RSN Fundraising Banner
FB Share
Email This Page
add comment

Excerpt: "In a dramatic action to symbolize that 'our mountains that have been stripped of everything living on them, and in solidarity with our people, who are sick and dying and dead because of this practice,' Mullens and a group of coalfield mothers, daughters and activists will shave their heads to call out the bald face complicity of Big Coal-bankrolled state politicians and the denial of the devastating health and human rights violations in coal mining communities."

The practice of mountaintop removal to extract coal has devastating impacts on the environment and communities. (photo: TheBolderReporter)
The practice of mountaintop removal to extract coal has devastating impacts on the environment and communities. (photo: TheBolderReporter)

Appalachian Women Lead Dramatic Protest Against Mountaintop Removal

By Jeff Biggers, AlterNet

25 May 12


fter serving her country as a major in the U.S. Army for 22 years, tending to injured soldiers as a case manager in other parts of the country, registered nurse Marilyn Mullens is now leading a group of her fellow Appalachian women to the West Virginia state capitol on Memorial Day to protest the growing humanitarian crisis of mountaintop removal mining.

In a dramatic action to symbolize that “our mountains that have been stripped of everything living on them, and in solidarity with our people, who are sick and dying and dead because of this practice,” Mullens and a group of coalfield mothers, daughters and activists will shave their heads to call out the bald face complicity of Big Coal-bankrolled state politicians and the denial of the devastating health and human rights violations in coal mining communities.

“We’ve gone through all the official channels of every level of our state government, we’ve been to DC, nothing is being done,” Mullens said in a press release. “Silence is louder than words. We’ve talked and talked and talked, but it hasn’t gotten us where we need to be with this issue. You have air pollution, water pollution, the destruction of so many living things - it’s a bigger deal than people think. I mean they are actually destroying a culture of people. It’s not what my grandparents would have wanted. And I know, the old coal miners, they don’t like it - they think it is horrible. We are the majority but our voices are drowned out by big coal money. It’s like they shove their money down our throats. The politicians completely ignore us.”

While state politicians, including Gov. Earl Ray Tomblin, often cry that President Obama has carried out a war on coal in central Appalachian states, the truth is that coal mining jobs have actually increased to ranks not seen since 1993, and mountaintop removal operations have not slowed to a trickle, as Big Coal sycophants claim.

The real casualties in coal mining communities, as Mullens and other mothers point out, are children, women, the elderly, and other residents living on the toxic frontlines of strip mining fallout.

The Appalachian Community Health Emergency campaign, launched earlier this spring to lobby for an immediate moratorium on mountaintop removal operations,noted:

Babies born to mothers who smoke during pregnancy HAVE AN 18 PERCENT HIGHER RISK OF BIRTH DEFECTS; however, babies born to mothers who live in areas with mountain top removal mining HAVE A 26 PERCENT HIGHER RATE OF BIRTH DEFECTS. Additionally, it was found that this risk is 42 PERCENT HIGHER OVER THE COURSE OF THE STUDY PERIOD FROM YEARS 2000-2003 and 181 PERCENT HIGHER DURING MORE RECENT YEARS, SPECIFICALLY FOR A HEART OR LUNG DEFECT. (Ahern, MM, et al, Environ. Res., (2011), DOI: 10.1016/j.envres.2011.05.19)

In advance of Monday’s silent protest, Mullens agreed to answer a few questions on her coal mining community and background, mountaintop removal and the role of women in Appalachia today:

Jeff Biggers: Can you describe your Boone County community, the level of strip mining and the general impact of Mountaintop Removal (MTR) on your daily lives?

Marilyn Mullens: The community I grew up in is your typical coal mining hollow in Appalachia. The hollow was four miles long and many people lived in row houses that were almost by its side. Being a child there was wonderful. The mountains were our playgrounds. We built cabins, played in creeks and did a lot of exploring. I moved back to this hollow in 1993 with my two young children. In the latter part of the ’90s the coal companies began doing MTR on both mountains that surrounded the hollow. There were extremely loud blasts that would shake pictures right off your walls. Large trucks traveled the once quiet road carrying heavy equipment. There was a fine gray dust that covered everything. It was even hard to have any flowers on your porch in the summer because the dust would just cover the leaves. You literally had to pressure wash your house about every two weeks to get the dust off of your windows, etc. People’s homes were damaged, and even though the coal companies said they would “make good” on any damage when it came down to it they would usually find a way to say they were not responsible. In 2001 we had a heavy rain. The hollow flooded and many of my friends and family lost their homes. Most people know it was due to the MTR. Not many people there have education past high school, but we are not stupid. We know that when you clear cut all the trees and vegetation, then get rid of the top soil and bury the natural course of the streams there is nothing there to hold or guide the water. Plus they build big “ponds” back on the mountain that are held back by earth and these broke free. Once again, the coal company said the floods were “an act of god.” Honestly, sometimes you feel as though you are in a war zone when you live in the middle of MTR.

JB: What’s the symbolism of shaving your head? A reference to cancer corridors in the coalfields - as you know, a door to door survey of 769 adults found that the cancer rate was twice as high in a community exposed to mountaintop removal mining compared to a non-mining control community - or a broader view of the denuding and stripping of the Appalachian mountains, or something else?

MM: For me, shaving my head will show the pain I feel when I see what is being done to not only our mountains but our people. These mountains have so much life in them and when they do MTR ALL of that life is stripped away. Studies show that MTR is making our people sick. They are sick and dying and it seems that for most, our lives are not worth their electricity and the money that “big coal” puts into people’s pockets. I guess I am hoping that by shaving my hair I will show that I will do something very drastic to get someone’s attention that might be able to help us stop this horrible practice.

JB: How do you see this action as part of a long-term movement to raise awareness of the egregious impacts of MTR and the need to abolish the practice?

MM: There have been Appalachians fighting this for many years before I got involved. People like Larry GibsonMaria Gunnoeudy BondsBo Webb andLorelei Scarbro. These are the people that have been in the trenches paving the way for the rest of us. Giving us the courage to have a voice. I only see the movement growing. I had a co-worker approach me early this week that had never seen MTR up close. She and her friends happened upon a site and when they questioned the guard that was blocking the road due to blasting why they could not travel a road that they always travel to a friend’s house he responded, “I guess you’re some of the activist people.” Her response was, “no actually, not until now.” So there are still Appalachian people that have no idea the extent of the devastation. I think the more eyes we get open the more the movement will grow. Sooner or later the shear volume of us will have to make someone listen.

JB: Considering that MTR effectively began in 1970 in Raleigh County - of course, strip mining has been going on for over a century - do you consider yourself a daughter and a mother of the “mountaintop removal generation” and its fallout in your communities, and how do you discuss it with your children and family?

MM: Yes, I consider myself a daughter and a mother. My parents still live in the coal fields where this is happening. Their lives are in danger every time they go to Whitesville to grocery shop. At any time I expect to hear that the Brushy Fork impoundment (coal slurry earthen dam holding over eight billion gallons of toxic coal slurry) has broken free and people are dead. My children lived right in the middle of the MTR breathing the dust for several years. I wonder what long term effects it will have on their respiratory system. I have always taught my children to live a healthy lifestyle. I never let them be exposed to cigarette smoke, encouraged a healthy, low-fat diet and exercise but I had no control over the dust they breathed for many years. The underground miners are provided with respirators but the people living in the valleys where the dust settles are not afforded that luxury. My immediate family is against MTR and they support my being active in stopping it, but they are afraid for me. There have been threats and acts of violence towards many people in this fight. I worry sometimes about repercussions towards my parents, who are getting along in years and still living in the middle of it all, but I explain to them that I feel compelled to fight this not only for them but for all the people in West Virginia. Especially the children. I want our children to be able to live here and know the mountains I knew growing up.

JB: Speak a little about the role of Judy Bonds and other women in taking a leading role to stop strip mining and MTR, and confront corruption in West Virginia?

MM: Very hard to speak of Judy without tears in my eyes. I did not know her personally but as heroes go she is a TRUE HERO. She was brave enough to stand up when standing up was out of the question. She, Maria Gunnoe and Lorelei Scarbro are all from my community and I have more admiration for them than I can put into words and I thank them for their bravery.

Appalachian women have always held a strength beyond measure. My grandmother was born and raised in West Virginia and she never backed down from a fight and I know she would be mad as hell about what is going on here. So part of what I do I do in her memory and I hear her saying, “you stand up for what is right no matter what because at night time you have to be able to lay your head down and sleep.” I feel like there is so much corruption in this state in all aspects of our government and law enforcement and the root of all of it is the money that the coal industry keeps putting in their pockets. It will come out sooner or later though. We will see to it.

JB: During the 2008 presidential campaign, Hillary Clinton told West Virginians she was concerned, but that perhaps we could find ways to reclaim the land after MTR operations. How would you respond to her now?

MM: “Wreck” lamation is a joke. There is no reclamation. I am convinced that if a value were put on the diverse vegetation that grows in our mountains it would far outweigh the coal that lies within them. We have a biodiversity only second to the Rain Forests and it’s being destroyed. My grandmother told me once when we were in the mountains digging ramps that these mountains are magical. She said, “they have everything you need to survive in them” and I don’t think she was talking about coal. When you strip them of their topsoil and use “spray on” grass to cover the mess you might fool some people, but if you take a closer look it just looks like death all over the place. Nothing grows for very long on an MTR site.

JB: Other comments?

MM: I would hope that any person reading this educates themselves as to what is going on. If nothing else, know that everything goes downstream and these mountains filter a lot of water for a lot of people and they’re being destroyed. So even if you think that the people in Appalachia are “dumb hillbillies,” take a minute to think about what is being sacrificed so you can turn on a light. Take a minute to see what your role is in not only destroying ancient mountains, but a culture of people. Take a minute to care. your social media marketing partner


A note of caution regarding our comment sections:

For months a stream of media reports have warned of coordinated propaganda efforts targeting political websites based in the U.S., particularly in the run-up to the 2016 presidential election.

We too were alarmed at the patterns we were, and still are, seeing. It is clear that the provocateurs are far more savvy, disciplined, and purposeful than anything we have ever experienced before.

It is also clear that we still have elements of the same activity in our article discussion forums at this time.

We have hosted and encouraged reader expression since the turn of the century. The comments of our readers are the most vibrant, best-used interactive feature at Reader Supported News. Accordingly, we are strongly resistant to interrupting those services.

It is, however, important to note that in all likelihood hardened operatives are attempting to shape the dialog our community seeks to engage in.

Adapt and overcome.

Marc Ash
Founder, Reader Supported News

+20 # Bluesyinohio 2012-05-25 09:46
Alternative energy sources are needed NOW! I see railroad car after railroad car of coal brougnt into our area for distribution by boats.

They are also used to deliver coal to a local electric generating plant near me.

We also have an on-again off-again nuclear plant that seems to have been poorly constructed and is having problems w/ the concrete walls.

These energy generating plants are just some of the sources of danger to life and health of Americans and Canadians who live just across Lake Erie.

If they started putting wind generators and solar collectors on these mountain tops instead of blowing them up and digging them out there would be little, or no, destruction of the ecosystem.

People would not be negatively affected by the dust and carcinogens generated by MRO activities.

The poor, the aged, the children and the wildlife that live in the middle of these mountains would not be adversly affected and energy would be produced and much cheaper.

We all need to do things like turn off lights, unplug appliances not in use, and recycle as much as possible to minimize our use of electricity and stop feeding the system that is destroying these beautiful and ancient mountains.

Do what you can to spread the word and work for the alternative energy resources that are built in to the environment without destroying it.
+10 # Erdajean 2012-05-25 10:35
Yea, verily, Bluesy. Of COURSE we do not have alternative energy because those who grow disgustingly richer off the destruction of a land and its people would lose their cash cow -- and THAT is what rules POLITICAL decisions, in WVA and Washington. To hell with mountain people, the devil take this earth -- just don't disturb the flow of filthy dollars into filthy pockets.
I AM one of these women, figuring now how I can get my ancient, wheel-dependent bones and shaved head to that rally, in defiant protest of what this country has become. I beg the wrath of God upon such "leaders" as ours who look the other way, while His earth and His children bleed.
+15 # Glen 2012-05-25 10:08
Well said, Blues. You will get arguments against wind generators as creating heat below the blades and their being ugly, but having seen many wind generators arrayed in various places, it must be said straight up that not only is it not an eyesore, the area on the mountain tops or bays is just as pretty as they were prior to the generators being installed.

There is no clean fossil fuel sources.

If the U.S. government were in favor of environmental preservation and conservation, there would already be wind generators on those mountains. Sadly, the U.S. government is controlled by both oil and coal and natural gas, among others.
+13 # Glen 2012-05-25 10:10
The bald heads of these women also represents the medical treatment of cancer and the inability to even grow hair when born with serious deformities.
+12 # Regina 2012-05-25 12:39
The coal mine owners are making fortunes, which they spend on ads plugging a fiction they call "clean coal." There is NO such product -- coal = soot = carbon, and when carbon is burned in air it turns to carbon monoxide, which messes up the atmosphere. And no matter their blurbs, shaved-off mountain coal is even dirtier than the dug-out variety. They can't fool nature -- unfortunately they fool other people with money and power for elections, whom they control with more money for further elections. I hope these brave and smart women make enough of an impression on the "media" -- not just onlookers, so that the politicians are forced to wake up, smell the pollution, and take constructive action for a change.
+6 # Michael_K 2012-05-25 15:55
Even a cursory review of American history will show that what little any communities achieved in fighting the depredations and lethal exploitations by huge mining syndicates and other predatory corporations, was not achieved in courts or through legislation, until there had been some amount of bloodshed.

Sadly, it is always thus.
+1 # KittatinyHawk 2012-05-25 21:56
My family mined. We all used.
It is 2012,I believe in employment so I never took a stand.
Coal is not good for lives no mining is, proven facts. The slag left is a reminder here in Pa of lives living in poverty, lives lost, disease. My family were among that list.
We saw mountains of ash, then we started reading what the ash could do to water, life forms. You have tons of ash leftover from burning, used to be dumped in backyard, then taken to landfills...lot s used in asphalt and cement but there was more ash than need...yet we still sell coal stoves. These too create jobs.

Here we are wanting jobs, not wanting these poverty level jobs to leave these families in a demise but we are killing them. We need to look to what was given use the first given technologies for all they are worth. Europe used it...yet I do not see them admonishing mining. We can make changes by using alternative energy, learn how to do it ourselves, buy American Products.
We can learn to start Coops, other states, towns are doing just that alternet has information on this..get involved. I am going to be looking in this state for Coops, we used to have.
Electricity is like gasoline.You are in charge of how much you use. Start making Corporations, Government pay their fair share, they use more than you.
Demand more rebates and help financing federal and state.
Demand Schools, Government, Corporations start using Alternative.
+1 # KittatinyHawk 2012-05-25 22:05
One homes, apartments, townhouses, and renovations have to pass an Energy Star Evaluation. If they are draining heat due to square footage, draining electric due to poor planning, using too much water...then these homes cannot be built.

We do not need mansions, we do not need obnoxious homes. In the past homes were built around the fireplace so heat was used wisely. Rooms were built with windows at the sun with good thought of waking, heating rooms, lighting for work, school study. Now we just have to outdo the next guy or one up our friends.

I say it is time we start acting responsibly or pay costs double or triple. Water...allottm ent, if you use it up...learn to be inventive.

By the way, most of you with homes built since Bush have bought garbage. Materials are subgrade and flammable... Facts, Fire Companies in NJ showed people in a up class neighborhood the pile of ash left after a family home went up. Fire couldnot be controlled because of materials in your home. Most unsafe while you are living in home. Kids on flooring that are environmental to their health. Same goes for trailers, modular. These companies laugh all the way to the bank.

Pay attention to what you are buying...Ask about the materials...I know that I trusted a Contractor from Pa Keystone Help Program...mater ials are hazardous...Sta te did not care nor the Finance Company
+1 # Peacedragon 2012-05-26 04:55
Is there any connection with people who are waging this fight in other locations?
+1 # Glen 2012-05-26 14:32
Good question, Peacedragon. If there isn't, there should be.
+1 # lark3650 2012-05-27 07:24
Unfortunately, for some people the idea of making money over-shadows everything, like concern for the safety and welfare of their fellowman and respect for the earth on which we all live.
0 # TxGranny 2012-06-25 17:36
There is a Cree Indian saying that goes:
When the last tree is cut down,
The last river poisoned,
the last fish cuaght.
Only then will man discover
That he cannot eat money.

Greed is killing the earth and it doesn't seem anyone or anything can stop it. So sad.

THE NEW STREAMLINED RSN LOGIN PROCESS: Register once, then login and you are ready to comment. All you need is a Username and a Password of your choosing and you are free to comment whenever you like! Welcome to the Reader Supported News community.