RSN May Fundraising
FB Share
Email This Page
add comment

writing for godot

Why do Republicans want to stigmatize welfare recipients?

Print
Written by Daniel Altman   
Tuesday, 07 August 2012 23:50

This morning I had a brief and revealing exchange on Twitter with Mickey Kaus, a blogger from The Daily Caller. Kaus was in the middle of a discussion with Dylan Matthews (a Harvard undergraduate who seems to be a pundit-in-training) and Jonathan Alter (of MSNBC) about how Kathleen Sebelius, the Secretary of Health and Human Services, might be trying to change welfare regulations. Here's how it went:

Mickey Kaus: @dylanmatt @jonathanalter she won't recreate AFDC but she may contradict "work first" and send signal that it's OK to go on welfare again.

Daniel Altman: @kausmickey @dylanmatt @jonathanalter It *is* okay to go on welfare. Why would you stigmatize people who do? Shameful to get Medicaid, too?

Mickey Kaus: @altmandaniel @dylanmatt @jonathanalter As long as welfare (+ foodstamps) R available 2 people who don't work they'll rightly be stigmatized

Mickey Kaus: @altmandaniel @dylanmatt @jonathanalter Also AFDC was epic social disaster for ghettoized poor. We don't want it to grow again if possible.

Daniel Altman: @kausmickey @dylanmatt @jonathanalter Punishing people w/stigma is not how 2 prevent this. Why stigmatize 4 something often not their fault?

The exchange ended there. I was shocked that anyone would suggest that people could be "rightly" stigmatized for receiving welfare benefits. For most people who receive benefits, it's not that they don't want to work. As Rebecca Blank, the new Secretary of Commerce, has written, most mothers who receive benefits face multiple barriers to working (http://www.npc.umich.edu/publications/policy_briefs/brief10/policy_brief10.pdf). Several of these barriers, such as health problems and domestic violence, are often beyond the mothers' control. To stigmatize them for receiving welfare benefits is to blame them unfairly for these barriers to work.

Kaus's callous and ill-informed comments echo a continuing strand of Republican economic philosophy: the idea that we live in a complete meritocracy. If that were true, then the only things affecting access to economic opportunities would be talent and effort. But that's not true. Many people are shut out of opportunities because of factors beyond their control, and many others are beaten out by people with more money and connections. For all of them, poverty is undeserved. To stigmatize these people for accepting the benefits that keep roofs over their heads and food in their children's mouths is both ignorant and cruel.

For more on the fallacies of Republican economic philosophy, please check out my new eBook, "SABOTAGE: How the Republican Party Crippled America's Economic Recovery" (http://www.amazon.com/SABOTAGE-Republican-Crippled-Americas-ebook/dp/B008LMNDYO).

 

Comments   

We are concerned about a recent drift towards vitriol in the RSN Reader comments section. There is a fine line between moderation and censorship. No one likes a harsh or confrontational forum atmosphere. At the same time everyone wants to be able to express themselves freely. We'll start by encouraging good judgment. If that doesn't work we'll have to ramp up the moderation.

General guidelines: Avoid personal attacks on other forum members; Avoid remarks that are ethnically derogatory; Do not advocate violence, or any illegal activity.

Remember that making the world better begins with responsible action.

- The RSN Team

 
+1 # RICHARDKANEpa 2012-08-08 13:45
Repubs condemn the poor but Dems constantly refer to the Middle Class including Bill Clinton whose mother was so poor that she had to give him temporarily to his grandparents who were small grocers until she remarried, then Bill several times stopped his step dad from beating up his mother and half brother.

Cheri Honkala is running for Vice President under the Green Party ticket so the homeless might learn to be proud enough of themselves to vote,

http://readersupportednews.org/pm-section/256-justice/12816-from-homeless-child-to-community-leader-perhaps-even-president-someday
 
 
0 # Seneca 2012-08-27 11:40
Again, people are taking the bait, hook, like and sinker..why allow such people to direct the dialogue at all? Counter this with the $1.6b in CORPORATE WELFARE the us govt gives out every year to thriving, and powerful, corporations. Or, how about the $2.3Trillion that the Pentagon "can't account for"??? Our government is thoroughly corrupt. Welfare recipients didn't cause the 'great recession', wall street and the corrupt govt did. Why do we keep playing THEIR game. RSN is also guilty of this.
 

THE NEW STREAMLINED RSN LOGIN PROCESS: Register once, then login and you are ready to comment. All you need is a Username and a Password of your choosing and you are free to comment whenever you like! Welcome to the Reader Supported News community.

You Are Not Logged In

Forgot Username?

RSNRSN