RSN May Fundraising
FB Share
Email This Page
add comment
Print

Tremlett reports: "Clues to Guernica's tragic past abound in a market town leveled 75 years ago during an almost non-stop four-hour bombardment in which Luftwaffe units loaned to Spain's Nazi-backed future dictator General Franco practiced aerial blitzkrieg."

Guernica, by Pablo Picasso. (photo: Burstein Collection/Corbis)
Guernica, by Pablo Picasso. (photo: Burstein Collection/Corbis)


Guernica 75 Years On

By Giles Tremlett, Guardian UK

19 August 12

 

A film about the painter's vision of a key event in Spain's civil war sheds light on a community finally overcoming the tragic scars of the past.

large cannon fires into the town square of the Basque town of Guernica, scattering small children. Fortunately, in a place tragically famous as Hitler's testing ground for the bombing of civilian targets, this is just part of the entertainment at the summer fiestas. The shiny weapon shoots watery bubbles at delighted children dressed in swimwear and goggles.

But clues to Guernica's tragic past abound in a market town levelled 75 years ago during an almost non-stop four-hour bombardment in which Luftwaffe units loaned to Spain's Nazi-backed future dictator General Franco practised aerial blitzkrieg.

Buildings across the town currently display two dozen peace posters painted by children from around the world on massive hoardings sized to match the world's most famous anti-war painting - Pablo Picasso's tortured, terrible depiction of the bombardment. His disturbing tableau of screaming women, dismembered bodies, crazed animals and dead children is pinned to walls in shops and bars.

As the Basque country slowly gets used to a peace denied it for almost four decades by the armed separatist group Eta, Guernica is preparing to return to the spotlight in a film starring Antonio Banderas and Gwyneth Paltrow that will depict the 33 days of furious creativity in which Picasso created one of his greatest works.

Banderas and Paltrow, playing the Spanish painter and his photographer muse Dora Maar, will be filming in the town in a specially built replica of Picasso's Paris studio. "Maar is the protagonist and not just because she was his lover and confidante, but because her photographs are the only proof of how the picture evolved," director Carlos Saura says. "Guernica was an extraordinary synthesis of Picasso's creativity," agrees art historian Gijs van Hensbergen, author of a book on the painting. "Dora was both participant and witness to the creation of the 20th century's most iconic work of art."

Tourists come in search of the old quarter. "We have to tell them there isn't one, that it was bombed to the ground," explains Luis Iriondo, an 89-year-old artist who lived through the bombing as a child. He recalls how incendiary bombs sent fire sweeping through the town, killing those in bomb shelters and destroying four out of every five buildings. "Each explosion was followed by a blast of air," he says, recalling that it was a busy market day in a town already packed with refugees. "They were horridly warm, as if they tasted of death."

"I spent four hours staring up terrified at the sky," recalls Iriondo's friend Enrique Aranzábal. "After the Spanish civil war I went to sea and ended up working with a German who had flown in those planes. He told me they treated it as a training mission."

Three-quarters of a century later, Guernica is perhaps freer of tension than at any time in its modern history. As the town parties, Iriondo and Aranzábal are dressed in Basque peasant outfits, celebrating the patron saint of San Roque with midday gulps of rioja, slabs of battered cod and thin slices of ham. An accordionist and tambourine player, hired every year by this slowly dwindling circle of elderly friends, play as we sit at a long table under the arches of the postwar town centre.

This year's fiestas are peaceful, untroubled by tensions with Eta supporters or baton charges by twitchy police. "It hasn't always been like that," admits mayor José María Gorroño. "On the opening day I stood on the town hall balcony and just saw thousands of happy people."

Guernica is naturally, comfortably euskera-speaking - typical of the country and fishing towns east of Bilbao. "Long live ETA," scribbled in marker-pen on a noticeboard, is a reminder that these sorts of places were traditional recruiting grounds for the all-but-defeated terrorist group that announced a definitive end to its 40 years of violence last October. Occasional banners on balconies calling for Eta prisoners to be moved to jails nearer to home show where some sympathies lie.

The historic roots of Basque exceptionalism are visible at one of the few spots to survive the bombardments - the provincial parliament. The ancient oak tree where Spanish monarchs once swore to respect local rights dried out a few years ago, though a younger one sprouts hopefully in its place.

The Basque country's special system that allows it to gather tax and send a portion to Madrid, rather than the other away around, is an inheritance - much envied in Catalonia - of those rights.

The town's peace museum displays a telegram from Telesforo Monzón, a Basque politician, sent the day after Hitler's Junkers 52s and Heinkel 111s joined with Savoia 79s sent by Mussolini to drop almost 40 tons of explosives and incendiary bombs. "Today Guernica is nothing more than burning coals and cinder ... It is still burning," it reads.

Guernica's museum, like its hotels and restaurants, is enjoying a peace dividend this year. "There are noticeably more people visiting from other parts of Spain," says the museum's Idoia Orbe.

Fear of Eta violence, and prejudice, used to keep them away, says Gorroño. He represents a new separatist coalition called Bildu that includes some traditional Eta supporters who harbour a visceral hatred for what they call "the Spanish state".

At the town hall Gorroño brings out the Guernica Agreement, signed two years ago, in which leaders of Eta's banned front party finally called for the laying down of arms. "I am proud of that," he says, explaining that his own non-violent Eusko Alkartasuna party, formed 25 years ago, seeks an amicable break with Spain. "My party has always been peaceful."

For the past few decades Guernica has busily been putting the record straight about what really happened on 26 April 1937. "Franco claimed it was burned to the ground by 'separatist reds', but that was a lie," says Gorroño. "Part of what we had to do to begin with was allow historians to tell the true story," says opposition leader Luis Ortúzar as we pass a bust of George Steer, the Times correspondent who alerted the world to the devastating bombardment. The call for the Guernica picture to be moved here from Madrid's Reina Sofía museum is unlikely to be answered; experts say the vast canvas is too delicate has already travelled too much. It has toured Europe twice and went to the US in 1939 to raise funds for civil war refugees. It did not come to Spain until 1981, following Picasso's wishes, when democracy had been restored.

The number of dead from the bombing has been put at up to 1,654. The town's registered population was just 5,630 inhabitants. The fact that the town's arms factories and main bridge were spared shows that civilians were targeted before more obvious military objectives.

William Smallwood, an American author who learned euskera from Basque shepherds in Idaho, has finally published a book of interviews he did secretly in 1970 - when memories were fresher than today but Franco's police ensured tongues were silenced in public. "There was a fear among the people of discussing politics," he writes in The Day Guernica Was Bombed. "Even a total stranger could experience the chilling effect of seeing sullen pairs of the Guardia Civil walking the street."

But while people in Guernica learned to talk about the bombing only after Franco's death in 1975, they soon found themselves battling another sort of silence, this time enforced by Eta, which killed seven people here. "Victims' families had to hide their grief," reads a board in the peace museum. "Society saw them as collateral damage, a lesser form of evil."

"It is great to live the fiestas without the added tension that the violence somehow created," agrees Ortúzar. "I was in a peace group that protested silently whenever someone was killed. Often there was a counter-demonstration. That sort of tension between neighbours in a small town like this can be unbearable."

But this weekend the town is in fancy dress. Glittery suits, Scottish kilts and bearded women compete to raise a laugh. "I'd ask you out, darling, but I bet you are all booked up," a carefully coiffured señora quips to a cross-dressing middle-aged man, as her friends squawk in delight.

Guernica is having fun. As the wounds, recent and past, begin to heal, Basques are relaxing. After years of bloodshed, it is an uplifting thing to see in the town that inspired Picasso.


 

Comments   

We are concerned about a recent drift towards vitriol in the RSN Reader comments section. There is a fine line between moderation and censorship. No one likes a harsh or confrontational forum atmosphere. At the same time everyone wants to be able to express themselves freely. We'll start by encouraging good judgment. If that doesn't work we'll have to ramp up the moderation.

General guidelines: Avoid personal attacks on other forum members; Avoid remarks that are ethnically derogatory; Do not advocate violence, or any illegal activity.

Remember that making the world better begins with responsible action.

- The RSN Team

 
-44 # Mannstein 2012-08-19 18:38
Thank God franco won else Spain would have become a Soviet Socialist Republic.
 
 
+9 # reiverpacific 2012-08-20 07:26
Quoting Mannstein:
Thank God franco won else Spain would have become a Soviet Socialist Republic.

There speaks the voice of the Dulles Bro's, Joe McCarthy, the CIA and Patrick Buchanan (who admired Franco so much) and most American reactionary ignoramuses.
Franco's troop leaders used to collect the heads of people they'd killed and hang them from their horses' pommels and they made liberal use of the Garrotte.
Is that what you admire so much??
Have you ever BEEN to Spain -my favorite country which was still deeply scarred by this "Brother against brother" conflict when I lived there in the 60's and 70's (under Franco), and what Fascist cell are you part of?
 
 
+4 # dkonstruction 2012-08-21 07:18
Spoken like a true fascist but one who clearly knows nothing about the history of the Spanish Civil War. Even fascists such as the Spanish philosopher Jose Ortega Y'Gasset renounced Franco and the spanish fascists when they adopted the slogan "Viva La Morte" (long live death). And, as for Spain becoming a "Soviet Socialist Republic" -- why was it that only the soviets supplied the Spanish Loyalists who were defending a democratically elected government while the US pretended "neutrality" while allowing US oil companies to provide spain (and Nazi Germany) with the oil they needed to carry out the bombing of Guernica? And, if you are so concerned about Spain not becoming a "Soviet Socialist Republic" why are you not on the side of the Spanish Anarchists (the largest anarchist movement in Europe at the time) that were equally anti-fascist and anti-soviet and who valiently fought and died first to protect the republic but more than that to establish a truly just and equalitarian society that was neither western style "free market capitalism" nor soviet-style "state capitalism" (to believe that the Soviet Union was socialist is to show complete ignorance of what socialism is which at the very least implies "workers control of the means of production." Essentially, you are saying better fascism than defending a democratically elected "socialist" government. this is why we must be ever vigilant in our fight against fascists including the current variety such as yourself.
 
 
0 # shraeve 2012-08-21 20:29
So it became a fascist state instead. Big improvement.
 
 
+6 # carurosu 2012-08-19 20:00
what price your Hiroshima bombing in 45?
 
 
+7 # L H 2012-08-19 22:36
I would like to read William Smallwood's book, "The Day Guernica Was Bombed" and see the real photos of Doris Maar. I'd rather see real pictures since Picasso's art does not speak to me. The Basques are amazing in their ability to endure. Basque-land is the home of Mondragon, the biggest worker-owned corporation in the world begun in the 50's when their economy was collapsing. We should learn from the Basques. The world needs what they have learned, especially the cooperative and peaceful part!
 
 
-3 # JDM 2012-08-20 03:25
Do you really believe ANY part of the relative independence of the Basques from monolingual Spain would have come without ETA? Evidently, yes - so ur an idiot as well as a fascist.
 
 
+4 # Glen 2012-08-20 07:19
JDM, surely you have researched the Eta and the evolution of their "cause". It is never as simple as your declaring Eta is the sole reason for progress. Citizens must also strive for reason and independence.

Eta morphed into something pretty nasty.
 
 
+7 # bobob 2012-08-20 06:49
@mannstein:
It's so hard to respond to a "mind" like yours. That kind of drivvel has propelled America the Beautiful into a warmongering poison, supporting brutal dictators worldwide over generations, for fear the monied classes would have to give something to the people. Luckily, you and your kind are on the way out.
 
 
+2 # chomper2 2012-08-20 11:51
Luckily, you and your kind are on the way out.

Alas, if only it were so.
 
 
-4 # Glen 2012-08-20 07:21
The destruction of this town, as so many others, should serve as a reminder of what can actually happen, and often, very much worse.

Those calling for revolution in the U.S. would be well served to do some research and include every town and city firebombed at any time in history and then decide whether or not they savor the idea of revolution.
 
 
+4 # dkonstruction 2012-08-21 07:59
Glen,

Guernica was bombed by fascists who were trying to overthrow a democratically elected government by force so what's this got to do with whether we are "calling for revolution in the U.S."?

The real question is why did the US not support a democratically elected
Spanish government (despite their pleas for help) and pretend instead that it was "neutral" when in fact it did nothing to stop US oil companies such as Texico from supplying the fascists with the fuel they needed to power their war machine?

Hitler and Mussolini used Spain as their testing ground and the lesson they learned was that the "democratic" countries would do nothing to stop them. Do you really believe that had we done the right thing and defended the democratically elected government of Spain and defeated the fascists (as they surely would have been with outside support for the Spanish gov't) that the German and Italian fascists would have been so emboldened?

Perhaps it is you that needs to do alot more research about the history of fascism and the complicity of the capitalist democracies in its rise to power.

As for "calling for revolution" in the U.S....did not Ghandhi call for revolution? What about Vaclav Havel? Was Martin Luther King Jr's vision for America not revolutionary? How about the American Revolution or the Haitian revolution that overthrew slavery or the revolution in South Africa that overthrew Apartheid?
 
 
+1 # Glen 2012-08-23 04:16
One more time: Many in the U.S. are calling for VIOLENT revolution, not a peaceful protest type effort to make change. Violent revolution is what I was referring to in an effort to yank folks into the reality, as I said, of death and destruction.

Comparing a revolutionary effort today with those of the past, and in other countries does not fly. The U.S. is powerful, with a powerful military and local policing. There is a population as diverse as any country on the planet, and over 300 million of them. You can't even compare a revolution today with the War Between the States, but do consider the loss of life in that war and how the scars remain after 150 years.

There are citizens in the U.S. who would be willing to sacrifice the lives of thousands of good people for their violent need for revolution. Where is this revolution going to play out?

Also as I have said, there are other means of rebelling, without all out war. Time to be clever and creative. Never think EVER that the wealthy, the corporations, or those who support them will put up with even a sniff of violent overthrow.

Two more things: what will you replace the present system with? How will you organize 300 million people?
 
 
0 # shraeve 2012-08-21 20:38
It will depend on what our other options are.
 
 
0 # shraeve 2012-08-21 20:44
The revolutionaries were the Nationalists, mainly the Falange. They won. So the lesson is that revolution can succeed, at least if you have powerful friends to help you.
 
 
+1 # dkonstruction 2012-08-22 05:13
Quoting shraeve:
The revolutionaries were the Nationalists, mainly the Falange. They won. So the lesson is that revolution can succeed, at least if you have powerful friends to help you.


the fascists were not the revolutionaries . They were the counter-revolut ionaries hell bent on overthrowing a democratically elected "socialist" government. The only "revolutionarie s" in Spain were the anarchists...Th ere were many "good" rank and file communinists but ultimately, the Soviet Union through the Comintern sabotaged their efforts (and the entire anti-fascist effort in Spain) and particularly those of the anarchists...An d, while most of the "International Brigade" volunteers weren't "revolutionarie s" in the strict sense in that they went to spain to defend the democratically elected government most had revolutionary aims in that they were communists and believed in replacing the entire capitalist order though they were clearly snookered by the Soviets and most had no idea of the reality of Stalin or Soviet-style state capitalism until Kruschev's speech in 1957 where most of the rank and file began to learn some of the truth.

To refer to the fascists as revolutionaries is to misunderstand their relationship with their own ruling class and ignore the fact that once in power they did little to nothing to do anything against the interests of capital as a whole.
 
 
0 # Glen 2012-08-23 04:17
Who would assist in an American revolution? Seriously. Yep, maybe another country that would enjoy ruling this nation.
 
 
+6 # reiverpacific 2012-08-20 07:52
When I first lived in Spain in the 1960's and 70's, the scars of the Civil War were still deeply etched on elders who endured that era, in which Franco brutally took the country from the possibility of democracy to the new dark ages dominated by hooded catholic monks, the army and a nepotistic, inbred and inefficient government made up of huge landowners, the hereditary monarch and the military (sound familiar in the Fragmented States these days).
I remember kinda freakin' out when I witnessed up close, as a British youth born at the end of WW11, my first parade along Barcelona's Ramblas de Cataluña, Franco's troops wearing Nazi helmets and goose-stepping to a solemn, heavy drum beat.
I loved the people, the country and the different regional cultures and foods but was always aware of the omnipresence of the Guardia Civil, machine guns slung around their shoulders in the main cities.
I'd took money from Amnesty International in Edinburgh to some of Franco's just-released political prisoner and listened to many tearful tales of violence and torture.
There was brutality on both sides but the utterly ruthless quality of Franco's lasting suppression of anything even hinting of progressive resistance, left the people with no choice. ETA was simply a reaction to this.
You really have to go to Spain to get the flavor of it.
I was also a member of the Basque club in Boise, Idaho and had some wonderful times with these strong, proud people.
 
 
+2 # Glen 2012-08-20 10:27
Quite right, reiver. It is not a simple matter to judge the history of a country without some sort of first hand experience and face to face discussion.

I remember my first trip to Greece and Europe, witnessing much what you saw in Spain, as far as guns on patrol, pockmarked cement still standing after the war. Cops in parts of Europe still carried weapons over their shoulders in the '90's.

Eta was organized much as Hizbollah and other organizations, in resistance to some powerful forces. If not kept organized with a specific cause, though, some organizations can become pretty vicious themselves.

War leaves scars. Forever.
 

THE NEW STREAMLINED RSN LOGIN PROCESS: Register once, then login and you are ready to comment. All you need is a Username and a Password of your choosing and you are free to comment whenever you like! Welcome to the Reader Supported News community.

RSNRSN