracy.

In a workshop at the ALEC meeting, Michael Farris, a Senior Fellow at the group Citizens for Self-Governance, advised ALEC members on messaging, and warned against the use of terms like "states rights."

"It's not about states rights, it's about local control," he said.

States rights is associated with slavery, Farris said, but by using terms like "local control," "you just steer the language in the proper direction." your social media marketing partner


A note of caution regarding our comment sections:

For months a stream of media reports have warned of coordinated propaganda efforts targeting political websites based in the U.S., particularly in the run-up to the 2016 presidential election.

We too were alarmed at the patterns we were, and still are, seeing. It is clear that the provocateurs are far more savvy, disciplined, and purposeful than anything we have ever experienced before.

It is also clear that we still have elements of the same activity in our article discussion forums at this time.

We have hosted and encouraged reader expression since the turn of the century. The comments of our readers are the most vibrant, best-used interactive feature at Reader Supported News. Accordingly, we are strongly resistant to interrupting those services.

It is, however, important to note that in all likelihood hardened operatives are attempting to shape the dialog our community seeks to engage in.

Adapt and overcome.

Marc Ash
Founder, Reader Supported News

+23 # Feral Dogz 2013-12-07 12:04
ALEC is the heart of fascism in Amerika. This group should be outlawed, as Nazism is in Germany.

Standing their ground and doubling down on their policies promoting corporate greed, voter disenfranchisem ent and global warming denial while hiding behind a completely transparent sham of transparency doesn't seem to be working for them, so perhaps they will simply wither and die from corporate abandonment as boycotts and shareholder protests seem to be gaining momentum.

Google ALEC, check out their corporate and legislative members, then boycott the products and vote out the thieves and liars. Hit them where it hurts!
+2 # Jim Young 2013-12-08 20:03
They aren't withering and dying, so much as relabeling new and varied effective franchises like the State Policy Network (local sounding names within states, sometime more than one per state), and the "Jeffersonian Project," (according to They are harder to kill than Vampires, Zombies, or whatever new names they come up with to do their dark-money dirty work.
+15 # bingers 2013-12-07 12:29
ALEC needs to die and every member should have their corporate charters revoked and all their assets should go to the treasury.
+8 # AMLLLLL 2013-12-07 15:18
I love the titles of the bills they come up with; kind of like the Patriot Act, an abrogation of our 4th Amendment rights. ALEC, along with the other corporate interests, have made a MOCKERY of the democratic system.
+11 # Jim Young 2013-12-07 15:52
Seems they don't like it when we "stand our ground" against their secretive attacks on our system, and unconscionable power grabs.

They are not "standing their ground" they are seriously walking all over ours and claiming it for their sponsors.

Besides fighting them by all legal means possible, I will do my best to stay away from their sponsors and their products, and supporting the local businesses that tell them to get lost.
+7 # Unicorn144 2013-12-07 22:55
Like the Nazi Party we must remember: everything Hitler did to come to power was "legal" in that he and his industrialist corporate sponsors evaded and nullified all the government's controls against their kind of "invisible" dismantling of the democratic process and lawful system of monitoring political organizations in place in Germany at the time....

THE NEW STREAMLINED RSN LOGIN PROCESS: Register once, then login and you are ready to comment. All you need is a Username and a Password of your choosing and you are free to comment whenever you like! Welcome to the Reader Supported News community.