RSN May Fundraising
FB Share
Email This Page
add comment
Print

Egan writes: "You come to the big green heart of the American rain forest because you want to be far, far away from the dead-eyed young man with dyed red hair and the thumping chatter about what's wrong with a country in which 16,000 lives are taken every year in violent homicide."

Part of the Elwha River at Goblins Gate. (photo: Jeff Taylor)
Part of the Elwha River at Goblins Gate. (photo: Jeff Taylor)



Biological Boomerang

By Timothy Egan, The New York Times

27 July 12

 

ou come to the big green heart of the American rain forest because you want to be far, far away from the dead-eyed young man with dyed red hair and the thumping chatter about what’s wrong with a country in which 16,000 lives are taken every year in violent homicide.

Each murder is inexplicable in its own way, so you look for something restorative and reliable in a park holding trees that were living when Thomas Jefferson puttered around Monticello.

It doesn’t take long to find a miracle in the newly released Elwha River, focus of the largest dam removal project in American history — the Berlin Wall of environmental restoration. When wrecking crews started whacking away at the Elwha Dam last September, it was projected to take two, or even three years to bring it down.

The Elwha River
Tom Roorda, via Associated PressThe Elwha River

By late spring the 108-foot-tall dam was completely gone, and the river looks frisky in its gravitational search for old channels. Another dam, twice the height of the Elwha and eight miles upriver, is also coming down. With these two concrete barriers gone, about 70 miles of some of the cleanest, coldest water on the planet will tumble through the park at the edge of the continent.

It defies experience-hardened cynicism whenever any big public works project is under budget and ahead of schedule. But the Elwha has served up something even better: life itself, in the form of ocean-going fish answering to the imperatives of love and death. Not long ago, scientists were stunned to find wild steelhead trout scouting habitat well past the site where the Elwha Dam had stood for nearly a century. They didn’t expect fish to return this soon.

This biological boomerang is a tribute to stubborn DNA memory, and it is a precursor for what the wild Elwha will be in the not-so-distant future. Beyond that, the restoration of the Elwha, as in the revival of the much-abused southern end of the Bronx River at the other end of the country, is proof that American ingenuity is alive and well and hard at work on with the tricky task of healing parts of the natural world that we’ve trashed.

Before two dams were stapled to the Elwha, upwards of 400,000 fish — all five native species of Pacific salmon, and steelhead trout (a close cousin) — thronged up and down this pretty river. Their watery crib was where they were born, reared and then, after a life in the ocean, a place to spawn and die.

The dams choked off one of the greatest salmon bounties in the United States. They were built to service a pulp mill, and once the mill outlived its purpose, the Indians of the Lower Elwha Klallam Tribe began to dream of big Chinook, some up to 80 pounds, coming back to a river wild once again — a ghost dance, in its way. After an initial act of Congress authorized dam removal in 1992, it took two decades of persistence by the tribe, the National Park Service and lovers of wild land and feisty fish to guide the $325 million project through much turbulence.

There were obstacles, of course, the usual Republicans who have abandoned the founding conservation principles of Teddy Roosevelt, who wore a G.O.P. uniform in the days when the party often stood for visionary common sense. But when even Chamber of Commerce types from nearby Port Angeles joined the Indians and the tree-huggers in seeing a bonanza in the audacity of restoring a wild river, most of the obstructionists retreated.

But as to the question of what taxpayers in Cleveland or Amarillo are getting out of a project of this size in the nation’s far corner: consider what else we subsidize in the food chain. The government has paid out $277 billion in farm subsidies since 1995 — an obscene amount for a runaway program that was started to help Dust Bowl farmers but now is just another corporate entitlement protected by K Street influence peddlers. Tobacco growers, alone, have received $1.3 billion in that time.

The investment here will not only return a river to its natural state, but lays the foundation for a wild salmon fishery like no other in the 48 states. Imagine having a place, two hours and change from the 3 million people of the Seattle metro area, that looks like Alaska’s Kenai Peninsula — and has the fish to bring in visitors to expand what is already a thriving tourist industry.

Always with the salmon, a New York friend of mine likes to say about us Far Westerners. Ah, but the rest of world, tired of mushy, food-coloring-injected Atlantic salmon raised in little pens, has caught up with our obsession.

Flying as V.I.P.’s in the frozen hold of a cargo jet from Cordova, Alaska, the first of the Copper River salmon arrived in the lower 48 states two months ago. They were carried over a red carpet in Seattle and off to markets selling the celebrity salmon for upward of $32 a pound.

But you don’t come here to a park named for the gods to dwell on markets and politicians. You come here to walk next to the wild Elwha, dripping moss and perpetual green overhanging the path, the white noise of river water hurrying over polished stone — enough, for an afternoon, to forget about the trauma outside this valley.

 

Comments   

We are concerned about a recent drift towards vitriol in the RSN Reader comments section. There is a fine line between moderation and censorship. No one likes a harsh or confrontational forum atmosphere. At the same time everyone wants to be able to express themselves freely. We'll start by encouraging good judgment. If that doesn't work we'll have to ramp up the moderation.

General guidelines: Avoid personal attacks on other forum members; Avoid remarks that are ethnically derogatory; Do not advocate violence, or any illegal activity.

Remember that making the world better begins with responsible action.

- The RSN Team

 
+22 # tanis 2012-07-27 21:46
O, good news on RSN, at last! Congratulations , America!
 
 
+14 # Majikman 2012-07-27 21:52
My secret is out...this is where I live, folks, and a glorious piece of our endangered planet it is. I can walk my dog or trail ride in a different place each day and not exhaust new trails. Some days it's the beach, or the river, or the mountains, or the rain forest or drive to the wild coast. Truly, living here keeps me from despair at the state of the world.
BTW I buy my salmon (almost still flippin') from a local fisherman at considerably less than $32/lb.
My German Shepherd and I are in training for search & rescue for when you crazy tourists get lost in our woods. Even though we have cougars (had an encounter on horseback) and bears I feel no need to pack a gun. The mountain goats can get nasty, however.
Oh dear, since this article was in the NYT, I'd better speed up on Libby's tracking.
 
 
+10 # Observer 47 2012-07-28 07:14
Love your comment! My prayer is that the river area is not inundated with tourists and spoiled.
 
 
+10 # Majikman 2012-07-28 08:43
We love well behaved, considerate tourists. One of our problems is the local meth cookers back in the hills, armed to the teeth, turning their piece of land into superfund sites. The other "fear" is that we will become a magnet for climate refugees.
OTOH we are a magnet for some world class talent...writer s, artists, musicians, prof.'s in our local college, NYC chefs, MD.'s, and a host of other amenities. If we don't have it, Seattle is a 20min. commuter flight away...or a 3 hr drive.
Y'all come visit.
 
 
+11 # Rascalndear 2012-07-28 01:16
Really a hopeful story. Would be incredible to see more of this going on, like the battered Colorado, for instance...
 
 
+15 # Ralph Averill 2012-07-28 01:17
You can tear it down.
I lived in San Francisco at the time of the Loma Prieta earthquake. Two elevated freeways were damaged; the Embarcadero and Central freeways. The former was a horrible blight cutting the city off from the northern waterfront, the latter was a neighborhood wrecker in the Hayes Valley. When the idea was floated to simply remove the structures instead of repairing them, merchants in Fishermen's Wharf, Chinatown, and North Beach screamed, literally, that life would come to an end, and those neighborhoods would become ghost towns.
Cooler, stronger heads prevailed, (I can't remember who the mayor was,) and the freeways came down. The northern waterfront was returned to the city, and the western Hayes Valley was no longer a no-go-at-night neighborhood. Chinatown, the Wharf, and North Beach thrived.
My point is that it is possible to remove a huge man-made structure; a dam, a freeway, and actually improve things.
Perhaps success of the Elwha dam removals, (and the recent collapse of the Pacific salmon stock,) will promote the removal of more western dams. Perhaps the removal of the two SF freeways, and the removal of the elevated West Side Highway in NYC, will encourage the removal of more of those horrible urban blights.
You can tear it down.
 
 
+8 # Observer 47 2012-07-28 07:31
I can completely empathize, Ralph. Our house is one of several on a promontory that projects over a valley. Behind our house, there is a bridge which crosses the valley at its center. There are other bridges at either end of the valley. Seven years ago, "our" original bridge was torn down unnecessarily, when it could have been repaired in place. We protested the demolition, because the graceful 75-year-old bridge was the only one of its kind left in the world. But after it was gone.....it was wonderful! Quiet descended, replacing the sounds of big trucks, motorcycles with throttles wide open, and thousands of cars. We could see the whole valley stretching before us. What a fabulous view! We would have gladly endured the slight inconvenience of a few minutes' drive to cross the valley at the end, but no! Everyone else in the neighborhood screamed about how terrible an imposition it was to have to drive a half mile in either direction to get across the valley. And now.....we have an enormous, super-highway-s ized monstrosity plunked down at the edge of our historic neighborhood. The noise is back, the view is blocked again, our space has been most rudely invaded, and the neighbors are happy. Go figure!
 
 
+4 # xflowers 2012-07-28 02:19
Beautiful!
 
 
+14 # Jameswhadley 2012-07-28 02:33
"One nation, indivisible..."
How do we restore that? The dams that are inside the heads of the members of the American right are inaccessible to the goals of peace and ecological balance. They must come down, but are barricaded with piles and piles of money. And a self righteousness more stubborn than concrete.
 
 
+7 # Observer 47 2012-07-28 07:32
OUTSTANDING comment, James!! BRAVO!!!!
 
 
+1 # mdhome 2012-07-28 07:59
You know they are right, cause why would god give them all the money?
 
 
+13 # genierae 2012-07-28 05:57
What a beautiful story, I was brought to tears by the thought of a penned-up river regaining its wildness. I thank all the people who worked long and hard to make this happen, may it be an inspiration across this country for more of these actions. To those of you who are not close to nature, but are like Mr. Egan, sickened by the violence and destruction in this society, I would say this: Go out to the woods, lakes and streams, and find yourself. I guarantee you that if you are open to her, Mother Nature will nourish, heal and restore your spirit back to health.

"Touch the earth, love the earth, honor the earth, her plains, her valleys, her hills, and her seas; rest your spirit in her solitary places." Ernest Dimnet
 
 
0 # Glen 2012-07-29 04:07
There are two sides to this. Beyond the original beauty of a river is a looming energy need. The two remaining dams on the river where I live have been teetering on destruction, except for the trout and other fish well established in the waters. The community has briefly called for generation of electricity in these dams. As energy becomes more expensive, there may be a great need for dams, assuming they are constructed for, or may be converted, generators.

There are no doubt other dams originally built to generate electricity but were shut down.

It is a difficult decision relative to the future. I'd love to see dams come down but...
 

THE NEW STREAMLINED RSN LOGIN PROCESS: Register once, then login and you are ready to comment. All you need is a Username and a Password of your choosing and you are free to comment whenever you like! Welcome to the Reader Supported News community.

RSNRSN