RSN Fundraising Banner
FB Share
Email This Page
add comment

Mooney reports: "Sperling says Beijing has cut off access to Ngaba in the eastern part of the region and prosecuted people for spreading news of the self-immolations."

Tibetan exile Jamphel Yeshi set himself on fire during a protest against the visit of Chinese President Hu Jintao to India. (photo: Manish Swarup)
Tibetan exile Jamphel Yeshi set himself on fire during a protest against the visit of Chinese President Hu Jintao to India. (photo: Manish Swarup)

Tibetans Cry Out for Haven From China in Dozens of Self-Immolations

By Paul Mooney, The Daily Beast

02 September 12


Since 2009 more than 50 people - two more just this week - have set themselves on fire to protest Beijing’s harsh rule. Can the world stop more?

he two teenage Tibetans, a monk and a layperson, walked past the eastern gate of the Kirti monastery on Aug. 27, their bodies engulfed in flames as they toppled to the ground. Chinese security forces raced over with fire extinguishers. They carried them to a nearby hospital, where they are believed to have died soon after.

The cousins, 17 and 18, joined a growing list of people who have set fire to themselves in the past three years to protest China's harsh rule of Tibetan areas.

According to Woeser, a Tibetan poet and commentator, 56 Tibetans, including nine women, have set fire to themselves since 2009, when the first self-immolation took place. Of those, 41 came in the first eight months of this year. Three have taken place in Nepal and India. Woeser keeps a running tally on Invisible Tibet, her Chinese-language blog. She's posted bios, photos, and testaments in some cases, of each person who has set fire to him or herself.

"Actually, in the history of the Tibetan people, there have never been so many people who have set fire to themselves," says Woeser.

More than a few observers have made comparisons to Thich Quang Duc, a Vietnamese monk who self-immolated in Saigon in 1963 to protest the Diem government's anti-Buddhist policies. A photo of the incident appeared in newspapers all over the world, putting pressure on the Diem regime to make religious reforms. Diem first agreed to carry out the changes, but he later reneged, setting off a series of incidents that led to his downfall.

So far, the more than 50 incidents in Tibet have not had the same impact as that single incident. Beijing remains unmoved.

Experts say they're not surprised, pointing to China's extremely tight control of Tibetan areas.

"It's interesting that the outside world might get four or five lines in The New York Times world round-up, but this does not get the sort of coverage one would think," says Elliot Sperling, professor of Tibetan studies at Indiana University. "China is doing a very good job of keeping people away."

Sperling says Beijing has cut off access to Ngaba in the eastern part of the region and prosecuted people for spreading news of the self-immolations.

"If Tibet were open and we could speak to people, this would be a much larger story," he adds. "I don't know how many journalists managed to even speak to friends or families of these people."

Sperling says that if one major story could be published, it might be able increase the focus on the issue.

"A lot of people don't know [about the self-immolations] because we're not commanding headlines because the lack of info is blocking us and holding this story back," says Lhadon Tethong, director of the Tibet Action Institute. "I think that the lack of constant coverage or information coming out of Tibet really hurts us."

"The fact that journalists can't get in and cover the story firsthand on the ground creates a pretty difficult situation in terms of keeping the story fresh," said Lhadon Tethong. "I believe the international media can do more, but it's images and video that sells, and not just another name that people don't know how to pronounce or another sound story. We need access and that's what governments should be pushing for."

Further, she says China has succeeded in convincing the world it's best to do things the Beijing way.

"China has just done a fantastic job of scaring the world into submission," says Lhadon Tethong. "The last thing the Chinese government wants to see is a new government-coordinated response to the Tibet issue. And that's exactly why we need to have one."

Woeser says that while many foreign governments had made perfunctory comments about the self-immolations, none have tried to pressure Beijing on Tibet. "All of the assessments and all of the weighing of pros and cons are really just a closing of the eyes and a refusal to see," she said.

But foreign governments may be at a loss about what to do.

"Foreign governments face the problem of not really knowing exactly what Tibetans want them to do that would not damage their own interests-what would not be damaging for them," says Robbie Barnett, director of the Modern Tibet Studies Program at Columbia University. "To really clarify this will require a lot of thinking and a lot of work."

First, Barnett says it's a mistake to compare the situation in Tibet to Vietnam in the 1960s.

"The Buddhist population of Vietnam was the majority at the time. And the Vietnamese government was an extremely weak government that was dependent on the U.S. for support. So media impact in the West had a significant political role in that case," he says.

"The Tibetans face a diametrically opposite situation-a very strong government, with little effective outside influence from the West, and a limited role for foreign media in affecting political change in their area."

Still, some say the self-immolations have had one key impact-bringing Tibetans closer together.

And it's the one tactic that the Chinese, even with all their resources, have found impossible to stop.

"It does seem that the thing about this that makes it difficult is that so many avenues of protest are repressed, but that self-immolation is something one does by oneself," says Sperling. "There's no meeting that has to be held, no group that can be infiltrated or informed on. It's something to be done spontaneously."

And it's something that can't be effectively combatted, though authorities have been trying to stop people from setting fire to themselves. "In Lhasa the police walk around with fire extinguishers and grappling hooks in case there's a self-immolation," he says.

Barnett says it's a protest that resonates within Tibetan society, fitting in with accounts of the Buddha sacrificing his life in his previous lives. And it's a tactic that doesn't involve other people getting hurt-a contrast with 2008, when demonstrations in some Tibetan areas turned into riots, bringing about a Chinese crackdown.

The self-immolations could continue until Beijing relents and agrees to concessions, or the Tibetan government-in-exile calls for them to stop.

"The whole idea of mass suicide is horrific, and it is extremely dangerous, since there's no obvious reason why people who are committed to changing Chinese policies in Tibet should stop killing themselves," Barnett says.

"They are likely to believe that it could have a cumulative effect, that the more people die, the more the Chinese government will have a reason to change." your social media marketing partner


A note of caution regarding our comment sections:

For months a stream of media reports have warned of coordinated propaganda efforts targeting political websites based in the U.S., particularly in the run-up to the 2016 presidential election.

We too were alarmed at the patterns we were, and still are, seeing. It is clear that the provocateurs are far more savvy, disciplined, and purposeful than anything we have ever experienced before.

It is also clear that we still have elements of the same activity in our article discussion forums at this time.

We have hosted and encouraged reader expression since the turn of the century. The comments of our readers are the most vibrant, best-used interactive feature at Reader Supported News. Accordingly, we are strongly resistant to interrupting those services.

It is, however, important to note that in all likelihood hardened operatives are attempting to shape the dialog our community seeks to engage in.

Adapt and overcome.

Marc Ash
Founder, Reader Supported News

+10 # fdawei 2012-09-03 01:44
Thank you for this overdue insight, Paul.
It's disgraceful that these events are conveniently ignored by foreign governments and mainstream media. However, when it comes down to business, visas, on-going cultural and ministerial exchanges, no one is interested in upsetting the boat.
+5 # Kootenay Coyote 2012-09-03 09:59
In the 19th & 20h Centuries, China lost, not without the aid of drastic political & economic beatings from the West, its best Confucian principles. Between 16 & 17 hundred years ago, Mahayana Buddhism came through Tibet to China. Now Tibet is challenging China spiritually once again. I wonder if there are hearts to hear....
+2 # Bill Clements 2012-09-03 12:01
It's difficult to come by hard facts on this issue, but there's a lot of anecdotal evidence to suggest a resurgent interest in Buddhism (Tibetan and Theravada) occurring in mainland China these days, especially among ethnic minorities but also among the educated class.
+2 # Bill Clements 2012-09-03 10:45
It is true that the Boxer Rebellion of 1900 (meant to rid the country of all foreigners, including missionaries and Christians) was a seminal event that set the stage for someone like Mao, but lets not place too much blame on the West for communism in China.
+2 # Bill Clements 2012-09-03 11:40
"Foreign governments face the problem of not really knowing exactly what Tibetans want them to do that would not damage their own interests-what would not be damaging for them," says Robbie Barnett....

Somehow, I don't really think that foreign governments like the U.S. are spending too much time wondering what Tibetans want them to do. If that was really their primary concern and focus, there would be some evidence of it in the Western media.

The fact of the matter is that economic self-interest is paramount and trumps all other concerns, including humanitarian ones. We give a little lip service to human rights in Tibet and China and that's as far as it ever goes.
+2 # RODNOX 2012-09-03 12:41
the chinese are a very dangerous culture and the world has let their guard down
+2 # Bill Clements 2012-09-03 13:34
Or more specifically, the CCP is truly dangerous and the world has failed to see the enormity of the threat. But those of us who are students of Tibetan history have never had anything but a clear-eyed assessment of communist China. And as the years have unfolded, so has the threat, yet the world is slow to see the destructive ramifications now and in the future.
+2 # Freedom2 2012-09-03 17:18
The Falon Gong newspaper covers China news and doesn't like the CCP. A search there for "immolation" gets about 300 articles, many re Tibet.

Maybe they could help get some videos out. Then post them on Western sites with explanations of what is happening and why.

THE NEW STREAMLINED RSN LOGIN PROCESS: Register once, then login and you are ready to comment. All you need is a Username and a Password of your choosing and you are free to comment whenever you like! Welcome to the Reader Supported News community.