Email This Page
add comment
read more of todays top articles

Chris Hedges writes: "Human beings seem cursed to repeat these cycles of exploitation and collapse. And the greater the extent of the deterioration the less they are able to comprehend what is happening around them. The Earth is littered with the physical remains of human folly and human hubris. We seem condemned as a species to drive ourselves and our societies toward extinction, although this moment appears be the denouement to the whole sad show of settled, civilized life that began some 5,000 years ago. There is nothing left on the planet to seize. We are now spending down the last remnants of our natural capital, including our forests, fossil fuel, air and water."

The Great Pyramids of Giza. (photo: Travel Broker Tours)
The Great Pyramids of Giza. (photo: Travel Broker Tours)

 

Comments  

We are concerned about a recent drift towards vitriol in the RSN Reader comments section. There is a fine line between moderation and censorship. No one likes a harsh or confrontational forum atmosphere. At the same time everyone wants to be able to express themselves freely. We'll start by encouraging good judgment. If that doesn't work we'll have to ramp up the moderation.

General guidelines: Avoid personal attacks on other forum members; Avoid remarks that are ethnically derogatory; Do not advocate violence, or any illegal activity.

Remember that making the world better begins with responsible action.

- The RSN Team

 
+20 # Elsie Scharff 2011-03-07 09:54
Would that those who need most to hear this, could.
 
 
+16 # bjw 2011-03-07 10:09
How do you get people to look at the big picture when everyone is staring obsessively into a small one in their hand?
 
 
+6 # Lee Black 2011-03-07 13:04
And what will the news stories today focus on - Charlie Sheen.

So much more comforting than to look at the 'big picture'.
 
 
+4 # Kenrick Chin 2011-03-07 10:28
"Greenhouse gases in the atmosphere now are at 329 parts per million and climbing"

obviously a typo - should read "392 parts per million"
 
 
+16 # Observer 47 2011-03-07 10:42
This is possibly the most coherent, accurate depiction of life on Earth today I've ever seen. FINALLY someone has mentioned the 800-pound gorilla of overpopulation! Hardly anyone ever addresses the fact that if we don't start limiting the number of people on the planet very soon, no degree of conservation or innovation will save the human race. As Mr. Hedges points out, Earth, like Easter Island, is a finite place, and once ever-growing population depletes the resources or damages them beyond repair, we're done.
 
 
+12 # Artful 2011-03-07 10:50
The republicans who need to hear this are too busy hauling their gold off to their vaults.
 
 
+10 # Kym Trippsmith 2011-03-07 11:03
This article is the canary in the mine that houses the soul of humanity. Greed is our economic plan and always has been and we are sadly (most likely) past the point of no return environmentally -- perhaps small conscious communities hidden away here and there will meekly survive. And to that end I will work tirelessly... www.aprainwaterharvesting.com
 
 
+14 # Maggie 2011-03-07 11:04
Once again, Mr. Hedges, you've told it like it is. We all admire your work, your mind, your writing, your diligence profoundly. Please don't stop,
THANK YOU!!!
 
 
-18 # lnason@umassd.edu 2011-03-07 12:02
In the past 5000 years, the overall population of the earth has multiplied dramatically. In the past 5000 years, life expectancies have increased dramatically. In the past 5000 years, the quality of human life and the material well being of humans has increased dramatically. In the past 5000 years, the growth in the arts and the sciences, the growth of philosophy and ethics, the growth of civilization has made us all luckier than our ancestors. Progress has always been a bit bumpy, but the trend is rather clear.

One is nonetheless allowed to predict apocalypse as do Mr. Hedges or some fundamentalist Christians and Muslims. But such counterfactual faith-based claims should be looked at askance by those who know history and have enough sense to know that the same claims have been made for millenia.

Lee Nason
New Bedford, Massachusetts
 
 
+6 # aikidokurt 2011-03-07 14:49
"you have eyes but cannot see...you have ears but cannot hear..."
anon., attributed to a prehistoric hippie-type from the dead sea essene colony
 
 
+5 # DesertMac 2011-03-07 23:20
Inason, you need to add: And yes, in the past 5000 years, as EVERY civilization has crested and collapsed there were, every time, those who would say exactly what you are saying and refuse to look around them at reality.

There are ALWAYS plenty of fools like you who utter, "What, me worry?" and insist there's nothing we can't overcome if we just "Stay the course!" After all, WE'RE AMERICANS! We can do anything! We're number one!

And for 5000 years there have always been a lot of people in every collapsing system who clung to the false sense of entitlement and moral certainty of manufactured destiny.

I just hope you live long enough to see the utter collapse. It IS coming. Our course is set, and the engineers of that course are counting on people like you to tell the others that there's no need to be alarmed, let alone armed.

"But such counterfactual faith-based claims should be looked at askance by those who know history and have enough sense to know that the same claims have been made for millenia."

The lack of common sense in people like you who think this way would merely be amusing if it weren't so critical to, and exacerbating of, the problems we face.
 
 
+1 # Loup-Bouc 2011-03-07 12:02
Mr. Hedges wrote: "...this moment appears be the denouement to the whole sad show of settled, civilized life that began some 5,000 years ago."

No. Civilization began more than 8,500 years ago, but, contrary to Mr. Hedges's musings," not in Mesopotamia, The West, the land of "Caucasians." It began on the northwest coast of India about 3500 years before it began in the West, and the people were dark-skinned and did not speak an "Indo-European" or Semitic language.

Those "foreign" brown-skinned Indian people had advanced agriculture and engineered irrigation and a written language and stone buildings and a city of paved streets and plumbing and jewelry and pottery and metal tools --- when the West was still populated by illiterate hunter-gatherer primitives.

In China, too, agrarian, permanent-village civilization began (and had pottery, hoes, polished axes, and weights for digging sticks) 1500 to 2000 years before it began in Mesopotamia.

How pathetic. Even Western political progressives cannot bear the truth that Asia's brown-skinned and yellow-skinned ushered humanity into civilization.

Descartes, Pascal, Gutenberg, Galileo, Pasteur...... stole the myriad mathematical and scientific inventions and insights of India and China and treated the East as if wastes of little better than savages.
 
 
0 # Loup-Bouc 2011-03-07 13:34
I need to correct one paragraph of my previous post, # Loup-Bouc 2011-03-07 12:02. The paragraph is:

"Civilization began more than 8,500 years ago, but, contrary to Mr. Hedges's musings," not in Mesopotamia, The West, the land of "Caucasians." It began on the northwest coast of India about 3500 years before it began in the West, and the people were dark-skinned and did not speak an "Indo-European" or Semitic language."

Civilization began in India about 7500 years before the oldest Mesopotamian civilization. It began about 13,000 BC, in what is now the Gulf of Cambay, northwest India. See, E.G., http://www.archaeologyonline.net/artifacts/cambay.html

Loup-Bouc
 
 
+13 # Dennis 2011-03-07 12:45
the bumperstick comes true "Earth First we will stripmine the other planets later"
 
 
+5 # Lee Black 2011-03-07 12:58
The International Data Base states that the earth's population in 1960 was 3 billion and it estimates 9 billion before 2050. This is surely analogous to Mr. Hitchens description of the Easter Island story.

Soon you will see the 'elites' preparing; more gated communities; hoarding of water (already happening); etc.

It may not be the religious "end times" scenario-there will be a few survivors, but I don't think it will be a life worth living.
 
 
+5 # aikidokurt 2011-03-07 14:47
"they have ears, but cannot hear; they have eyes, but cannot see..."
and they have religous nutters and zealots who refuse or choose not to teach rational thought and what such lines REALLY mean and imply...
now its more like: "you hear our conservative dribble but do not evaluate...you see our hateful acts but choose to be blind ..."
 
 
+7 # genierae 2011-03-07 14:53
Sometimes I think that we were brought here by aliens. Think about it, we don't fit in. We are the only creatures on earth who don't live in harmony with our environment, the only ones who foul our own nest. I think that we were seeded here by aliens as an experiment of some kind. Or maybe our ancestors were taken off a planet that was overpopulated. However we got here, we now seem to be in a race between attaining spiritual enlightenment and suffering egocentric global self-destruction. Please God, help us to wake up!
 
 
+6 # rf 2011-03-08 05:31
There is no God! Get over it and figure out that you will have to save yourself or die. Quit expecting something else to save you...nature holds no deus-ex-machinas...wake up.
 
 
-2 # genierae 2011-03-08 06:58
rf: I was being intentionally dramatic, but I see that anyone who is expressing their own enlightenment is a threat to those who prefer to remain comatose. It is you who needs to wake up, my friend. I see that you reject God, but do you reject love as well? I mean real love, not the erotic kind. Do you know what it is to love your fellow man and want the best for all of humanity? If you have ever had a hint of this all-pervading love, then you have had a glimpse of the divine. You then can use that glimpse to expand your consciousness and rise above your cynicism. Once you take your first step on that good road, you will never want to walk any other road again. When I speak of God, I speak of higher power, spiritual enlightenment, divine presence. Someday you will wake up from your particular dream and realize that love is God, and "God is love". May that day come soon.
 
 
+2 # Glen 2011-03-08 16:47
Are you expecting your god to save the planet? Maybe through love?
 
 
0 # Gary Ray Pierson 2011-03-09 07:13
Quoting
Are you expecting your god to save the planet? Maybe through love?

Don't know why Glen but, that remark just cracked me up... Hell people, you've got eyes.... Your supposed to have a some what rationale mind... Any one with sense enough knows were wasting this planet and ourselves at the same time... I feel like a chicken.. They eat us before were born and after..... Sunny side up and fried some times.. And about there being no god.. How the hell do we know there is one.. This is how I look at it. We got here some how and were some where.. To simplify the reason, A three letter word works out well enough for me.. God put us here.. Now.. what the hell for, to just watch us destroy ourselves or maybe, save ourselves? Testing our resolve? His cable bill came in and he's broke according to televangelist and has nothing to watch but us? If so.. Wake up Omnipresent one.. You fell asleep way back when.. Look at what your little creatures are doing... Were creatures...... That go along with the features... On this fragile planet... And it is fragile.. Be nice to it and it may be nice to you.. People, well... Nice is a bigger concept to them than God... Cpl. Pierson 101st Vietnam
 
 
0 # genierae 2011-03-09 12:43
Hi Glen: All I know is that love saved me. (But I had to meet it halfway.) My point is that many people reject the concept of God, but don't reject the concept of love. And so that's why I asked rf about it. The word God is rather generic, what it means depends on who you ask, but I think that the word love is pretty clear in definition, most people know what it is. As for the planet, I think that it will eventually save itself, mainly by getting rid of us. We are a plague upon this earth, and we don't yet have enough collective sense, to stop our madness. Who knows if we will wake up in time?
 
 
-1 # Gary Ray Pierson 2011-03-09 07:17
Quoting
rf: I was being intentionally dramatic, but I see that anyone who is expressing their own enlightenment is a threat to those who prefer to remain comatose. It is you who needs to wake up, my friend. I see that you reject God, but do you reject love as well? I mean real love, not the erotic kind. Do you know what it is to love your fellow man and want the best for all of humanity? If you have ever had a hint of this all-pervading love, then you have had a glimpse of the divine. You then can use that glimpse to expand your consciousness and rise above your cynicism. Once you take your first step on that good road, you will never want to walk any other road again. When I speak of God, I speak of higher power, spiritual enlightenment, divine presence. Someday you will wake up from your particular dream and realize that love is God, and "God is love". May that day come soon.

"You know when I talk to god I know he understands.. He says stick by me and I'll be your god in hand.. But don't ask me what I think of you,I might not give the answer you want me to.." Fleetwood Mac. 'Then play on.' garyray
 
 
0 # genierae 2011-03-09 13:01
Mr. Pierson, any answer that you might choose to give would be welcome, no matter whether I like it or not.

"O wad some power the giftie gie us,
To see oursels as ithers see us!"
Robert Burns
 
 
+7 # Joyce Tarnow 2011-03-07 14:53
Population reduction---first and foremost of the lessons we have failed to learn. Whether two billion or three billion is the sustainable number need not be debated. It is certainly not SEVEN billion.
 
 
+5 # Frank Dolan 2011-03-07 15:47
Donella Meadows, et al authored The Club of Rome report entitled iirc, The Limits to Growth, the simple conclusion of which was: You can not have infinite growth on a finite planet. These days are those days...and we need more than Zero Population Growth to remedy the situation. The Laws of Life, which govern all species, will not exempt h.sapiens from the consequences of its actions. TANSTAFL... (epecially in physics)
Good Luck to us all...say 'Good Night, Gracie'.
 
 
+3 # Denis Frith 2011-03-07 16:39
This article blames the demise of civilizations on the unwise decisions of the elite. There is mention of the consequences of the ravishing of the natural life support system. However, there is no mention of the fact the natural forces always determine what happens. Humans can only make decisions about using what is possible. The operations of civilization have irreversibly used up limited natural capital. Wiser decisions would have been made if there had been this understanding of the dependence on nature for the operation and maintenance of materialistic civilization during its life time.
 
 
+4 # Demfatale 2011-03-07 18:29
There was a time, in the '70s and early '80s, when humanity was still lovable. The Human Potential movement was in full sway, whispering of greatness to come. How could we have known, then, that we had already peaked … that from Reagan on, the degenerative disease of Doris Lessing's prophetic Shikasta novel would bore into the species and pull us down to mindless brutality, all within a couple of generations?

Today I would be content to see our species go extinct. Better that than taking the planet down with us, as Chris Hedges has aptly declared the possibility for this evolutionary round.

Earth is not a Kindergarden of Eden.

It takes a mature consciousness to run the planet, not this infantile selfishness that's taken over the Republican party and is trying to take over the world. It’s clear: humans aren't ready to handle real power, not by a long shot. I would rather see the planet take a long spa day, maybe 10,000 years, and heal herself of human destruction than see her suffer one more decade at our hands. If we’re about to repeat the Easter Island lesson, then let that climax come soon, while there's still enough ecosphere to regenerate a paradise and perhaps brew some desirable human DNA changes, like more skin color varieties, mosquito immunity, extra civility and NO, repeat, ZERO neo-con genes on the chain.
 
 
+3 # Frosty Wooldridge 2011-03-07 19:43
This piece by Hedges represents the best writing and understanding of humanity's predicament in the 21st century. As a 6 continent world bicyclist, I witnessed what he writes about. I will submit my latest series on overpopulation in America. It sobers, educates and offers solutions, but it may be too late, but we must attempt to save our civilization by our actions. Frosty Wooldridge www.frostywooldridge.com
 
 
+3 # Beth Brant 2011-03-07 21:10
Unfortunately, the article mentioned nothing about the extinction of all that is beautiful and wondrous in this world- the animals and green things that make living a joy. The factory farms, the gmos that have invaded our food, all are obscenities that have tainted our natural world. And WE let it happen. I never dreamed that I would live inside a Philip K. Dick story, and I never thought tigers would become extinct in my lifetime. I have tried so hard to do what I could to save this awe-inspiring planet and as my days are coming to a close, I despair over the loss of so much.
 
 
+1 # Chacka Garcia 2011-03-07 22:46
PLEASE READ! And then weep if you're one of the many who are unwilling to enact change by first questioning your dogmatic faith in 1) the politicians, who promise you that they are protecting your right to obtain your dreams, while they play Ivory Tower chess, using us as pawns, and 2) the economic system called capitalism, which is founded almost entirely on -- dare I say it -- GREED.
 
 
+1 # Meriwethers son 2011-03-08 21:26
There are still pathfinders in our modern wilderness.I too despair at this cycle of self destructive behavior, but one must look beyond our earth for a larger context, for comprehension, and peace. Our foundling understanding of the nature of our universe leaves us in awe of what we don't know yet. The next evolution is at hand and it comes out of us-see Ray Kurzwil's " Singularity"-
There is truth in degrees in all said here....but we must get beyond cynical,jaded,h opeless, naive, nihilistic. God doesn't exist in any anthropomorphic sense, but (as said before) Love is God and God is Love... I have experienced this without seeing Jesus in a tortilla chip etc.We must keep trying for the sake of that...for the sake of building a new paradigm/reality...for the sake of our children...and even the sake of whatever it is that is coming to replace us.
 

THE NEW STREAMLINED RSN LOGIN PROCESS: Register once, then login and you are ready to comment. All you need is a Username and a Password of your choosing and you are free to comment whenever you like! Welcome to the Reader Supported News community.