Email This Page
add comment
read more of todays top articles

Klein writes: "If there is one thing I know, it is that the 1 percent loves a crisis. When people are panicked and desperate and no one seems to know what to do, that is the ideal time to push through their wish list of pro-corporate policies: privatizing education and social security, slashing public services, getting rid of the last constraints on corporate power. Amidst the economic crisis, this is happening the world over."

Portrait, author, environmental and political activist Naomi Klein in 2001. (photo: Leonardo Cendamo)
Naomi Klein in 2001. (photo: Leonardo Cendamo)

go to original article

 

Comments  

We are concerned about a recent drift towards vitriol in the RSN Reader comments section. There is a fine line between moderation and censorship. No one likes a harsh or confrontational forum atmosphere. At the same time everyone wants to be able to express themselves freely. We'll start by encouraging good judgment. If that doesn't work we'll have to ramp up the moderation.

General guidelines: Avoid personal attacks on other forum members; Avoid remarks that are ethnically derogatory; Do not advocate violence, or any illegal activity.

Remember that making the world better begins with responsible action.

- The RSN Team

 
+40 # Andrew Hansen 2011-10-07 15:46
Indeed OWS is real and it is reassuring to see the voices, Naomi, Bernie, Cornell, Michael, Noam all drawn to the nexus. It has staying power as only 99% can. There are so many contributing. Yes, just a beautiful moment.
 
 
+30 # adickinson 2011-10-07 23:27
Naomi is articulate. That is so fun to hear ideas communicating beautifully. Great article and a wonderful, fabulous movement. I'm getting involved by showing clips of the movement to my students at school and sharing links to the whole staff. Everyone can do something and be part in some way. We will keep looking for ways to be a part of it all, including listening and speaking (out).
 
 
+15 # PiscesCurveUS 2011-10-08 12:08
Yes. And it helps to be right, too (which Naomi also is).

But even Steve Jobs' Apple creations are not perfect, and I don't think the following quibble is trivial:

>> We have picked a fight with the most powerful economic and political forces on the planet. That’s frightening.
 
 
+1 # anarchteacher 2011-10-08 06:12
If the Occupy Wall Street protesters were serious, they would be storming the Harold Pratt House, 58 E. 68th Street at Park Avenue, New York, NY (Headquart­ers of the Council on Foreign Relations) and the New York Fed, 33 Liberty Street, New York, NY.

But they won't be led to confront the gods on Mount Olympus by their Judas goats and media shills. David Rockefelle­r, Pete Peterson, Warren Buffett, David Koch and Henry Kissinger might be held up from lunch at 21.

For both supporters and opponents of the Occupy Wall Street protests who seek more incisive background in understand­ing what has been really going on behind-the­-scenes with the Wall Street corporate and financial elites, Google the three items below:

"In a Relationsh­ip, and It's Complicate­d," by Anthony Gregory

"Wall Street, Banks, and American Foreign Policy," by Murray N. Rothbard

“Marx’s Tea Party,” by Anthony Gregory

All three articles "name names," are forthright­, direct, and pull no punches.
 
 
-8 # PiscesCurveUS 2011-10-08 11:38
agent provocateur?
 
 
+2 # noitall 2011-10-10 15:42
As an indepenent, you are free to throw yourself on the sword. We will applaud your courage and ignore your ignorance. Immediate "gratification" if you will. What would come of that? This is a gnawing away at a giant dam. you would sacrifice yourself by driving your car into it. The car and you would be destroyed, the dam would stand, you would be their example of the violence against the dam. This is not a football game, it will not end in 4 quarters. There will be no single heros, it will take time. Americans have been cajoled into expecting immediate gratification and are weak in persistence and tenacity. Take the money out of the war and see how many of the war corporations who are "fighting for the Iraqi and Afghan people" will remain to fight for their gallant cause. They will be taking a "well deserved" vacation while sneering at the servants. This will take years. If it takes less, so much the better, but that must be the mind set.
 
 
-10 # DaveM 2011-10-08 15:04
This may get me labeled as a heretic, but a question has been lingering in my mind since this began: what is the point of all this? I understand that the "movement" is a mass protest, but what is it supposed to accomplish?

Don't get me wrong: I am delighted to see people who are "fed up" and not afraid to do something to express their thoughts. But is there a specific message here? Is there a purpose to the protests? Wall Street is not going to go away--though it sure would be nice if some of the people working there would.

I'm just barely old enough to remember the marches and protests of the 1960s, most of them demonstrations against the Vietnam war. These events had a clear motivation, a clear agenda, and the hallmark of any successful campaign, an "exit strategy" (when the war ended, the protests stopped). What are the demands of Occupy Wall Street, and how will any of us know if any have been met or even can be met?

Mind, if the Tea Party can turn out en masse out of a weird impulse to wear pseudo-Revolutionary War costumes and chant inane slogans, more power to anyone from the other side who wants to make their desires known. But just what are those desires? At the moment, I fear that "the movement" is in grave danger of becoming a sort of urban Burning Man, without music.
 
 
+2 # noitall 2011-10-10 16:00
You're not a heretic, you're just another American without an imagination. Can you identify anything wrong with our system today? Too many to fit on a placard, I'd say, but it is a many-leafed tree. Look to the roots, the vitals of a Democracy, the right to know (stimied by news media controlled by the rich), the right to justice (stimied by a Supreme Court controlled by the rich), the right to representation (Representative s bought and owned by the rich), the right to assemble and free speech (harassment by "peace officers" white shirts with red necks fearful of their jobs and owned by the rich)one man, one vote (stimied by the SC decision recognizing giant corporations that cannot be sued, with thousands of shareholders all voting the interest of the corporation, many not citizens and of all nationalities, as aN American person). Has one ever been executed in Texas or Florida? The Teabaggers were a fraction of the numbers of this movement but were backed by the Kochs (notice the uniform, manufactured signs?) spouting illogical, ignorant claims and lies, flashing guns. What would happen to this group if there was a rumor of the presence of guns? What do you wait for? for someone to hold a sign that you agree with? where is your sign? what do you want to be left for your grand children? what is YOUR responsibility in this Democracy? Don't know? THINK ABOUT IT! THINK ABOUT IT!
 
 
+13 # dnvergrl1301 2011-10-08 20:32
I am so proud and humbled by what I have been seeing all over the country. The 99% are standing up for all of us who can't be there in person. The courage of all of them makes me so very proud. This is what it means to be an American. To stand up for what you believe in. How is it that some don't seem to care that the people lost so much while they were forced to give the few, the 1% 700 hundred billion plus dollars so that they could redecorate, take expensive bonuses. Do some of you like being used? Abused? I for one do not and it now seems many more feel as I do. There should be outrage. When is enough, enough? This is being done peacefully, in a non violent and non threatening way. We would like to redecorate, if we had our homes back. We want JOBS. We want a chance at an education that is affordable. We want and expect our fair share. No more, no less. I am tired of Goldman Sachs running our treasury Dept. I can only hope that this movement grows and grows until things change so that it benefits the 99%. I am proud to be one of the 99%.
 
 
+5 # James38 2011-10-08 21:47
Some members of the Wall Street group need to get serious about a simple fact. Money needs to be raised to rent portable toilets. This movement is foundering on its own poop, literally. The businesses, restaurants etc, in the area are totally fed up with bathroom abuse, and thee is no answer to that but to provide your own.

It would be very stupid and absurd to have the whole movement become famous for trashing the bathrooms that are, after all, only provided for the clients of the businesses. This kind of thoughtlessness can result in public rejection of the whole movement, and accusing the "public" of throwing the baby out with the bathwater will not regain the respect that the movement needs to become successful over the long term.

Pay attention to the simple basics, along with the long term ideas that Naomi expresses so well.
 
 
+5 # DIAMONDMARGE 2011-10-08 21:48
DaveM:
Please read Naomi Klein's full speech. She answers your concerns.
And drivergrl points out that people need jobs, education, and their homes back.
 
 
+10 # Paul Scott 2011-10-08 22:31
I'm an old combat vet who totally supports the OWS movement. Just as in combat, when you decide to have a battle you have to believe you can and will win. If you show weakness when the other side strikes out, at you, he will eat you’re c-rations.

I may be old, but that only means I know more of what is right and wrong. Wall Street continues to rob, because the Attorney General will do nothing about it. It's called aiding and abedding when we do it.
 
 
+6 # futhark 2011-10-08 22:36
The Tea Party was founded a couple of years back by some disgruntled Republicans who were fed up with the corruption and waste in government. Remember, this was during the tail end of the Cheney/Bush administration. Now the left is playing catch up in expressing their similar dissatisfaction with America's dysfunctional social, political, and financial situations. The Tea Party was co-opted by the neocons they had originally set out to oppose. The OWS movement needs to generate its own agenda and not allow policy makers who have failed to exert positive leadership get a free ride into office on the frustrations of the masses.
 
 
+1 # noitall 2011-10-10 16:34
futhark speaks the truth. You can bet they'll try to covertly take this over too and skew the message (in the search for something that they can "give" us to make us go away). Let's hope that leaders emergent are above this. It COULD happen. Don't underestimate the 'enemy'. They are rich and there are a lot of smart people up for sale hoping for their place at the trough. The focus, no matter how broad, must be kept.
 
 
+14 # Artemis 2011-10-09 04:52
To the people on the streets - Europeans are watching you closely and supporting you all the way!
And to DaveM - pay attention to what the people are saying. They are smarter than you may think. Ideas are developing, they don't come ready made with a demonstration.
One of the ideas I support strongly is that Wall Street is made to pay for its mistakes and to pay back what they stole. Money just doesn't disappear when it is stolen - the question is, where precisely has it gone?
Another idea I support is that banks are taken back, by law, to the days where they served people, not robbed them.
 
 
+1 # Financial Slave 2011-10-11 22:32
Artemis - Well said.
Article 1, Section 8, Paragraph 5 of the US Constitution: "Congress shall have power to coin money and regulate the value thereof..." That's 'taking back' the banks. That puts the enormous power of money creation as close to the control of the people for which it should serve (as a medium of exchange) as lawfully possible today.
You are right--money lost does not just disappear... the thief now has the money, and the thief is the International Financier -- he who charges interest for the use of our own money.
 
 
0 # okie_mule 2011-10-15 14:09
And the people shall rise up and shake the foundations of power.....even small tremors persistently over time can weaken even the strongest wall. Any action or any movement must follow these basic principles: Assess: know thy enemy and know them well, but also know yourself, Plan: establish and clearly articulate your goals because they are your ultimate guide Implement: determine the most effective methods to carry out your plan(s) according to the specific goals that you have defined and Evaluate: constantly measure and be able to articulate your successes and failures as this is the only way to increase the former and decrease the latter.
 

THE NEW STREAMLINED RSN LOGIN PROCESS: Register once, then login and you are ready to comment. All you need is a Username and a Password of your choosing and you are free to comment whenever you like! Welcome to the Reader Supported News community.