RSN Fundraising Banner
'They're Playing Dirty': Can Navajos Win Power After Racial Exclusion?
Written by <a href="index.php?option=com_comprofiler&task=userProfile&user=49442"><span class="small">Jeremy Miller, Guardian UK</span></a>   
Thursday, 01 November 2018 13:08

Miller writes: "Hundreds of people lined up in view of Monument Valley's towering red mesas to enjoy traditional singing and dancing but also to register to vote - and end the legacy of racial gerrymandering that, for decades, has blocked Native Americans from power in this isolated corner of the American west."

James Adakai, the San Juan county Democratic party chairman, in Oljato, Utah. (photo: Jeremy Miller/Guardian UK)
James Adakai, the San Juan county Democratic party chairman, in Oljato, Utah. (photo: Jeremy Miller/Guardian UK)


'They're Playing Dirty': Can Navajos Win Power After Racial Exclusion?

By Jeremy Miller, Guardian UK

01 November 18


Republican-drawn voting districts left Native Americans voiceless despite their majorities. This election could bring sweeping change

he community gathering took place in the northern reaches of the Navajo Nation. Hundreds of people lined up in view of Monument Valley’s towering red mesas to enjoy traditional singing and dancing but also to register to vote – and end the legacy of racial gerrymandering that, for decades, has blocked Native Americans from power in this isolated corner of the American west.

Here in southern Utah’s red rock country, as in other rural reaches of the US, Democrats are working hard to make the so-called blue wave a reality. But the history of disenfranchisement has cast a long shadow over the Navajo Nation, one they hope they can throw off in the election.

Today, Native Americans, who lean heavily Democratic, make up a slight majority in San Juan county, which encompasses this part of Utah. But for decades they were “packed” by Republican officials into a single district in the county’s southernmost reaches, echoing other partisan gerrymandering efforts across the US.

In 2016, a federal judge ruled that San Juan county had violated the Voting Rights Act of 1965 by illegally drawing contorted voting districts to disenfranchise Native American voters. In a follow-up ruling last December, the judge handed down newly drawn district maps that give Navajos a majority by population in two of the county’s three commission districts. If Navajo candidates win next week, it could reshape the region.

James Adakai, a Navajo tribe member and Democratic party chairman of San Juan county, sat at a desk inside the Navajo Welcome Center in Oljato, Utah, in mid-September, sipping from a bottle of Gatorade as the powwow and voter registration drive took place outside. He was losing his voice. For weeks, Adakai had been on a frenetic circuit, working with tribal officials and volunteers from the Rural Utah Project, a not-for-profit, nonpartisan voter registration group, to get residents scattered across the 27,000 sq mile expanse of the Navajo Nation on the voting rolls. “I’m tired, but people are energized,” Adakai said.

Since last October, more than 1,600 voters – many of whom live in remote corners of the Navajo Nation and don’t have formal street addresses – have been registered, according to the Rural Utah Project.

The inequitable drawing of voting districts has meant that Navajos have never held a majority on the school board or county commission. (In fact, the first Navajo county commissioner, Mark Maryboy, was only elected in 1986, nearly 30 years after Native Americans were granted the right to vote.) As a result, some Navajos say they have seen funding for classrooms, roads and infrastructure pass them by.

In the Navajo community of Westwater – just minutes outside the tidy downtown and neatly clipped lawns of the majority-white town ofBlanding – residents lack running water and electricity. “There are no sidewalks, no streetlights,” said James Courage Singer, a Democrat running for Utah’s third congressional district. “This, right here, is the legacy of gerrymandering.”

The midterm ballot in San Juan county includes two Navajo candidates for county commissioner and Singer, who is the first Navajo – and probably the first indigenous candidate – in Utah to run for a seat in the US House of Representatives. The election is also seen as a referendum on the Trump administration, which has attacked tribal sovereignty on various fronts.

The Navajo, like tribes across the country, have bristled at Trump’s suggestion that tribes should be reclassified as races rather than separate governments, a legal shift that would mean that tribal members were no longer exempt from Medicaid work requirements. Trump’s downsizing of Bears Ears national monument, which was done at the urging of Utah Republicans, has also been a key rallying point for Native Americans.

‘They don’t want us to tell our story’

“There has been a deliberate effort in San Juan County to make it hard for Native Americans to cast a ballot,” said Leonard Gorman, executive director of the Navajo Nation Human Rights Commission.

Gorman points to 1957, the year the state constitution was amended and Utah became one of the last states to give Native Americans the right to vote. Ever since, he says, white GOP leaders – many of whom trace their ancestry to Mormon settlers who moved into the region in the 1860s, after the Navajo were forcibly removed by the US government – have used a host of tactics to suppress the Navajo vote.

The 2016 redistricting order was followed by a legal settlement requiring mail-in ballots to be distributed in the Navajo language as well as in English. The settlement also requires San Juan county to open three satellite polling places, each staffed with a Navajo translator.

In response to these legal victories, there has been a concerted pushback from entrenched Republican interests. Phil Lyman, a powerful county commissioner running for a seat in the state legislature, told one reporter that he would not comply with the redistricting order and would be “happy to be held in contempt”.

Local Democrats have accused county officials of failing to observe the redrawn boundaries. During the June primary, for example, hundreds of voters received ballots with candidates from the court-invalidated districts; others received ones with the wrong party affiliation. In addition, said Adakai, hundreds of voter registration cards were reportedly “lost” by the county clerk’s office. “They’re worried that the redistricting order might shake up the balance of power,” he said. “They’re playing dirty.”

Jesse Trentadue, an attorney representing San Juan county in the redistricting case, denied Adakai’s claims. He said that local election officials were acting in good faith to implement the new voting requirements but that San Juan county’s vast size and rugged, rural character has made the effort more complicated. “The county is almost twice the size of the state of Connecticut,” said Trentadue. “But only a quarter of its residents, both Navajo and non-Navajo, have a street address.”

According to Trentadue, even in urban districts where voters have traditional street addresses it is not uncommon for 10%-12% of voters to be placed in the wrong precinct. “We’re doing the best we can but mistakes happen,” he said.

Perhaps the most overt attempt to short-circuit mounting Native American power in San Juan county came last June, when the county clerk, John David Nielson, removed the Navajo county commissioner candidate Willie Grayeyes from the primary ballot. Nielson based his decision on a complaint from Grayeyes’s Republican rival Wendy Black, who claimed that the Navajo candidate did not live in Utah but across the border in Arizona – a violation of state residency requirements.

Those assertions were later found to be false by a federal judge and Grayeyes was returned to the ballot. Nielson, who may face an investigation for allegedly falsifying documents to remove Grayeyes from the ballot, declined to comment.

Grayeyes lives at the foot of Navajo Mountain, in an isolated community called Paiute Mesa, which, like Westwater and dozens of communities across the Navajo Nation, lacks running water and electricity.

Because of the district realignment, another Navajo Democrat is running unopposed for one of San Juan county’s three county commissioner positions. A Grayeyes victory would therefore mean that Navajos would go from decades of nominal representation on the county commission to a majority. That, Grayeyes said, would mean more resources could be marshaled to fix the rutted roads, crumbling water systems and aging schools in Navajo communities. It would also mean a reversal of the county commission’s presently vehement anti-monument stance.

But Grayeyes knows that, even if he wins, change will not come easily. “We’ve got Republican politicians all the way up the line who are invested in deceiving the public about what the monument is and what it stands for,” he said. “They don’t want us to have power. They don’t want us to tell our story. We have a mountain to climb.”

Email This Page

e-max.it: your social media marketing partner
Last Updated on Thursday, 01 November 2018 14:44
 

Comments   

A note of caution regarding our comment sections:

For months a stream of media reports have warned of coordinated propaganda efforts targeting political websites based in the U.S., particularly in the run-up to the 2016 presidential election.

We too were alarmed at the patterns we were, and still are, seeing. It is clear that the provocateurs are far more savvy, disciplined, and purposeful than anything we have ever experienced before.

It is also clear that we still have elements of the same activity in our article discussion forums at this time.

We have hosted and encouraged reader expression since the turn of the century. The comments of our readers are the most vibrant, best-used interactive feature at Reader Supported News. Accordingly, we are strongly resistant to interrupting those services.

It is, however, important to note that in all likelihood hardened operatives are attempting to shape the dialog our community seeks to engage in.

Adapt and overcome.

Marc Ash
Founder, Reader Supported News

 
+2 # dotlady 2018-11-01 22:54
This is a hopeful story - time for the Navajo people to get a voice in their districts in state government and some amenities. Good luck to Willie Grayeyes, whom I met during an election campaign at a Pioneer Day ceremony when he was a young leader among the people near Navajo Mountain.
 
 
+2 # Kootenay Coyote 2018-11-02 08:03
This is blatant racism & no Whitewashing can hide it. US abuse of Indigenous people is a longstanding cultural trait, & a damned one.