Email This Page
add comment
read more of todays top articles

Naomi Klein writes: "My city feels like a crime scene and the criminals are all melting into the night, fleeing the scene. No, I'm not talking about the kids in black who smashed windows and burned cop cars on Saturday."

A Toronto crowd-control officer at the G20 Summit, 06/26/10. (photo: Getty)
A Toronto crowd-control officer at the G20 Summit, 06/26/10. (photo: Getty)

 

Comments  

We are concerned about a recent drift towards vitriol in the RSN Reader comments section. There is a fine line between moderation and censorship. No one likes a harsh or confrontational forum atmosphere. At the same time everyone wants to be able to express themselves freely. We'll start by encouraging good judgment. If that doesn't work we'll have to ramp up the moderation.

General guidelines: Avoid personal attacks on other forum members; Avoid remarks that are ethnically derogatory; Do not advocate violence, or any illegal activity.

Remember that making the world better begins with responsible action.

- The RSN Team

 
+18 # Guest 2010-06-28 23:11
The answer is quite simple. Stop the wars and end the militaristic insanity. Cutting the Pentagon budget would save every dime we need to save. Close at least half of the bases around the world. It is that simple !!! Then there would be enough money for everything else we need. It is all a question of priorities. It is that simple.
 
 
+4 # Guest 2010-06-29 08:30
Exactly so, ER444! That was my response, as well, when I read about the mandate to cut the deficit.
 
 
+5 # Guest 2010-06-29 00:04
Thank you, Naomi. Return to sender is good advice but I'm afraid the cat's in the bag and the bag's in the river - the cat being what little security we thought we had. No use blaming the money boys and gals. The Iceland volcano, the Gulf gusher, these, curiously, may be harbingers of how our problems may be resolved - we may well be drifting from a modicum of man-made order into natural chaos. Even so, a lot of money still protects a lot more than a little or no money. So even if we're going down the river toward the falls, some people will travel more comfortably than others.
Pete Edler, Stockholm
 
 
+2 # Guest 2010-06-29 11:53
So even if we're going down the river toward the falls, some people will travel more comfortably than others.
Pete Edler, Stockholm

_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/

Well said. Unfortunately, their comfortable ride makes it easier for those prosperous few to ignore how dire is our collective circumstance. They continue to resist change, to protect their privileged status (a status which is not, as Naomi says, a natural law, but a human construct), even as the boat goes down around them. I would say, however, that the "money boys and gals" bear more of the blame as they have seized more of the power.
 
 
+3 # Guest 2010-06-29 20:50
I think you are right. It helps explain why virtually nothing is being done to fight global warming (compared to the minimum that needs to be done). This is only one example, but it could have the worst consequences of them all.

Some very rich and/or powerful people (more often collections of people) have huge short term interests in the fossil fuel industry, and stand to reap ever huger profits as the resources get more scarce, especially if demand goes up. They are doing everything they can to maximize their short term profit, including sacrificing the future quality of life for everyone.

Most people involved are probably not aware, or only vaguely aware, that they are doing this. It’s the system more than individuals. But I don't know how those who are aware can could live with themselves. And thus we get the massive denial. On the other hand, much of it is at least partly conscious and willing, and to that extent, it is the worst of crimes. And you know who you are.
 
 
+1 # racetoinfinity 2010-07-01 01:47
Quoting
Most people involved are probably not aware, or only vaguely aware, that they are doing this. It’s the system more than individuals. But I don't know how those who are aware can could live with themselves. And thus we get the massive denial. On the other hand, much of it is at least partly conscious and willing, and to that extent, it is the worst of crimes. And you know who you are.


People who haven't grown from the industrial to the ecological level of awareness have an easy time denying the harm, because they don't even apprehend it. I think some people who are screwing the planet with carbon now fit into that category, but, as you say, not all. I think the BP top management are an amalgam of arrested development (stuck in the pre-ecological 50s) AND sociopathic greed and status-lust.
 
 
+1 # racetoinfinity 2010-07-01 01:40
There's nothing natural about the BP oil gusher. Nature is not suicidal. However, in their myopia and greed and recklessness, this great deep BP gusher probably will have vast and long-term effects to the whole chain of life in the biosphere and unknown effects on the climate and weather, so I see what you mean about natural processes outstripping our ability to correct or heal them. I've long suspected that SOME people at the top were grabbing money at as fast and greedily as they could, because they saw global warming and chaos coming and wanted to insulate themselves from the suffering to come - the self-centered so-and-sos! Not that they'll escape...just a respite. We need a new pro-labor pro-Planetary health/environmental progressive party in America, if the Green Party doesn't catch fire.
 
 
+9 # goodsensecynic 2010-06-29 03:45
Watching the police tactics, the political spin and the overall lose-lose performance in Toronto was disspiriting. Friends from Newfoundland to Vancouver Island have been e-mailing me with questions such as "What the hell is going on?" and lamentations about something profoundly changing in Canadian political culture as "Darth Vader" took to the streets.

While I sympathize with those who saw the promotion of the "fear factor" and what Naomi Klein accurately calls the tactics of "crisis capitalism," I do wish people would pay more attention to the past. "Overzealous" law enforcement and the political fear mongering that sustains it are endemic to modern political arrangements. Yet, each time another step is taken toward an authoritarian state, people insist on being "shocked and appalled."

Meanwhile, Martin Niemoller's warning that if fascism comes to America, it will come on "kitten feet," each step quietly taken as justified as necessary under exigent circumstances.
 
 
+7 # Guest 2010-06-29 04:37
YES - what happened to supposed G20 country ethics related to fairness?! "...not even a measly tax on banks or financial transactions, yet instructs governments to slash their deficits in half by 2013. This is a huge and shocking cut, and we should be very clear who will pay the price." Well said, Naomi!
 
 
+6 # Guest 2010-06-29 04:51
Ahhh, yes, the "trickle down" theory, but reversed to enrich those who control (or refuse to) money. Of course they're 'dipping around' the responsibility for what they've created, and passing the buck to those of us who play the game in good faith - changing the rules in the middle of the game.

Sort of like trashing a shopping center across town from where the police are prepared for confrontation. This won't be pretty. Yes, stop the wars that weren't necessary in the first place - send the Pentagon on furlough.
 
 
+7 # Guest 2010-06-29 04:53
The system we live under(the pyramid) where the few reap huge benefits at the expense of the many is what we need to flip over upside down. If we would grow up & take responsibility as citizens instead of playing 'children/parent rulership' these things wouldn't happen. We are just as guilty for these crimes for letting them happen & letting the elitists get away with it while we whine & complain. What are we, still ignorant & stupid vassals & serfs working under feudalism? No we are now, in this age,somewhat more learned & yet we still let these folks, ride this system to our back-breaking sufferage. We need to become good, concerned,infor med active citizens that are involved instead of bitching whiners who squack about the whip but do nothing to stop it or take it away. Overturn the system, call your reps, get involved. If you grow up, get involved and rule yourselves as adults, then you wouldn't live under a system that rules you as children & exploits you,right?
Return 2 U!
 
 
+1 # Guest 2010-06-29 05:10
Starve the obese,feed the poor
till there are no poor nor rich no more
break out of your bubble
take a look around
do what you know is right
take on injustice and make it just
 
 
+3 # Guest 2010-06-29 05:51
Naomi only touched on one of the key issues of the next several decades; energy. Simply put, there are no alternatives to hydrocarbons. Nope. None. No alternative energy resource or combination of alternatives can come close to supplying the 24/7 energy flows we take for granted. The global economy is in crisis and the movers and shakers in the financial sectors know it. The coming energy famine means the end of the perpetual exponential growth paradigm. The signal is the $70/bbl floor in the price of oil. The only way to keep the profits rolling in is for the economy to canabalize itself. Instead of feeding on the labor of the working class, it now feeds on them directly by cutting their access to resources. The snake is dining on its own tail.
 
 
+2 # Guest 2010-06-29 20:56
That's not what many scientists who have studied the situation say. They say we can transform our energy generation system in a few decades for only about 1% of the world's GDP. The sun puts out enough energy to supply 10,000 times our energy needs, and solar panels are already more efficient than plants at turning sunlight into energy. We have everything we need to do this, except the collective will.
 
 
+4 # Guest 2010-06-29 06:18
What can we do in a game where others set rules that render our personal economic decisions nearly pointless? In the May/June issue of Dollars and Sense magazine, Katherine Sciacchitano traces the history of international economic arrangements from Bretton Woods to the present. She makes it clear that under Reagan and Clinton we traded manufacturing for finance, relying on recycling our debt in dollars for cheap goods from the Global South and a trade deficit. We also got the housing bubble financed largely by foreign investors holding trade deficit dollars they exchanged for mortgage-backed securities.
Sciacchitano points to the need for an alternative to cutting back on government social spending;namely , re-instituting controls on international capital flows, democratizing control of the IMF, and reworking neo-liberal trade agreements like NAFTA. It all seems to come down to reforming the global financial system (which is hard to even understand) or deficit reduction and misery.
 
 
+2 # Guest 2010-06-29 08:43
As much as I agree with the article I can’t see anything changing. Read some history. We are too concerned about who the bachelorette will choose, or who the next American Idol will be to care about such things. Are we any different than the attendees at the Roman Coliseum who were treated by the ruling elite to circuses and irrelevant spectacles of gladiators fighting each other to care that their country was falling apart right under them? No, I don’t think anything will change until we care enough to do something about it, which we don’t right now.
 
 
+4 # Guest 2010-06-29 08:54
We are not powerless. Damn those who say we are. We are not organized - that's the problem. Organize and attack the capitalists where they are the most vulnerable - financially. Choose one company and organize a relentless international boycott until that company is bankrupt - then, pick another. Only then will the rules begin to change.
 
 
0 # Guest 2010-06-29 12:35
True, DH - going down the Niagara Falls in a yacht is different from going down in a canoe or as a swimmer - and not necessarily better. In a yacht there's considerably more disorientation. The chances are you'll be knocked unconscious before you hit bottom. As a swimmer at least you're alive to the end in free fall - so yes, I'd rather swim or paddle in a canoe. Small consolation, yes. After all, they may have had a pretty good time on the yacht before it fell. Info Pete Edler, Stockholm
 
 
+2 # Guest 2010-06-29 13:35
A two-tiered society is where this will lead
The smell of roses at the top while at the bottom we bleed
At the trough of inequality the elite will still feed
While the test for all the rest is to create a new seed
 
 
+3 # Guest 2010-06-29 20:47
The G20 was masterminded by two men only Paul Martin (Canada) and Larry Summers (U.S.A) and as such is nothing but a scam perpetuated and expanded by others who see a means of making a fast buck at the expense of the masses. Police in riot gear and people protesting...It is not nice to say but the police (Our sons and daughters)are being USED by the Corporate few to protect their elitist life style.
 
 
+2 # Guest 2010-06-30 10:25
Folks, we have a problem. It is structural. Historically, we have vested ``legitimacy`` in our police and armed forces.
These governmental branches with a monopoly on the exercise of naked power, the use of force, and physical coercion have been hijacked by corporate-controlled politicians.
Either we, as free citizens, re-take control of these "security" institutions, or else we alter our monopoly-on-force structure, and de-legitimize the use of force against those who demonstrate peacefully for a more equitable socio-economic distribution of public resources.
Something's got to give. Back in the late 1920's even Hitler knew that in order to stage a successsful coup, he had to seek Constitutional "cover."
Seems legal persons, corporations, have learned that lesson only too well...
 

THE NEW STREAMLINED RSN LOGIN PROCESS: Register once, then login and you are ready to comment. All you need is a Username and a Password of your choosing and you are free to comment whenever you like! Welcome to the Reader Supported News community.